Why are Fourier series important?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the importance and applications of Fourier series in various fields, particularly in motivating students to study this mathematical concept. Participants explore real-life applications, theoretical implications, and pedagogical approaches related to Fourier series in mathematics, physics, and engineering.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants mention applications of Fourier series in signal processing and electrical principles, suggesting these are common examples taught in undergraduate courses.
  • One participant proposes that sounds produced by musical instruments could serve as a practical application of Fourier series.
  • A participant expresses concern about the effectiveness of motivating students through applications, noting that detailed explanations are often necessary to convey meaning.
  • Another participant suggests that understanding linear independence and orthogonality is crucial for grasping Fourier series, comparing it to vector representation.
  • Some participants highlight the relevance of Fourier series in laser science, particularly in mode locking and bandwidth versus pulse length.
  • One participant emphasizes the connection between Fourier series and Fourier transforms, stating that the latter has more ubiquitous applications.
  • Another participant discusses the role of Fourier series in solving linear differential equations, such as the heat equation and Schrödinger's equation, suggesting this as a strong motivation for students in physics and engineering.
  • One participant mentions the significance of discrete Fourier series and Fast Fourier Transforms (FFT) in modern computation, indicating their impact on various applications.
  • Another participant refers to historical problems like heat transfer and the vibrating string problem as motivations for studying Fourier series, linking them to actual physics experiments.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of views on the applications and pedagogical approaches related to Fourier series, with no clear consensus on a single motivating example or method. Multiple competing perspectives on the importance and relevance of Fourier series remain present throughout the discussion.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note that understanding concepts like normal modes and eigenfunctions may be necessary for fully grasping the applications of Fourier series, indicating potential limitations in students' backgrounds that could affect comprehension.

matqkks
Messages
283
Reaction score
6
Are there any real life applications of Fourier series?

Are there examples of Fourier series which have an impact on students learning this topic. I have found the normal suspects of examples in this field such as signal processing, electrical principles but there must be a vast range of applications as it is taught on most undergraduate courses in mathematics, physics and engineering. I am looking for examples which will motivate why students should study Fourier series.
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
Sounds produced by musical instruments.
 
matqkks said:
Are there any real life applications of Fourier series?

I am looking for examples which will motivate why students should study Fourier series.

The trouble with motivating mathematics by showing applications is that you have teach the details of the applications to convey the full meaning. You can always give a little speech like "Fourier series are useful in electronics, acoustics, ...blah-blah" and not show the details, but I don't think that's what you have in mind.

We can consider whether there are any gizmos you could set up on a table top and show how sums of pure trigonometric functions add to a complicated function - and the reverse process. I don't know of any simple equipment that does this. You can do it with electronic devices, but it isn't convincing unless the class is already familiar with the equipment.

I think such a demonstration is actually misleading. In applications of Fourier series, it is usually implausible to think that a complicated function is actually being produced by some physical gizmos that are producing pure sine or cosine waves. It is analogous to the case with vectors. We can imagine a vector being the result of two component vectors in various ways, but in a physical situation there is often no physical implementation of each separate component..

I think Fourier series are easier to swallow if the students first understand the general idea of linear independence and orthogonality as applied to functions. If we are given a set of simple looking functions and a complicated function there are two basic questions 1) Can we approximate the complicated function using the simpler functions? 2) How do we find the approximation? Question 1) is mathematically complicated. Question 2) can be taught by analogy to vectors. If you have a non-independent set of non-orthogonal vectors, you may be able to represent a given vector in various non-unique ways. If you want to represent in a convenient and unique way, you should use a set of independent vectors, if possible a set of orthogonal vectors, and even better a set of orthonormal vectors.
 
it might also help if they know about eigenvectors.
 
matqkks said:
Are there any real life applications of Fourier series?

Are there examples of Fourier series which have an impact on students learning this topic. I have found the normal suspects of examples in this field such as signal processing, electrical principles but there must be a vast range of applications as it is taught on most undergraduate courses in mathematics, physics and engineering. I am looking for examples which will motivate why students should study Fourier series.

It is important in so many ways in laser science. (mode locking, bandwidth versus pulse length, etc.)
 
Fourier series aren't used so much, but the Fourier transform is related and is totally ubiquitous in its applications. The Fourier series is a good stepping stone toward the Fourier transform.

Sound processing is probably the purest and simplest application.
 
Fourier series are important for understanding Fourier Transforms which is one of the most basic elements of signal processing of all sorts (including Khashishi's sound processing). If you are interested in that subject, a good book is the University of Lex's "Who is Fourier. Just be warned that even though the book looks like (and is) a cartoon book, the math in it is difficult and complex for those with less than a couple years of college math.
 
Many of the basic areas of physics and engineering can be mathematically described by differential equations - heat flow, fluid dynamics, electromagnetic theory, quantum mechanics. Fourier series naturally arise in solving some linear differential equations (heat equation, wave equation, Schrödinger's equation, etc.) in bounded regions. I say "naturally" because they are eigenfunctions of a differential operator (see Mathwonk's comment above). This application alone would be motivation for including it in basic mathematical training of physicists and engineers.

Today, I would think the discrete version is at least as important, as much of the computation done today is in the digital domain. Discrete time Fourier series are essentially the discrete Fourier transform (DFT). And in the digital domain, if we have a short signal that is not periodic, we often pretend that the entire signal is one period of a periodic signal and use the DFT to analyze/process it. There are a fast set of algorithms collectively known as Fast Fourier Transforms (FFT) that efficiently calculate the DFT. The FFT is so efficient that engineers will often go out of their way to be able to use the FFT instead of something much more computationally expensive. I think it is fair to say that the FFT has had a large impact on computation for many applications, and the FFT is simply a fast way of computing the coefficients of a discrete time Fourier series.

Fourier analysis is one of the most important tools that I use as an electrical engineer. As Stephen Tashi and Mathwonk indicated, knowing linear algebra really helps with understanding Fourier series.

jason
 
Why not use Fourier's reason? Heat transfer. Cooling off a 1-dimensional rod. Similarly, the vibrating string problem, which was the original historical motivation. I don't know that these specific problems are that important, in terms of really practical applications, but they do correspond to actual physics experiments that you can carry out.

To me the best motivation is to note that you can get any twice differentiable function to satisfy the wave equation if you move it along at the right velocity, but on the other hand, if you know that you can think of the vibrating string as a limiting case of a bunch of harmonic oscillators, and you know about normal modes in physics, it should be the case that any motion of the string is a superposition of the normal modes (i.e. the eigenfunctions). If you put the two points of view together, it seems physically plausible that you ought to be able to represent functions in terms of the normal modes. Of course, this sort of depends on understanding normal modes, which could be a big digression, depending on the students' background, but with some finesse, you could probably develop this explanation to be accessible to audiences at different levels, with correspondingly different levels of hand-waving.

In the case of the cooling off problem for a rod, we can work out that sinusoidal things decay exponentially. So, if, as we've been taught to do from studying the vibrating string, we can express the initial temperature distribution as a Fourier series, we should be able to solve the problem for a general initial temperature distribution, since we know how to solve it for sinusoidal ones.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 27 ·
Replies
27
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
9K