lagmonster
- 2
- 0
help pls! since electrons cr8 a magnetic field due to their spin, shouldn't atoms be magnetic? o0
The discussion revolves around the question of why atoms are not universally magnetic despite the presence of electrons, which generate magnetic fields due to their spin. Participants explore the nature of atomic structure, the contributions of electrons and protons, and the conditions under which atoms exhibit magnetic properties.
Participants express differing views on the conditions under which atoms exhibit magnetism, with some arguing that certain configurations lead to measurable magnetic moments while others point out that many atoms do not display significant magnetism. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the general behavior of atomic magnetism.
Limitations include the dependence on specific atomic configurations for magnetism, the complexity of interactions between charges and magnetic fields, and the varying detectability of nuclear spins in different contexts.
This discussion may be of interest to those studying atomic physics, magnetism, or materials science, particularly in understanding the conditions that lead to magnetic properties in atoms.
lagmonster said:help pls! since electrons cr8 a magnetic field due to their spin, shouldn't atoms be magnetic? o0
mrjeffy321 said:but both electrons and protons each have a fundamental charge, equal and opposite each other, so those cancel out each other.
but a moving charged particle, like an electron, also creates its own magnetic field, in addition to the fundamental charge it carries.
how do this work in, since this extra charge doesn't seem to "Cancel" anywhere?