What is the power of suggestion in the placebo effect?

  • Thread starter Thread starter matthyaouw
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion explores the concept of the placebo effect through a humorous exchange about a student mistaking water for acid, leading to a burning sensation. It highlights that while the placebo effect involves symptom alleviation through suggestion, the scenario presented is more about self-hypnosis or mind control rather than a true placebo response. Participants share personal anecdotes related to food aversions and how knowledge of ingredients can trigger strong reactions, illustrating the power of suggestion in everyday experiences. The conversation blends humor with insights into psychological responses to suggestion. Overall, the thread emphasizes the complexities of perception and belief in influencing physical sensations.
matthyaouw
Gold Member
Messages
1,125
Reaction score
5
I was in the lab yesterday testing some soil samples when I had this exchange with another student:
"I spilled some of that acid on myself a minute ago, and it's kinda starting to burn now." he says, pointing to a bottle on the desk next to him.
"That's water." says I.
"oh..."

:biggrin:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Does he speak strange languages, lift incredibly heavy weights? Does he have mysterious symbols or words on his skin? Does he swear a lot and he is lustful towards inappropriate or reluctant partners? Does he listen to Ozzy Osbourne music?

He could be possessed by the Devil, which would explain the burning sensation he felt when exposed to water.
 
That's not really an example of the placebo effect:

Placebo effect - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Address:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Placebo_effect

which involves a cure or allieviation of symptoms. I think it might just be an example of self-hypnosis, but something tells me there's a better term.
 
zoobyshoe said:
That's not really an example of the placebo effect:
Well, if you consider the fact that the liquid was sulfuric acid, matthyaouw's suggestion that it was only water would be an example of mind control equal to a placebo effect. :biggrin:
 
Evo said:
Well, if you consider the fact that the liquid was sulfuric acid, matthyaouw's suggestion that it was only water would be an example of mind control equal to a placebo effect. :biggrin:
Yes, he is clearly some sort of Shao Lin monk.
 
this reminds me of one time, where someone offered me a pretzel. I ate it, sort of liked it, and asked what flavor it was. they said mustard and I started gagging

(I h8 mustard)
 
^
It's the funniest thing when that happens. My mother once had a cow-tongue burrito and loved it, thought it was the greatest burrito she'd ever eaten. As soon as she found out what it was, she nearly retroactively vomited.
 
yomamma said:
this reminds me of one time, where someone offered me a pretzel. I ate it, sort of liked it, and asked what flavor it was. they said mustard and I started gagging

(I h8 mustard)
Ahh, so George Bush isn't the only one.
 
Back
Top