Why Does Heat Transfer Direction Differ in Triangular and Rectangular Fins?

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
2 replies · 2K views
roughwinds
Messages
11
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


I'm unsure of what exactly is changing the heat transfer direction in the triangular fin.

Homework Equations


$$q_{x} = -kA(x)\frac{dT(x)}{dx} (1)$$
$$q_{x+dx} = -kA(x)\frac{dT(x)}{dx} - k\frac{d}{dx}[A(x)\frac{dT(x)}{dx}] (2)$$
$$dq_{conv} = h(x)dS(x)P[T(x) - T_{∞}] (3)$$
A = cross-sectional area m²
q = heat transfer rate W
h = convection heat transfer coefficient W/m²K
k = thermal conductivity W/mK
T = temperature K
dq = convection heat transfer rate
dS = surface area of the differential element
Tb = base surface temperature K
A0 = base area
L = length

The Attempt at a Solution


Energy balance:
$$q_{x} = dq_{conv} + - q_{x+dx} (4)$$
Substitute (1), (2) and (3) in (4):
$$\frac{d}{dx}[A(x)\frac{dT(x)}{dx}] - \frac{h(x)dS(x)}{kdx}[T(x) - T_{∞}] (5)$$
$$X = \frac{x}{L}$$
$$\theta(X) = \frac{T(X) - T_{∞}}{T_{b} - T_{∞}}$$
$$K(X) = \frac{A(X)}{A_{0}}$$
$$W(X) = \frac{h(X)dS(X)}{P_{0}h_{av}dX}$$
$$M = mL$$
$$m² = \frac{h_{av}P_{0}}{kA_{0}}$$
$$\frac{dS(X)}{dX} = p(X)$$
Substitute into (5) and rearrange:
$$\frac{d}{dX}[K(X)\frac{d\theta(X)}{dX}] - W(X)M²\theta(X) = 0 (6)$$

Rectangular profile:
1.png

A(X) = A0, K(X) = 1, W(X) = 1
$$\frac{d}{dX}[\frac{d\theta(X)}{dX}] - M²\theta(X) = 0$$

Triangular profile:
2.png


A(X) =/= A0, K(X) = ~ X, W(X) = 1
$$\frac{d}{dX}[X\frac{d\theta(X)}{dX}] - M²\theta(X) = 0$$

I did the energy balance thinking of the heat going from left to right like it's shown on the rectangular fin, but on the triangular fin it goes on the opposite direction. Which is fine for what I want to do, but why exactly does this happen? Due to the equations involved the heat will only move from a bigger to an equal or smaller area? Which adjustments would I have to make to change the heat transfer direction and make a fin like this:
3.png
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Could you be a bit clearer as to the original problem you are trying to solve (rather than the problem you're having with it...). I think I could figure that out with some effort but I'm not inclined to exert that effort right now.
 
I did the energy balance thinking of the heat going from left to right like it's shown on the rectangular fin, but on the triangular fin it goes on the opposite direction. Which is fine for what I want to do, but why exactly does this happen? Due to the equations involved the heat will only move from a bigger to an equal or smaller area? Which adjustments would I have to make to change the heat transfer direction and make a fin like this:
View attachment 103858
The direction that the heat flows has nothing to do with how the area is varying. It has everything to do with how the temperature is varying. This is determined the the boundary conditions on the fin. What are the boundary conditions being applied on the two ends of your fin?