Who Said "Shut Up and Calculate"?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Azael
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the attribution of the phrase "Shut up and calculate!" with conflicting claims about whether it originated from Richard Feynman or Paul Dirac. A participant expresses confusion after reading a Wikipedia article that credits Dirac, despite a personal belief that Feynman is the source. The reliability of Wikipedia is questioned, with comments suggesting it can contain errors due to its editable nature. There is a broader commentary on the nature of scientific discourse, with some participants expressing disdain for outspoken scientists, suggesting that they often complicate matters with unnecessary rhetoric. The conversation also touches on the importance of citation and the perception of scientists' opinions compared to those of other groups, such as "hippies." Overall, the thread highlights the complexities of attributing quotes in science and the varying attitudes toward scientific communication.
Azael
Messages
257
Reaction score
1
Physics news on Phys.org
I read it ascribed to Feynman, but don't recall where I read it. If it comes back to me I'll post it here, though.
 
Here's a very interesting piece:

http://www.physicstoday.org/vol-57/iss-5/p10.html

This man believes he may have originated the phrase.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You shouldn't trust wiki articles ever since they are free to edit and can be made by anyone. They are good articles for basic knowledge but don't rely on it for facts because more often than not there is an error lying in it.
Now whether it is Mermin or Feynman is a different story...and an interesting one.
 
The plot thickens:cool:
 
If there is any quote I like, it would be this one. It eptomises the need for just 'shutting the f*&k up' in science. Not even Einstein does it for me here, too much outspoken, too much BS in my opinion.

Outspoken Scientists are the worst, besides hippies.
 
Bladibla said:
If there is any quote I like, it would be this one. It eptomises the need for just 'shutting the f*&k up' in science. Not even Einstein does it for me here, too much outspoken, too much BS in my opinion.

Outspoken Scientists are the worst, besides hippies.

How outspoken.
 
Christina- said:
You shouldn't trust wiki articles ever since they are free to edit and can be made by anyone. They are good articles for basic knowledge but don't rely on it for facts because more often than not there is an error lying in it.
Now whether it is Mermin or Feynman is a different story...and an interesting one.
I have Mermin's book on SR. Decent read, but not real great. Wish we used Wheeler instead. Oh well.

Wikipedia is in general as accurate as Brittannica. That said, neither is authoritative, and neither is a method of proof (*points at the myriads of morons who try to tell me iron undergoes fusion in supernova explosions trying to use wikipedia citations as a method of proof*). Citation in general, is not a method of proof.
 
Last edited:
rachmaninoff said:
How outspoken.

No. Me outspoken would be to take about politics, society and general anti war protests.
 
  • #10
Bladibla said:
No. Me outspoken would be to take about politics, society and general anti war protests.

I don't see why one would disregard a scientists opinion like a hippies opinion. Yah hippies are generally way off and have no regard for reality but scientists tend to be pretty level-headed people. I personally have a problem of people quoting scientists in a way that depicts them as of a higher philisophical intellect. Then again quoting people to me is a fairly flakey idea in the first place. Then again, i was about to put a quote in my signature...
 
  • #11
I almost agreed with you, then I realized who wrote it and disregarded it.
 
  • #12
tribdog said:
I almost agreed with you, then I realized who wrote it and disregarded it.

i love you so much tribdog
 
  • #13
wanna make out?
 
  • #14
No no is no[/color]
 
  • #15
I meant in general, not just with me. virgin
 

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
994
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Sticky
Replies
0
Views
4K
Back
Top