Understanding Electric Field Addition for Opposite Charges

5 replies · 5K views · last reply
keyfob
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
I'm a little confused on how the math is supposed to work out when you are adding an electric field from charges with opposite signs. Looking at the image, both of these situations should yield equivalent electric fields at that point right? I get the right answer for when the situation involves two identical charges, but when the charges are opposite i have an extra negative coefficient from the -q which messes up my calculations. I think the problem is that when I draw triangles to try and split up the components that perhaps my Y should be positive for the -q charge, but I'm not sure if/why that should be the case. Otherwise I'm not really sure what I'm doing wrong...any help would be appreciated.
 
Attachments
  • Two side-by-side diagrams of electric field vectors at a point, with charges labeled q and q on the left and q and -q on the right, plus right-triangle component sketches labeled x, -y and -x.
    electric field.png
    2.8 KB · Views: 541
Welcome to PF!

Hi keyfob! Welcome to PF! :smile:
keyfob said:
… I think the problem is that when I draw triangles to try and split up the components that perhaps my Y should be positive for the -q charge, but I'm not sure if/why that should be the case. Otherwise I'm not really sure what I'm doing wrong...any help would be appreciated.

You seem to be having drawing problems …

just draw the "second" side of the triangle the other way, so that the internal angle is 180º minus the original angle. :wink:
 
Thanks for the help, I'm still a little confused though... I attached an updated picture to this post, is this what you meant? Thanks again
 
Attachments
  • Three-panel hand-drawn sketch of electric field vector addition: charges q and q, then q and -q above a horizontal line, with field arrows and angle marks, and right-triangle component diagrams labelled -x and -y, followed by a right-pointing arrow to a simplified panel.
    electric field.png
    14.3 KB · Views: 609
I don't understand … what are the 6 triangles at the bottom?