Using Normal Force on inclined plane vs banked curve

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
1 reply · 4K views
Rick4
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
On an inclined plane, "[tex]\Sigma[/tex]Fy = N - mg cos ø = ma = 0".
And "[tex]\Sigma[/tex]Fx = mg sin ø = ma" (frictionless).
So, in the y direction, "N = mg cos ø".


But on a banked curve, "[tex]\Sigma[/tex]Fy = N cos ø - mg = ma= 0".
And "[tex]\Sigma[/tex]Fx = N sin ø = ma = mv²/r" (frictionless).
So, in the y direction, "N cos ø = mg".
I know how to get "tan ø = v²/rg".
The two free body diagrams look identical to me so why doesn't "N = mg cos ø" (from inclined plane) work to get "tan ø = v²/rg"?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
On a banked curve, circular motion is normally involved and so there is an extra centrifugal force. I don't see the problem except you've neglected to take that into account on the free body diagram.