- #1
Viper
- 54
- 0
Ok what's better and why?
Wars vs Trek: Choosing the Ultimate Sci-Fi Franchise
- Thread starter Viper
- Start date
Click For Summary
Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the comparison between the Star Wars and Star Trek franchises, focusing on personal preferences, perceived qualities, and cultural impacts. Participants express their opinions on various aspects of both franchises, including character appeal, thematic depth, and entertainment value.
Discussion Character
- Debate/contested
- Exploratory
Main Points Raised
- Some participants express a preference for Star Trek, citing its moral and ethical dilemmas as more valuable than those in Star Wars.
- Others argue that Star Wars is more entertaining despite its perceived lack of scientific consistency, with some preferring its characters and aesthetics.
- A participant mentions that Star Wars has suffered due to the quality of its later episodes, specifically referencing episodes one and two.
- Some participants acknowledge that both franchises have their strengths and weaknesses, with no clear consensus on which is superior.
- One participant humorously states a dislike for both franchises but enjoys the community surrounding Star Trek fans.
- There are playful exchanges about the difficulty of choosing between the two franchises, with suggestions of other shows like "Lost in Space" and "Stargate SG-1."
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants do not reach a consensus on which franchise is better, with multiple competing views and personal preferences expressed throughout the discussion.
Contextual Notes
Some arguments rely on subjective interpretations of entertainment value and thematic depth, which may vary widely among participants. The discussion includes humor and light-hearted banter, indicating a casual tone rather than a rigorous debate.
Who May Find This Useful
Fans of science fiction franchises, particularly those interested in the cultural impact and thematic discussions surrounding Star Wars and Star Trek.
- #2
Viper
- 54
- 0
I voted trek for seven of nine (sorid rant edited out.)
- #3
Andy
- 73
- 14
I voted for trek because it just better! I can't explain why i voted for it other than that i prefer to watch Star Trek.
- #4
Mentat
- 3,935
- 3
I only picked Star Wars because it never claimed to be scientifically consistent - while it was implied in Star Trek that it was - and neither of them (Wars or Trek) are.
- #5
Raavin
- 86
- 0
Apples and oranges but I'd have to say Trek. If you ignore the really ridiculous stuff you can almost pretend that it's real.
Raavin
Raavin
- #6
mouseman
Look at my avatar and you know my answer. Luke would pummel Kirk to bloody goo. And Light sabers are cooler than phasers. And besides, what kind of alien civilization would name their planet X-2347R?!
- #7
kyleb
i voted for trek, mostly the old stuff. i know most of it was ripped from classic literature but i still appreciate the moral and ethical situations portrayed in them more than star wars which i find to be of less value in that sense.
- #8
Viper
- 54
- 0
Star wars is cool but I feel episodes one and two have dampened down the flame a bit, they were a bit crap. Jar JAR STEPPING IN CRAP, WHY?
- #9
ottjes
- 21
- 0
Trek
just because i like it more
just because i like it more
- #10
BoulderHead
I liked Star Trek more. Star Wars is good and has better special effects but only comes in second place.
- #11
quantum
- 33
- 0
I made the same thread in PF 2.0... It eventually ended up in a very large debate resulting in no conclusion. However, I voted StarTrek
- #12
climbhi
I voted star trek, but not because I like it. I hate them both, but treky nerds are really funny to laugh at so it really makes my day sometimes.
- #13
drag
Science Advisor
- 1,097
- 1
Hey !
That's not fair !
I can't choose between ST and SW !
That's not fair !
I can't choose between ST and SW !
- #14
BoulderHead
Maybe we should choose Lost in Space my green princely friend.
- #15
drag
Science Advisor
- 1,097
- 1
Oh NOOOOOOOO !
The HORROR !
I can't rule-out that show either !
P.S. Weren't I the black or red one ?
P.P.S. Who was in Dr. Smith's discise ?
- #16
BoulderHead
I remember the fear I felt when they first encountered this dude;
http://home.pacbell.net/thoemke1/robby-the-robot/lis-15.html
Fortunately the robot had a trusty old hammer to fix the problem;
http://home.pacbell.net/thoemke1/robby-the-robot/lis-03.html
http://home.pacbell.net/thoemke1/robby-the-robot/lis-15.html
Fortunately the robot had a trusty old hammer to fix the problem;
http://home.pacbell.net/thoemke1/robby-the-robot/lis-03.html
Last edited by a moderator:
- #17
Viper
- 54
- 0
Or stargate sg1
Similar threads
- · Replies 21 ·
- · Replies 7 ·
- · Replies 13 ·
- · Replies 55 ·
- · Replies 17 ·
- Poll
Writing: Input Wanted
Designing the Nuclear-Fusion Reactor for my Generation Ship
- · Replies 12 ·