Why is gain with feedback lower than gain without feedback in this example?

3 replies · 3K views · last reply
iitjee10
Messages
56
Reaction score
0
While introducing negative feedback, my book gave the following example:

Let the signal voltage be 101mV and the output voltage of the amplifier be 10V
Out of this 10V a fraction (0.01) i.e. 100mV was made to feedback to the input circuit. The feedback circuit did not introduce any phase change. Hence, the feedback was negative (there is a 180 deg. phase reversal in amplifier circuit.)
The input signal now becomes (101-100) = 1mV

Then it was given that,
Gain (without feedback) is 10V/1mV = 10,000
Gain with feedback = 10V/101mV = 100 (approx)
Feedback factor = 100mV/10V = 0.01

My doubt is that shouldn't the gain without feedback and the gain with feedback be just the opposite?
With the feedback the input becomes 1mV and without feedback the input was 101mV
 
They are keeping the output voltage constant and instead modifying the input signal. So with feedback, they needed a greater input signal to achieve the same output. This is to be expected with negative feedback since you are essentially subtracting off some of the output signal off from the input.
 
ohk... this was what was intended.
Thanks a lot Born2bwire
 
See complete derivation of op amp feedback and gain in thumbnail.
 
Attachments
  • Inverting op-amp circuit schematic with R2 = 1k from V_in to the inverting node and R1 = 100k feedback resistor to V_out, with labels Vm, Vp and Gain_A, followed by a typed derivation of Vout = -99.000099 Vin for A = 10,000.
    OpAmp_ckt1.jpg
    38.3 KB · Views: 506