Which of the two dielectrics breaks down first?

  • Thread starter Thread starter HelloCthulhu
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Dielectrics
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers on the breakdown voltages of two dielectrics—mica and water—within a parallel plate capacitor setup. The maximum voltage for mica is calculated to be 590 kV, while for water, it is 325 kV. The capacitance values are determined as 0.531 pF for mica and 14.2 pF for water. Ultimately, the mica dielectric will break down first due to its lower breakdown voltage compared to water.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of parallel plate capacitors
  • Knowledge of dielectric materials and their properties
  • Familiarity with capacitance calculations using the formula C = Kε₀(A/d)
  • Concept of dielectric breakdown and its significance in capacitor design
NEXT STEPS
  • Research the effects of dielectric materials on capacitor performance
  • Learn about the implications of dielectric breakdown in electrical engineering
  • Explore advanced capacitor configurations, including multi-dielectric systems
  • Investigate the thermal and electrical properties of mica and water as dielectrics
USEFUL FOR

Electrical engineers, physics students, and anyone involved in capacitor design or dielectric material research will benefit from this discussion.

HelloCthulhu
Messages
150
Reaction score
3

Homework Statement



A parallel plate capacitor has area A = 1 cm2 and a plate separation of d = 0.01m (1cm). Water at room temp (20°C) is poured into a mica cylinder and placed between the plates filling the volume of 1cm3. Find the Maximum capacitance, voltage and charge for the capacitor as well as which dielectric will break down first.

Homework Equations



Q=CV

V = Edmica
cyclinder thickness = 0.25cm x 2 (touches both sides of the capacitor =0.5cm = 0.005m)

dielectric constant = 3-6 (3)

dielectric breakdown = E = 118MV/mwater
thickness = d = 0.005m

electric constant = ε0 = 8.854×10−12 F

dielectric constant = K = 80.1

dielectric breakdown = 65MV/mCapacitance for 2 capacitors in series:
$$C_T\frac{C_1\times C_2}{C_1+C_2}$$
Breakdown voltage the capacitor:
$$V{max}=\frac{V_{bd}}{\frac{C_T}{C_1}}$$

The Attempt at a Solution



In a two dielectric capacitor, if one dielectric breaks down the capacitor fails. To solve for the voltage across each capacitor in series, first find the capacitance:https://www.electronics-tutorials.ws/capacitor/cap_7.htmlSeries capacitor specs:

$$C=K\varepsilon_0\frac{A}{d}$$

Max voltage for mica:

$$(118\times10^6V)\times0.005m=590\times10^3V=590kV$$

Max voltage for water:

$$(65\times10^6V)\times0.005m=325\times10^3V= 325kV$$

Capacitance for mica:

$$C=K\varepsilon_0\frac{A}{d}=C=\frac{(8.85\times10^{-12})\times3\times0.0001}{0.005}=5.31\times10^{-13}F=0.531pF$$

Capacitance for water:

$$\frac{(8.85\times10^{-12})\times80.1\times0.0001}{0.005}=1.41777\times10^{-11}F=14.1777pF=14.2pF$$

Charge for mica:

$$(118\times10^6V)\times(5.31\times10^{-13}F) =6.2658\times10^{-5}C=626.58nC=627nC$$

Charge for water:

$$(65\times10^6V)\times1.41777\times10^{-11}F=5.529303\times10^{-8}=552.9303nC=553nC$$(this equation can be used when only two capacitors are in series)

$$C_T\frac{C_1\times C_2}{C_1+C_2}$$$$C_T=\frac{(1.41777\times10^{-11}F)\times (5.31\times10^{-13}F)}{(1.41777\times10^{-11}F)+(5.31\times10^{-13}F)}=\frac{(7.528359\times10^-24) F}{(1.47087\times10^-11)F}=5.11830\times10^{-13} = 0.511830pF=0.512pF$$$$V_{C_{1}}=\frac{C_T}{C_1}\times V_T$$I modified this equation to solve for the max voltage across the mica's breakdown voltage(bd1):

$$V_{bd1}=\frac{C_T}{C_1}\times V{max}$$$$V{max}=\frac{V_{bd}}{\frac{C_T}{C_1}}$$

mica:

$$V_{c1}max=\frac{59\times10^4V}{\frac{0.511830pF

}{0.531pF}}=\frac{59\times10^4V}{0.963898pF}=612,097.7668371V=612.1kV$$

water:

$$V_{c2}max=\frac{325\times10^3V}{\frac{0.511830pF

}{14.1777pF}}=\frac{325\times10^3V}{0.036101pF}=9002505.71V=9MV$$

The mica containing the water will break down first.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
HelloCthulhu said:
A parallel plate capacitor has area A = 1 cm2 and a plate separation of d = 0.01m (1cm). Water at room temp (20°C) is poured into a mica cylinder and placed between the plates filling the volume of 1cm3.
You've done lots of work which is great.

But, I'm having trouble visualizing this setup. How in the world can a cylinder with a volume of 1cm^3 fill the volume between 1cm^2 plates spaced 1cm apart?. Can you post the figure that goes with this? Does the cylinder not really fill the total rectangular area between the square plates? Thanks. (sorry if I'm missing the obvious)
 
berkeman said:
You've done lots of work which is great.

But, I'm having trouble visualizing this setup. How in the world can a cylinder with a volume of 1cm^3 fill the volume between 1cm^2 plates spaced 1cm apart?. Can you post the figure that goes with this? Does the cylinder not really fill the total rectangular area between the square plates? Thanks. (sorry if I'm missing the obvious)

No it's ok. This isn't really homework just a scenario I've been experimenting with mathematically. I guess it's more of an approximation. Here's a related post I made back in March. I just changed a few of the specs:

https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/max-values-for-a-2-dielectric-capacitor.941359/#post-5954565
 

Similar threads

Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
6K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
5K
Replies
2
Views
19K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K