What is the definition of a function being spherically symmetric?

  • Thread starter Taylor_1989
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Symmetric
In summary, the conversation is about a question regarding converting a function to spherical coordinates and determining its spherical symmetry. The first part of the question (a) involves simplifying the function to log(r^2)=2log(r). The second part (b) asks for help in understanding the concept of spherical symmetry and how to determine it. The conversation also includes a discussion about the definition of spherical symmetry and how it relates to the given function.
  • #1
Taylor_1989
402
14

Homework Statement


Hi guys, having problem trying to understand what this question wants.

upload_2017-3-11_23-50-0.png

the question I am stuck with is 7.3.

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


So for a) I converted to spherical co-ordinates:
##log(r^2sin^\theta cos^2\phi+r^2sin^2\theta sin^2\phi+r^2 cos^2\theta)## which simplifies to ##log(r^2)=2log(r)##
is this correct?

for b) I am not quite sure what it wants. Could someone please advise. Thanks in advance
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Taylor_1989 said:
is this correct?
You forgot the 1 inside the log argument.
Taylor_1989 said:
b) I am not quite sure what it wants. Could someone please advise.
You can try calculating its gradient ##\nabla f(r)## and then the directional derivative in an arbitrary direction perpendicular to the radial unit vector ##\hat r##.
 
  • #3
@Taylor_1989 : What is your definition of a function being spherically symmetric?
 
  • #4
@LCKurtz Well looking at the above function, wid the 1 in. It will have to go from the center of the axis because the way i see it each side about the center will have the same volume, but if you say move it to the left one side will have a larger volume that the other.
 
  • #5
LCKurtz said:
@Taylor_1989 : What is your definition of a function being spherically symmetric?

Taylor_1989 said:
@LCKurtz Well looking at the above function, wid the 1 in. It will have to go from the center of the axis because the way i see it each side about the center will have the same volume, but if you say move it to the left one side will have a larger volume that the other.

You were asked to show a certain function is spherically symmetric. How can you expect to do that if you don't know what being spherically symmetric is? That should have been included in the homework template under "relevant equations", which you left blank. Look in your text, find the definition, and quote it here. Then we might be able to help you.
 
  • Like
Likes SammyS
Back
Top