Where Does the Missing Energy Go When Capacitors are Connected in Parallel?

  • Thread starter Thread starter asifshaik
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Capacitors Energy
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers on the energy dissipation when two identical capacitors, each with capacitance C, are connected in parallel. Initially, one capacitor holds energy calculated as 1/2*C*V^2, while the other holds none. Upon connection, the total capacitance becomes 2C, and the voltage across the combination drops to V/2, resulting in a new energy storage of 1/4*C*V^2. The missing energy is attributed to electrical heating losses in the connecting wires, as well as potential losses from arcing and electromagnetic radiation during the momentary current flow.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of capacitor fundamentals, including capacitance and energy storage.
  • Knowledge of electrical current flow and its effects in circuits.
  • Familiarity with energy dissipation concepts, particularly in resistive components.
  • Basic grasp of electromagnetic theory related to radiation and arcing.
NEXT STEPS
  • Research the principles of energy dissipation in resistive circuits.
  • Learn about the thermal effects of current flow in conductors.
  • Explore the concept of arcing in electrical connections and its implications.
  • Study the relationship between current, voltage, and energy in capacitor circuits.
USEFUL FOR

Electrical engineers, physics students, and anyone interested in understanding energy dynamics in capacitor circuits and electrical systems.

asifshaik
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
hi, this is a basic conceptual question.
Assume two identical capacitors of capacitance C without any leakage. potential difference across one capacitor V volts and the other capacitor is 0 volts. now the energy stored on the first cap is 1/2*C*V*V and there is no energy stored on other capacitor. Now if i connect these capacitors in parallel the overall cap is 2C and since there is no way for charge to escape the voltage across the parallel combination will be V/2. now the energy stored in the entire network is 1/2*(2C)*(V/2)^2=1/4*C*V*V. I couldn't figure there the pther half of the energy is gone.

please help me understand where i am going wrong in understanding the concept here.
thank you.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
I guess I need to make this a stickie FAQ. Could somebody please search up some links to the solution to this problem, and I'll take care of the stickie. It's late, and I'm out for tonight. Thanks.
 
Hello asifshaik,what do you see happening in the connecting wires when the capacitors are joined together?

(Can someone please tell me what is meant by "sticky" and by "sticky FAQ".Yes,I am dopey.)
 
Dadface said:
Hello asifshaik,what do you see happening in the connecting wires when the capacitors are joined together?

(Can someone please tell me what is meant by "sticky" and by "sticky FAQ".Yes,I am dopey.)

A stickie is a thread that get's pinned or stuck at the top of a forum, and doesn't get pushed off the bottom of the first page by newer posts. Look at the top of the EE forum to see some stickied threads.

A FAQ is a frequently asked question.

This is a handy website for decoding common acronyms, BTW:

www.acronymfinder.com

.
 
Thank you berkeman.
 
Hello asifshaik,what do you see happening in the connecting wires when the capacitors are joined together?I never tried it to see what happens when i physically connect these capacitors, its just a theoretical question popped up in some discussion. I came to some conclusions but wanted to confirm them.
thats why i posted this question.

thanks to TurtleMeister for the link. it was very useful.
 
asifshaik said:
Hello asifshaik,what do you see happening in the connecting wires when the capacitors are joined together?


I never tried it to see what happens when i physically connect these capacitors, its just a theoretical question popped up in some discussion. I came to some conclusions but wanted to confirm them.
thats why i posted this question.

thanks to TurtleMeister for the link. it was very useful.

Hello again asifshaik,my question wasn't meant to be taken literally,it was meant to get you thinking about the problem in a particular way.My fault,I should have phrased it more carefully.Anyway, when the capacitors are joined together there is a momentary current flow as charge flows from one set of plates to the other through the connecting wires.This results in electrical heating losses.There can also be losses due to any spark that may be produced and any electromagnetic wave pulse that may be generated.Most of the energy is lost as heat in the connecting wires.
 
I never tried it to see what happens when i physically connect these capacitors, its just a theoretical question popped up in some discussion. I came to some conclusions but wanted to confirm them.
that's why i posted this question.

thanks to TurtleMeister for the link. it was very useful.

Hello again asifshaik,my question wasn't meant to be taken literally,it was meant to get you thinking about the problem in a particular way.My fault,I should have phrased it more carefully.Anyway, when the capacitors are joined together there is a momentary current flow as charge flows from one set of plates to the other through the connecting wires.This results in electrical heating losses.There can also be losses due to any spark that may be produced and any electromagnetic wave pulse that may be generated.Most of the energy is lost as heat in the connecting wires.My way of analysis is that, when i assumed a resistance R between the two caps, and calculate the energy dissipated on resistor it comes to be CV^2/4 which is independent of R. Hence when I connect those capacitors I think a infinitely large current flows for zero time like a delta signal.*************************************************************************************************************
When this delta current signal is squared and multiplied by R and integrated overtime as R->0 the limit if that integration results in (CV^2)/4. In other words an infinite amount of current going through a zero resistance may result in finite energy dissipation.

But I was not happy with the conclusion because i didn't understand what this energy is getting converted into, till I have gone through this site.
http://www.smpstech.com/charge.htm
which i mentioned in this post by TurtleMeister.
There I came to know that It will result in some form of heat or radiation like an arcing.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
658
Replies
44
Views
6K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
5K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
887
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
4K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
3K