I Why is the driven gear's torque's direction clockwise?

  • I
  • Thread starter Thread starter annamal
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Gears Torque
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the torque direction of two interacting gears, A and B, where gear A is driven clockwise. Gear B's torque is counterclockwise as a reaction to gear A's clockwise motion, illustrating Newton's third law. The Right-Hand Rule is suggested as a method to visualize the torque vectors for both gears. The magnitude of the torque for each gear is influenced by their size and tooth count. Ultimately, the interaction between the driving torque and the resisting torque is emphasized as a fundamental principle in gear mechanics.
annamal
Messages
393
Reaction score
33
TL;DR Summary
Two gears (A and B) are spinning with their centers fixed with the left one being the driver driving the left gear clockwise. Why is the driven gear (gear B to the right) torque clockwise as well?
We have two gears A and B (left and right). Gear A is driven with a clockwise torque. Why is gear B's torque also clockwise? I would say that if gear B is driven to turn counterclockwise, the torque should be in the counterclockwise direction.
Screenshot 2023-09-12 at 7.09.39 PM.png
 
Physics news on Phys.org
If the left gear is turning clockwise, the right gear will turn counterclockwise. Is the torque you are applying to A against the rotation or something?
 
berkeman said:
If the left gear is turning clockwise, the right gear will turn counterclockwise. Is the torque you are applying to A against the rotation or something?
No. I am applying a torque just to gear A. And apparently the torque for gear B is in the opposite direction because it is some reaction torque to gear A.
 
I assume what's being described is the force applied by gear B to gear A. If gear A applies a force downwards at the point of contact, gear B must be applying a force back against it upwards per Newton's 3rd law.
 
annamal said:
No. I am applying a torque just to gear A. And apparently the torque for gear B is in the opposite direction because it is some reaction torque to gear A.
Sure, just use the Right-Hand Rule for torques to help you see what is going on. Draw the force and torque vectors for each gear...
$$\vec \tau = \vec R \times \vec F$$
 
Ah. I figured it out. The torque for the right gear is drawn as the load's torque.
 
annamal said:
Ah. I figured it out. The torque for the right gear is drawn as the load's torque.
Correct.
Consider that the magnitude of each torque depends on the diameter (or number of teeth) of each gear.
Only the tangential contact forces mentioned in post #4 are of equal magnitude and opposite directions.

Force (or torque) and resistance to it are always a pair.
We can't talk about a driving torque, unless we have a resisting torque.
In the same way, we can't exert any weight on the floor of a free-falling elevator.

FREE-BODY-DIAGRAM-OF-TWO-GEAR.png
 
Back
Top