What is the equivalent resistance between points a and b in the figure

  • Thread starter Thread starter smoics
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Resistance
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating the equivalent resistance between points a and b in a circuit with multiple resistors. Participants clarify that resistors in series add up, while those in parallel require the formula 1/(1/R + 1/R...). A common mistake identified is treating resistors in series as if they were in parallel, leading to an incorrect total resistance calculation. It is emphasized that a wire shorting a resistor effectively removes it from the circuit, as it provides a path of zero resistance. The correct equivalent resistance is confirmed to be 7 ohms after proper analysis.
smoics
Messages
28
Reaction score
0
circuits--equivalent resistance

Homework Statement


What is the equivalent resistance between points a and b in the figure ?


Homework Equations


Resistors in series add up, resistors in parallel are 1/(1/R + 1/R...)


The Attempt at a Solution


I tried 1/(1/16 + 1/12 + 1/4) + 5, but I get 7.5 and the answer is 7 ohms...where did I go astray?
 

Attachments

  • physics2.jpg
    physics2.jpg
    4.2 KB · Views: 445
Physics news on Phys.org


smoics said:

Homework Statement


What is the equivalent resistance between points a and b in the figure ?


Homework Equations


Resistors in series add up, resistors in parallel are 1/(1/R + 1/R...)


The Attempt at a Solution


I tried 1/(1/16 + 1/12 + 1/4) + 5, but I get 7.5 and the answer is 7 ohms...where did I go astray?

It's a 6 Ohm resistor in the figure, and 16 Ohms in your calculation...
 


Why wouldn't you add the 6+10=16? Because they're in series and the rest are in parallel...Yet when I add them all up as if they are in parallel, plus the "Extra" 5, I get the correct answer...
 


smoics said:
Why wouldn't you add the 6+10=16? Because they're in series and the rest are in parallel...Yet when I add them all up as if they are in parallel, plus the "Extra" 5, I get the correct answer...

The 6, 12 and 4 Ohm resistors are in parallel. See how they all are connected at their tops with solid wire lines? And the same for their bottoms -- all connected with solid wire lines.

And as for the 10 Ohm resistor -- can you see how there is a solid wire line all the way from its top to its bottom? What is the parrallel combination of a resistor and a wire...?
 


So it takes the path of least resistance, which is NOT through the 10 ohm resistor?
 


smoics said:
So it takes the path of least resistance, which is NOT through the 10 ohm resistor?

Correct-amundo. When you short out a resistor with a wire, you get zero Ohms (for ideal wire -- for real wire, it's still close to zero Ohms).


EDIT -- So do you get the right answer now?
 


Yes--merci beaucoup!
 
Back
Top