Thread Closed

CNN: It's McCain and Palin

 
Share Thread Thread Tools
Aug29-08, 07:44 PM   #52
 

CNN: It's McCain and Palin


Quote by Astronuc View Post
And she'd still be way ahead of the current president!

There's nothing like on-the-job training (although it hasn't worked for Bush).
On the job training is something you'd expect from entry level employees though. The person running the country better already have experience. The 'training' should just be small adjustments from knowledge already had in a very similar area but simply tailored here and there for the differences from the last job.

Walking in not knowing what to do is a clear indication of a clueless idiot, which is what she stated herself in that youtube video from war. If I applied for a job and asked the interviewer, sooooooooo.......what will I be doing?.......he'd throw me out and say come back when you learned something about the company and job position you're after.

Quite simply, what she said was inexcusable.
Aug29-08, 08:13 PM   #53
 
Recognitions:
Gold Membership Gold Member
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Retired Staff Staff Emeritus
Quote by Vanadium 50 View Post
Not true.

Her name was (and is) Harriet Meirs, who was a lawyer in private practice for almost 30 years, was president of the Texas bar association and at the time of her appointment was White House Counsel. She was recommended as O'Connor's successor by none other than Harry Reid, the Democratic Senate (then) Minority Leader.

GWB has done many things deserving of criticism.
And this was likely one of them. Nominating your own White House counsel - a person who became famous for asserting that Bush was the most brilliant man she'd ever met. Oh, and let's not forget the BS story that Bush made up as the reason for her withdrawing.
Aug29-08, 08:48 PM   #54
 
Mentor
Quote by Cyrus View Post
Doesnt this lady have like 2 years as governor of Alaska? That's pretty slim experience. What's her resume even look like?
Poly sci degree from U of Idaho
City council of some city I never heard of, 1992-1996
Mayor from 1996-2003 (I think - she tried for Lt Gov in 2002 and lost and it doesn't say when she actually left the mayorship)
Held a mid-level advisor job (on ethics) with the governor from 2003-4 (resigned in protest of ethics violations and ended up bringing down the head of the Rep party in Alaska over it (that impresses me a lot).
Governor, 2007-8 (19 months)


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palin

I don't think that's necessarily true. A CEO and VP can be nearly match in experience, one is just a better leader than the other.
You're really trying to have it both ways here. To be objective, you need to set all variables but one equal and consider only that one variable: so all else being equal, would you want the more experienced or the less experienced potential President/CEO? Or put another way, which should be President/CEO and which should be

Heck, VP is, in reality, used as a stepping stone to President/CEO in both government and business. In business, it's almost a requirement.
In any even, I'd really like to hear what qualifications makes her stand out from the other choices McCain had on the table.
McCain picked her, and here's why:
"She's not from these parts and she's not from Washington," McCain told a crowd of some 12,000 Republicans at a basketball arena in Dayton, extolling her work against corruption and special interests in Alaska. "But when you get to know her, you're going to be as impressed as I am."

McCain said, "she's got the grit, integrity, and good sense and fierce devotion to the common good that is exactly what we need in Washington today."
From wiki: "Palin holds a bachelor of arts degree in journalism from the University of Idaho."

I think I'd want someone smarter than that...
Journalism is the school, not the major, but ultimately I agree that I'm not overly impressed with a political science degree.

Regardless, our Presidents have had a very wide range of educational credentials.
Also from wiki........................yikes. No thank you. Let's try nominating smart educated people for office.

She's a religious right nutjob.
While I agree that the evolution thing is a fairly big black stain, it is being used as a "religious right nutjob" litmus test, which may or may not really be accurate.
Aug29-08, 08:56 PM   #55
 
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Help
I found this amusing (to me anyway) take on Sarah Palin's appointment posted by someone in Alaska that I thought gives an interesting perspective.

http://mudflats.wordpress.com/2008/0...s-perspective/
Aug29-08, 08:57 PM   #56
 
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Help
Science Advisor Science Advisor
well obviously she is a pitifully embarrassing choice, like a hail mary pass from a loser candidate, but she is about 100 times smarter than dan quayle. so although the gop ticket looks like a "little moron" joke to me, i think, given the idiocy of the us electorate, it is still a toss up.
Aug29-08, 09:08 PM   #57
 
Quote by russ_watters View Post
Poly sci degree from U of Idaho
City council of some city I never heard of, 1992-1996
Mayor from 1996-2003 (I think - she tried for Lt Gov in 2002 and lost and it doesn't say when she actually left the mayorship)
Held a mid-level advisor job (on ethics) with the governor from 2003-4 (resigned in protest of ethics violations and ended up bringing down the head of the Rep party in Alaska over it (that impresses me a lot).
Governor, 2007-8 (19 months)
That's a pretty sad list for a VP.

You're really trying to have it both ways here. To be objective, you need to set all variables but one equal and consider only that one variable: so all else being equal, would you want the more experienced or the less experienced potential President/CEO? Or put another way, which should be President/CEO and which should be
Ok, thats fine. But then the more experienced one shouldnt be lightyears ahead of the less experienced one. Keep in mind, she is potentially the president if something happens to McCain. I would not trust this woman to run things properly with her total lack of experience.

Heck, VP is, in reality, used as a stepping stone to President/CEO in both government and business. In business, it's almost a requirement.
Yeah, but it takes years of experience to become even a VP in a company. You dont get there overnight like this lady is trying to do.


Journalism is the school, not the major, but ultimately I agree that I'm not overly impressed with a political science degree.

Regardless, our Presidents have had a very wide range of educational credentials. While I agree that the evolution thing is a fairly big black stain, it is being used as a "religious right nutjob" litmus test, which may or may not really be accurate.
Oh come on, her education is pathetic. Even Ron Paul is a doctor. I want an intellectual in office, be it republic or democrat. Be a doctor, lawer, PhD, go to a top name school: Harvard, Yale, Princeton, MIT, Stanford. Whats so great about the university of Idaho? Did she major in reporting about potatoes?

But no, we can't boast intellect when running for office. That would be elitist. So instead, they have to pander to the 249 million dumbases that will vote for them that they are 'one of them'. Apparently, its bad to be smart. To win, you must be fat, stupid, love god, love guns, and worked in a mill growing up. These are 'important qualities' - (again, for both parties not just one). It's really pathetic. We should frown upon them as a nation playing to the stupid crowd. It's insulting.

Seriously, what's so bad about Tom Ridge? Smart guy, harvard, military service in vietnam, head of DHS, former Governor.....
Aug29-08, 09:10 PM   #58
 
Mentor
Can you see her staring down Putin?
Aug29-08, 09:10 PM   #59
 
Quote by mathwonk View Post
well obviously she is a pitifully embarrassing choice, like a hail mary pass from a loser candidate, but she is about 100 times smarter than dan quayle. so although the gop ticket looks like a "little moron" joke to me, i think, given the idiocy of the us electorate, it is still a toss up.
Hahahha, last sentence is funny, but sad because its true.
Aug29-08, 09:38 PM   #60
 
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Help
Not to put too fine a point on things, but Nancy Pelosi is third in line to the Presidency..
Aug29-08, 09:43 PM   #61
 
Mentor
Quote by LowlyPion View Post
Not to put too fine a point on things, but Nancy Pelosi is third in line to the Presidency..
IMO, Pelosi as Commander in Chief is much better than Sarah Palin. Pelosi's tough.
Aug29-08, 09:56 PM   #62
 
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Help
Science Advisor Science Advisor
as my wife put it: a beehive hairdo?

what scares me was the ad showing her firing a combat rifle. is that the argument for her qualifications?


this is a sick joke right?

the good part is, there is no clearer distinction possible between these candidates. there is no way to confuse them. ( i hope) it is inconceivable that any hillary clinton supporter could vote for these dingbats.
Aug29-08, 10:01 PM   #63
 
Mentor
Quote by mathwonk View Post
as my wife put it: a beehive hairdo?
Good point, mathwonk...what the hell is up with the hair?!?!?
Aug29-08, 10:04 PM   #64
 
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Help
Quote by lisab View Post
IMO, Pelosi as Commander in Chief is much better than Sarah Palin. Pelosi's tough.
I expect so.

I'd say the bald appeal to the anti-intellectualism of Intelligent Design, the pro-life stance, NRA membership, appeal to keep polar bears off the endangered species list, and dedication to drilling ANWAR, will wear quite thin once people get to reviewing her qualifications.

Insofar as cracking the glass ceiling, Geraldine Ferraro was already there and Nancy Pelosi is still poking her head through. She is only a couple of gaffe's away from total disaster for the Republicans.

I marvel at the Republican euphoria about her selection.
Aug29-08, 10:06 PM   #65
 
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Help
Quote by lisab View Post
Good point, mathwonk...what the hell is up with the hair?!?!?
Probably designed to make her look taller?

In that regard Romney was probably too tall for McCain.
Aug30-08, 12:01 AM   #66
 
Mentor
Quote by mathwonk View Post
well obviously she is a pitifully embarrassing choice, like a hail mary pass from a loser candidate, but she is about 100 times smarter than dan quayle. so although the gop ticket looks like a "little moron" joke to me, i think, given the idiocy of the us electorate, it is still a toss up.
Yes, obviously.....well wait - obvious to who? People who are so far to the left they can't even see the center?? The polls say the race is a dead heat right now, but you wouldn't know it from the way people in this forum talk. Personally, I think the 'everyone is an idiot except for me' stance is arrogant and naive, but it does seem to be the popular stance at PF.
Aug30-08, 12:24 AM   #67
 
Quote by russ_watters View Post
Yes, obviously.....well wait - obvious to who? People who are so far to the left they can't even see the center?? The polls say the race is a dead heat right now, but you wouldn't know it from the way people in this forum talk. Personally, I think the 'everyone is an idiot except for me' stance is arrogant and naive, but it does seem to be the popular stance at PF.
I dont think you have to be far left to see this woman's a joke. I'm in the middle and I dont like her.

Honestly, why not a guy like Tom Ridge? Who is this lady that came out of thin air?

So lets see:
-Doesn't support protecting endagered species
-Wants to teach evolution
-Joke of college degree
-Mayor of a small town no one's heard of

Why are republicans not up in arms over this? This woman should be a laughing stock on every major news channel and newspaper so that McCain, out of shame, has to retract his nomination of her and get someone that's more serious.

Why can't there be a debate between two sane, qualified representatives from both parties? Is it really too much to ask?
Aug30-08, 12:45 AM   #68
 
Quote by lisab View Post
IMO, Pelosi as Commander in Chief is much better than Sarah Palin. Pelosi's tough.
I know some Alaskan women. Believe me, they're tough.
She may be a beauty queen but the Alaskan idea of a beauty pagent is "What does she look like in a bikini? Can she skin a moose? What sort of rifle does she own? What sort of truck and snowmobile does she drive?"
Thread Closed
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: CNN: It's McCain and Palin
Thread Forum Replies
Is McCain a war Hero? Current Events 343
McCain Watch Current Events 19
I didn't like McCain... Current Events 11
John McCain Current Events 12