Discussion Overview
The discussion centers on the electron binding energy for multi-electron atoms, specifically seeking information on the energy required to separate all atomic electrons from the nucleus. Participants express interest in both general binding energy data and specific values for excited atomic states, such as for the Li3 atom.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Homework-related
Main Points Raised
- One participant seeks references for the total binding energy of multi-electron atoms, noting that ionization energy is easier to find.
- Another participant provides a link to the x-ray data booklet, which contains binding energies but notes that these are relative to different reference levels.
- A participant expresses a preference for binding energy data relative to a fully ionized nucleus and questions the availability of such information.
- One suggestion involves using Density Functional Theory for total-energy calculations to derive ionization and excitation energies.
- A participant mentions using "The Elements" by John Emsley but encounters difficulties in matching isotopes with binding energy data.
- Another participant references Webelements for ionization energies of elements up to Argon.
- One participant requests atomic radius data for isotopes and ions, expressing concern about the availability of such information in the forum.
- Another participant suggests that while atomic radii can be found, comprehensive data for all isotopes and ions may be challenging to obtain.
- A participant notes discrepancies between atomic radii data from Emsley and university websites, indicating a preference for Emsley's results.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express varying degrees of uncertainty regarding the availability and reliability of binding energy and atomic radius data. Multiple competing views exist on the sources and methods for obtaining this information, and no consensus is reached on the best approach or source.
Contextual Notes
Participants highlight limitations in accessing reliable data, particularly regarding isotopes and the context of binding energies. There is also mention of the challenges posed by the cost of academic resources and the availability of information online.
Who May Find This Useful
This discussion may be useful for researchers, students, or hobbyists interested in atomic physics, particularly those focused on electron binding energies, atomic radii, and the challenges of sourcing reliable data in these areas.