What is the probability that candidate A wins the election?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Inertialforce
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Probability
Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
8 replies · 4K views
Inertialforce
Messages
67
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


In an election there are three candidates. Candidate A is twice as likely to win than candidate B and candidate B is twice as likely to win than candidate C.

What is the probability that candidate A wins the election?

Note: The answer is 4/7

The Attempt at a Solution



Could someone explain to me why the answer is 4/7 I don't really understand why it is the answer?
 
on Phys.org


Inertialforce said:

Homework Statement


In an election there are three candidates. Candidate A is twice as likely to win than candidate B and candidate B is twice as likely to win than candidate C.

What is the probability that candidate A wins the election?

Note: The answer is 4/7


The Attempt at a Solution



Could someone explain to me why the answer is 4/7 I don't really understand why it is the answer?

First write out all the givens, then realize that P(A) + P(B) + P(C) = 1
 


Inertialforce said:

Homework Statement


In an election there are three candidates. Candidate A is twice as likely to win than candidate B and candidate B is twice as likely to win than candidate C.

What is the probability that candidate A wins the election?

Note: The answer is 4/7


The Attempt at a Solution



Could someone explain to me why the answer is 4/7 I don't really understand why it is the answer?

A = 2B
B = 2C
C = 1 - (A + B)

Can you take it from here?

k
 


say that C =5
Then B=
 
Last edited:


Although giving a solution helps some, the socratic method helps more I believe. Ask guiding questions, then see their response instead of just solving the problem. Just my .02
 


alennix21 said:
say that C =5
Then B=

You can't say that "C= 5", C is a person, not a number.

(If you were to use C to mean the probability that candidate C wins, it still can't be 5: a probability must be between 0 and 1.)
 


alennix21 said:
say that C =5
Then B=
That's not quite the correct approach. Instead, denote a particular candidate probability of winning as P, and note that one of them will definitely win the election. So that means that the individual probabilities of candidates A,B,C must sum to 1. The statement of the problem let's you relate the individual probabilities of the other two candidates to the designated one whom has probability P of winning.
 


A=2B
B=2C

The probability equals: [tex]\frac{one event}{the whole number of events}[/tex]

So it should be [tex]\frac{A}{A+B+C}[/tex]

B=A/2
C=B/2 or C=A/4

Here is the result:

[tex]\frac{A}{A+A/2+A/4}[/tex]

Can you continue from now on?

Regards.
 


I was thinking; to say C=5 then B=
is a concrete way of seeing the problem as a bag of marbles probelm.