Volume work, absolute and relative pressure confusion

2 replies · 3K views · last reply
kandelabr
Messages
110
Reaction score
0
hello.

i can't figure out where I'm wrong. this is the problem:

we have a cylinder, closed with a piston. the absolute pressure inside the cylinder is p0, atmospheric pressure is patm. the air inside expands isothermally to some (specific) volume vend.
i derived the equation for isothermal work directly from this one: dW = F(s)ds.

here it is (sorry for handwriting... uses less time :eek: (will learn TeX one day... :smile:)):
Handwritten derivation with a sketch of a cylinder and piston holding gas at p0 over length s0, with force F(s) and area A. Equations: W = integral from a to b of F(s)ds, F(s) = A·p(s), p(s) = p0·s0/s, and W = p0·v0·ln(v_end/v0).


the final equation seems just fine, but you've probably noticed the big fat asterisk. here's why:
p0 is absolute pressure and it exerts F(s0) on the piston. but there is also patm, which does negative work equal to patm * A * (send - s0). this fact hasn't been taken into account anywhere.

where am i wrong (the thermodynamics probably isn't wrong, right? :) )
 
What you are calculating is the work done by the gas on the piston, not the net work done on the piston. The gas is not subjected to atmospheric pressure--it's contained in the cylinder.
 
oh, i get it.
but if now i want to know how much work i can get from this piston, i need to include atmospheric pressure.