Which city ranks as the smartest in America?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ivan Seeking
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the ranking of cities in America based on educational attainment, specifically focusing on which cities are considered the "smartest." Participants reference a list from Forbes.com that ranks metro areas according to the percentage of residents with at least a bachelor's degree, as well as other educational metrics. The conversation touches on various cities, their characteristics, and the implications of these rankings.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants note that college towns tend to rank higher due to the concentration of students and university employees, which could skew the data.
  • There is a mention of the influence of local businesses in retaining graduates, potentially boosting educational attainment statistics.
  • Concerns are raised about the validity of the rankings, with some participants expressing skepticism about the absence of major cities like Boston.
  • Participants discuss the quality of water in Corvallis, with some attributing the city's educational success to its environment and local amenities.
  • Some participants highlight the presence of professionals, such as engineers and medical doctors, in Corvallis, which may contribute to its ranking.
  • There are humorous exchanges about the characteristics of various states, particularly Kansas, and their perceived lack of excitement compared to other regions.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a mix of agreement and skepticism regarding the rankings. While some acknowledge the influence of educational institutions in certain cities, others question the methodology and outcomes of the survey, indicating that multiple competing views remain.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note that the rankings may not account for various factors such as cost of living, local demographics, and the transient nature of college towns, which could affect the educational attainment statistics.

Who May Find This Useful

Readers interested in urban studies, educational demographics, and regional characteristics of American cities may find this discussion relevant.

Ivan Seeking
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
Messages
8,213
Reaction score
2,660
Our own little Corvallis, Oregon, home of OSU [Integral's and my alma mater], made number five!

Which cities house America's smartest? Forbes.com has taken a list of some 300 metro areas and broken the numbers down to illustrate which cities have the most brains. Using Sperling's BestPlaces, we obtained the most recent percentages, through 2007, on educational attainment--then, whether large or small, we ranked them based on the percentage of inhabitants 25 and over with at least a bachelor's degree. We also found the percentage of these residents with a Ph.D, a professional degree and that have graduated high school. Although these numbers weren't factored into our ranking, they're all laid out in America's 25 Smartest Cities. [continued]
http://www.forbes.com/opinions/2008/02/07/americas-smartest-cities-oped-cx_apa_0207smartest_slide.html
 
Physics news on Phys.org
You'll never win the title of STD capital of the world, GO BALTIMORE!
 
Heh, not too surprising. Lots of college towns...of course the people there are educated, they're all either students or employed by the university. And, of course, if some businesses open up around the university to retain some of the graduates for other employment, you can really boost those numbers.
 
Yes, but in our case it's the water.
 
Ivan, so you live in Corvallis, I guessed that. I go there every summer, got a lot of family in the area. Ever heard of the Goetzingers?
 
Wow, the University of Kansas is #7.
 
Bethesda-Gaithersburg-Frederick, Md.

We made number two, hell yeah!

And DC is number 13! Double points!
 
You mentioned water Ivan, you mean the rain, or the Willamete?
 
binzing said:
You mentioned water Ivan, you mean the rain, or the Willamete?

The tap. :biggrin:
 
  • #10
Moonbear said:
Heh, not too surprising. Lots of college towns...of course the people there are educated, they're all either students or employed by the university. And, of course, if some businesses open up around the university to retain some of the graduates for other employment, you can really boost those numbers.

I was surprised to see three metro's with over a million make the top ten list.
That's like way too many smart people in one place.
Kind of gives me hope for humanity.
 
  • #11
Well, maybe that accounts for some of my smarts, my dad grew up there. The Willamete used to be pretty nasty, and I assume that's where Curvallis' water is drawn from.
 
  • #12
OmCheeto said:
I was surprised to see three metro's with over a million make the top ten list.
That's like way too many smart people in one place.
Kind of gives me hope for humanity.

Yeah, those were more surprising to me, actually. I figured there'd be a lot more less-educated people in those areas to drop their rankings. Maybe it's the cost of living...the less educated people have been forced out because they can't afford to live there?
 
  • #13
binzing, I don't live in Corvallis but I did finish school there... spent many many hours at The Donut Shop across the street from the Physics and Chem schools.

As for my current location, it's a mystery. :biggrin:
 
Last edited:
  • #14
Cyrus said:
Bethesda-Gaithersburg-Frederick, Md.

We made number two, hell yeah!

And DC is number 13! Double points!
How can DC with 13 with that black hole of negative intelligence in the WH?
 
  • #15
Ivan Seeking said:
As for my current location, it's a mystery. :biggrin:

Apparently, even for those with directions to get there. Just ask Integral. :biggrin:
 
  • #16
Heh, maybe we'll meet and never know it. Do you ever check out the Kinetic Sculpture Race or for that matter all of da Vinci days? It's really cool.
 
  • #17
I'm surprised not to see Boston. :confused: They've got MIT, Harvard, BC, BU, and Wellesley.
 
  • #18
binzing said:
Heh, maybe we'll meet and never know it. Do you ever check out the Kinetic Sculpture Race or for that matter all of da Vinci days? It's really cool.

Heh, you got my weak spot here. I once had what was called the most successful exhibit ever seen at da Vinci days. :approve: It was the public debut of an energy education concept that later won a grant from the NEH. The next generation device was or still is operating at OMSI. At last count about five million people had participated.

It was my baby. :biggrin:
 
Last edited:
  • #19
Tom Mattson said:
I'm surprised not to see Boston. :confused: They've got MIT, Harvard, BC, BU, and Wellesley.

Hmm, this survey smells fishy...

Evo said:
Wow, the University of Kansas is #7.

Now it's really starting to reek.

Evo, it's only surprising because, well, you know how modest Kansans are... we hate to show off our intelligence (especially during school board meetings in Topeka!) ;)
 
  • #20
I used to live in #12 (Fort Collins) and now I live in #13. That's just a little messed up.

-scott
 
  • #21
Yeah, the da Vinci days are really cool. My dad, uncle, and I have been scheming on a kinetic sculpture for the past few years. If we do eventually, maybe I'll put a PF logo on it. OMSI is one of the best museums I've ever been to, and I go nearly every summer because my 7 year old cousin loves it so much. Also, I'm seriously considering OSU for college.
 
  • #22
I'm surprised to see Ann Arbor! Yeah, it's supposed to be a "college" town, but who knew folks actually graduated there?!
 
  • #23
Kansas is the most boring state to drive through! Sorry to all residents, but it is. Totally flat, and the time I went through, covered in snow. How do you people survive without seeing mountains?
 
  • #24
Corvallis tap water comes of the side of Marys Peak or straight out of the Willamette depending on the time of year. During the summer it is pretty rank. Some of the worst water in Oregon, Albany gets their water out of the South Santiam, it is quite good, I was surprised.

Another factor for the number of degreed residents in Corvallis in HP. There are a lot of HP engineers living in the area.


Yeah, Ivan lives off in the hills, he is not in a real bad area though, it only takes 2 local housewives to get a full set of teeth, 10 miles further into the hills and it is up to 4. (Tsu is going to smack me for that!)
 
  • #25
Integral said:
Corvallis tap water comes of the side of Marys Peak or straight out of the Willamette depending on the time of year. During the summer it is pretty rank. Some of the worst water in Oregon, Albany gets their water out of the South Santiam, it is quite good, I was surprised.

Another factor for the number of degreed residents in Corvallis in HP. There are a lot of HP engineers living in the area.


Yeah, Ivan lives off in the hills, he is not in a real bad area though, it only takes 2 local housewives to get a full set of teeth, 10 miles further into the hills and it is up to 4. (Tsu is going to smack me for that!)

Ivan lives near a hockey rink?
teemu selanne said:
If you lose a couple of teeth on the way to a gold medal I think it's a small price to pay
You can always get new teeth.
 
  • #26
Corvallis also has very strict growth policies which help to limit the population. And it is not only a community of college professors and HP engineers, but it has recently become a bedroom community for medical doctors and other professionals who commute to Eugene, Salem, or even Portland.

Yep, where I live men are men and sheeps are scared. [Actually it looks like we invested very well. This is now considered a prime area where the rich people are buying :biggrin:]
 
Last edited:
  • #27
YES! The SF bay area is #9. Take that, Iowa City!

- Warren
 
  • #28
Yeah one of my uncles grew up in Corvallis and went to OSU to become an electrical engineer. He now works for HP in Vancouver, WA. My godfather still lives in Corvallis and does technical writing for HP and other tech companies. I've been on the Willammete (knew I was misspelling it) in the middle of summer, actually paddling along with the kinetic sculptures. Whether or not I go to OSU I plan to live in Corvallis, either just for a while, or maybe buy the home place from my aunt eventually.
 
  • #29
Last edited:
  • #30
I was going to see where Phoenix ended up on the list, but couldn't figure out where the actual list was. Maybe that tells me we wouldn't be on the list anyway.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
4K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
8K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
6K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
5K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
8K
  • · Replies 67 ·
3
Replies
67
Views
16K
  • · Replies 59 ·
2
Replies
59
Views
12K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
31K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K