Work calculation for lifting a Tetrahedron-shaped object from the water

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
37 replies · 4K views
@Frabjous, I tried sending a PM (private message) to you (and @NODARman). But the system wouldn't let me send it to you. I know the problem requires a method using integration, but If you are interested in how to do it without any explicit integration, let me know.
 
Reply
  • Love
Likes   Reactions: NODARman
Physics news on Phys.org
Steve4Physics said:
@Frabjous, I tried sending a PM (private message) to you (and @NODARman). But the system wouldn't let me send it to you. I know the problem requires a method using integration, but If you are interested in how to do it without any explicit integration, let me know.
If you are talking about not having to integrate 1-(h/h₀)³, I’d be interested.
 
Frabjous said:
If you are talking about not having to integrate 1-(h/h₀)³, I’d be interested.
I'll attempt to send it again.
 
Maybe I misread the above posts, but IMO the buoyancy (from Archimedes principle) needs to be ## \int \rho g \,dV=\int \rho g A \, dh ##. and note: ## \rho ## is the density of the water, so it along with ## g ## can be in front of the integral.). post 26 is trying to do an integral of ## \int V \, dh ## , and that is incorrect.
 
Last edited:
Charles Link said:
Maybe I misread the above posts, but IMO the buoyancy (from Archimedes principle) needs to be ## \int \rho g \,dV=\int \rho g A \, dh ##. and note: ## \rho ## is the density of the water, so it along with ## g ## can be in front of the integral.). post 26 is trying to do an integral of ## \int V \, dh ## , and that is incorrect.
It’s a work integral of a fully submerged volume. This is an incomplete thread because the discussion moved to a private conversation. I believe the OP is satisfied.
 
Frabjous said:
It’s a work integral of a fully submerged volume. This is an incomplete thread because the discussion moved to a private conversation. I believe the OP is satisfied.
The OP looks to me to still be doing an incorrect computation of the buoyant force.
 
Charles Link said:
The OP looks to me to still be doing an incorrect computation of the buoyant force.
He’s calculating the work done by gravity and buoyancy of a fully submerged constant volume that is lifted height L-h.
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Charles Link
Frabjous said:
He’s calculating the work done by gravity and buoyancy of a fully submerged constant volume that is lifted height L-h.
Thank you=I just re-read the title of the post=the work to lift the object. I would expect to see ## W=\int F \cdot ds ##, but my mistake. :)
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Frabjous