Weight vs Water Resistance: Comparing Exercise Challenges

  • Thread starter uknowho
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Weight
In summary, the conversation discussed the difficulty in determining an exact equivalence between carrying weight and swimming in a pool of water due to the different forces acting against the body in each scenario. While there may be studies on simulating swimming conditions using weights, it is not a direct connection and would require trial and error due to various variables.
  • #1
uknowho
2
0
How much weight would I have to carry to equal the resistance I would face swimming in a pool of water? Let's assume I am wearing the same clothing to perform both events.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I don't see how you can get a very exact equivalence since the forces acting against you would be different, and I think that holds even if you were able to distribute the weight evenly around your body. The water resists your movement in whatever direction you move against it whereas gravity only acts downward.
 
  • #3
Agreed. It's apples and oranges. There might be some studies done on ways of simulating swimming conditions using weights, but it won't be a direct connection, like a formula, it will be a trial and error thing. And very dependent on variables.
 

Related to Weight vs Water Resistance: Comparing Exercise Challenges

1. What is the difference between weight and water resistance when it comes to exercise challenges?

Weight and water resistance are two different types of resistance that can be used in exercise challenges. Weight resistance involves using external objects, such as dumbbells or resistance bands, to create resistance against your muscles. On the other hand, water resistance involves moving through water, either in a pool or with specialized equipment, to create resistance against your muscles.

2. Which type of resistance is more effective for building muscle?

Both weight and water resistance can be effective for building muscle, but they target different muscle groups. Weight resistance tends to target specific muscles, allowing for more isolated and targeted muscle growth. Water resistance, on the other hand, engages multiple muscle groups at once, leading to overall muscle development.

3. Can weight resistance and water resistance be used together in an exercise challenge?

Yes, weight resistance and water resistance can be combined in an exercise challenge for a more comprehensive workout. For example, using weights while performing water exercises can increase the challenge and intensity of the workout. Additionally, many workout programs incorporate both types of resistance to target different muscle groups and provide a well-rounded workout.

4. Which type of resistance is better for cardiovascular exercise?

Both weight and water resistance can be used for cardiovascular exercise, but water resistance tends to be more effective. Moving through water requires more effort and energy, leading to an increase in heart rate and improved cardiovascular health. Additionally, water resistance is low-impact and easier on the joints compared to weight resistance.

5. Is one type of resistance better for weight loss than the other?

Both weight and water resistance can be effective for weight loss, as they both require physical effort and can burn calories. However, weight resistance may be more effective for targeted fat loss in specific areas, while water resistance can provide a full-body workout and help with overall weight loss. Ultimately, the most effective type of resistance for weight loss will depend on individual goals and preferences.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
895
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
27
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • Mechanics
Replies
1
Views
4K
Back
Top