Vectors Thinking Question: Proving Perpendicularity using the Cosine Law

  • Thread starter Thread starter DespicableMe
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Thinking Vectors
Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
3 replies · 2K views
DespicableMe
Messages
40
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



a) Write the cosine law using a vector operation.
b) If |vector a - vector b| = |vector a + vector b|, prove that a is perpendicular to b using the formula you found in a).

The Attempt at a Solution



The red period represents the dot product

a) magnitude c = SQUAREROOT (a.a + b.b - 2(a.b) )

b) magnitude c = SQUAREROOT (a.a + b.b - 2(a.b) )

= SQUAREROOT ( a2 + b2 - 2( |a||b|cos 90 )
= SQUAREROOT ( a2 + b2 )

And this is the Pythagorean theorem, which only applies for right angle triangles, so if mag. C is SQUARERT (a2+b2), then a and b are perpendicular.

DId I do this correctly?

I didn't know how to include |vector a - vector b| = |vector a + vector b| into the equation and it only asked to prove it using the formula that I found...
 
Physics news on Phys.org
DespicableMe said:

Homework Statement



a) Write the cosine law using a vector operation.
b) If |vector a - vector b| = |vector a + vector b|, prove that a is perpendicular to b using the formula you found in a).

The Attempt at a Solution



The red period represents the dot product

a) magnitude c = SQUAREROOT (a.a + b.b - 2(a.b) )

b) magnitude c = SQUAREROOT (a.a + b.b - 2(a.b) )

= SQUAREROOT ( a2 + b2 - 2( |a||b|cos 90 )
= SQUAREROOT ( a2 + b2 )

And this is the Pythagorean theorem, which only applies for right angle triangles, so if mag. C is SQUARERT (a2+b2), then a and b are perpendicular.

DId I do this correctly?

I didn't know how to include |vector a - vector b| = |vector a + vector b| into the equation and it only asked to prove it using the formula that I found...

The b part isn't correct. You need to start by assuming that |a - b| = |a + b|, and showing that it follows that a and b are perpendicular.

You could start by assigning coordinates to a and b, such as a = <a1, a2> and b = <b1, b2>.
 
Mark44 said:
The b part isn't correct. You need to start by assuming that |a - b| = |a + b|, and showing that it follows that a and b are perpendicular.

You could start by assigning coordinates to a and b, such as a = <a1, a2> and b = <b1, b2>.

I'm still kind of...
What can I do with the coordinates?

At one point, I did draw vector diagrams to show|a - b| = |a + b| but other than that, I didn't know how to use that in the equation.
 
Start by writing out the magnitudes using the definition of magnitude. Of course, it would be easier if you squared both sides first.