When Do Sand Particles Slip Off a Vibrating Plate?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the conditions under which dry grains of sand lose contact with a vibrating metal plate oscillating with simple harmonic motion. As the plate's amplitude increases, the grains begin to lose contact when the plate's acceleration exceeds gravitational acceleration (g). The necessary condition for this loss of contact is that the normal force between the plate and the grains becomes zero. Participants explore how to calculate the normal force and the maximum amplitude (D) at which the sand particles remain in contact. Ultimately, it is concluded that the plate's acceleration must be greater than g at maximum displacement for the grains to lose contact.
heroslayer99
Messages
33
Reaction score
6
Homework Statement
What is the max amplitude before the sand particles slip off?
Relevant Equations
a = -w^2 x
A horizontal metal plate connected to a vibration generator is oscillating vertically with simple
harmonic motion of period 0.080 s and amplitude 1.2 mm. There are dry grains of sand on the
plate. The frequency of the vibrating plate is kept constant and its amplitude is slowly increased
from zero. The grains of sand start to lose contact with the plate when the amplitude is
D. State and explain the necessary conditions when the grains of sand first lose contact
with the plate. Hence calculate the value of D.I have calculated that the acceleration of the plate is -(2pi x 1/(0.08))^2 (x) but I do not know where to go from here, any reading material / hints will be very helpful.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What is the acceleration of a grain just as it loses contact?
 
haruspex said:
What is the acceleration of a grain just as it loses contact?
This seems like the typical problem that contains the condition "loses contact" which physicomathematically is being translated to "The normal force from the plate to the grain becomes zero"?
 
Delta2 said:
This seems like the typical problem that contains the condition "loses contact" which physicomathematically is being translated to "The normal force from the plate to the grain becomes zero"?
How am I meant to calculate the normal force
 
haruspex said:
What is the acceleration of a grain just as it loses contact?
I dont know :(
 
heroslayer99 said:
I dont know :(
What will be its acceleration after losing contact then?
 
heroslayer99 said:
How am I meant to calculate the normal force
You don't find some bizarre formula for Normal force, you just do newton's 2nd law for a grain and then set normal force to zero and see how the equation simplifies.
 
heroslayer99 said:
Homework Statement: What is the max amplitude before the sand particles slip off?
Relevant Equations: a = -w^2 x

A horizontal metal plate connected to a vibration generator is oscillating vertically with simple
harmonic motion of period 0.080 s and amplitude 1.2 mm. There are dry grains of sand on the
plate. The frequency of the vibrating plate is kept constant and its amplitude is slowly increased
from zero. The grains of sand start to lose contact with the plate when the amplitude is
D. State and explain the necessary conditions when the grains of sand first lose contact
with the plate. Hence calculate the value of D.I have calculated that the acceleration of the plate is -(2pi x 1/(0.08))^2 (x) but I do not know where to go from here, any reading material / hints will be very helpful.

If the plate is moving vertically, what force would cause the sand particles to move horizontally across the plate to fall off?

(or did you misread the problem?) :wink:

EDIT -- or did you mean "lose contact" with the plate, instead of "slip off"? I can use my Mentor powers to see from your location that there should be no language translation issues... :smile:
 
berkeman said:
If the plate is moving vertically, what force would cause the sand particles to move horizontally across the plate to fall off?
I assure you that they would indeed start to drift off the plate. Bouncing around will lead to some rotational, and hence horizontal, motion.
 
  • #10
heroslayer99 said:
Relevant Equations: a = -w^2 x
What is value of ##x## when the acceleration has its largest magnitude?
 
  • #11
I think the problem wants us to focus on the vertical oscillation of the grains, together with the plate, and not in some sort of Brownian horizontal motion that the grains might do and slip off the plate.
 
  • #12
Delta2 said:
I think the problem wants us to focus on the vertical oscillation of the grains, together with the plate, and not in some sort of Brownian horizontal motion that the grains might do and slip off the plate.
Sure, but the title is not inappropriate.
 
  • #13
haruspex said:
Sure, but the title is not inappropriate.
I think he misinterpreted the statement of the problem, and in the thread title he put something according to his misinterpretation. Probably the exact wording of the problem doesn't contain the words slip off. And it doesn't seem to , if we take the exact wording of the problem to be what is in the paragraph following the relevant equations statement.
 
  • #14
Apologies for any confusion I have caused, I figured out that the acceleration of the sand particles when they lose contact is g, and hence the plate's acceleration must be greater than g, when it is at its max vertical displacement
 
  • Like
Likes Herman Trivilino, haruspex and Delta2

Similar threads

Replies
8
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
22
Views
3K
Replies
12
Views
2K
Back
Top