Register to reply

How much damage will a B- in Calc II do to a prospective math/econ/stat PhD

Share this thread:
inknit
#1
Dec22-10, 05:41 PM
P: 59
I know this is a low level math course, but will it screw up my chances for grad school admissions? I plan to apply for grad school in either math, statistics, or economics (not entirely sure yet).

I'm especially pissed by this because I knew the material inside and out, aced every quiz, midterm, and final I took except one - the one I didn't take.

I accidentally skipped my first midterm so that brought my grade down like a *****..Had I gotten even a B on that midterm, I would've received an A for the class.

So how bad is this really? I'm taking Linear Algebra, and Multivariable in the spring. Pretty sure I'll ace them if I pay attention to the exam schedule. Do you think A's in higher level math will render that B- irrelevant?

Thanks.
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Mysterious source of ozone-depleting chemical baffles NASA
Water leads to chemical that gunks up biofuels production
How lizards regenerate their tails: Researchers discover genetic 'recipe'
mrmiller1
#2
Dec22-10, 05:46 PM
P: 51
I would re-take the course. You already know the material and MORE so it shouldn't take up a lot of your time.
inknit
#3
Dec22-10, 05:48 PM
P: 59
Retake? That would be a huge waste of my time. Besides, retaking it won't erase that B-.

chiro
#4
Dec22-10, 05:53 PM
P: 4,573
How much damage will a B- in Calc II do to a prospective math/econ/stat PhD

Quote Quote by inknit View Post
I know this is a low level math course, but will it screw up my chances for grad school admissions? I plan to apply for grad school in either math, statistics, or economics (not entirely sure yet).

I'm especially pissed by this because I knew the material inside and out, aced every quiz, midterm, and final I took except one - the one I didn't take.

I accidentally skipped my first midterm so that brought my grade down like a *****..Had I gotten even a B on that midterm, I would've received an A for the class.

So how bad is this really? I'm taking Linear Algebra, and Multivariable in the spring. Pretty sure I'll ace them if I pay attention to the exam schedule. Do you think A's in higher level math will render that B- irrelevant?

Thanks.
I'm still an undergraduate but from what I've read on these forums of people who have gotten a PhD, a large majority say that your grades in higher level courses, research experience and letters of recommendation are the ones that matter.

I think that if you ace high level courses, then the lower level courses won't impact as much. Besides, everyone makes mistakes and has to learn from them: if we didn't tolerate mistakes, we wouldn't really get far as a race.
inknit
#5
Dec22-10, 05:57 PM
P: 59
This is my first semester btw.
Angry Citizen
#6
Dec22-10, 06:08 PM
P: 867
You're kidding, right? A B is a good grade. This isn't high school. You're not expected to have a string of A's. Please understand this as you move forward in school. Worry about getting C's, not the occasional B.
Chaostamer
#7
Dec22-10, 06:15 PM
P: 104
Quote Quote by Angry Citizen View Post
You're kidding, right? A B is a good grade. This isn't high school. You're not expected to have a string of A's. Please understand this as you move forward in school. Worry about getting C's, not the occasional B.
Even an occasional 'C' won't ruin you. For example, if you're a Math student and your interest is Analysis, it won't be too harmful if you get a 'C' in PDEs but an 'A' in your Analysis classes and Topology, for example.
Jokerhelper
#8
Dec23-10, 04:14 AM
P: 183
BTW, how do you accidentally skip a midterm?
pr0blumz
#9
Dec23-10, 05:30 AM
P: 66
Quote Quote by Jokerhelper View Post
BTW, how do you accidentally skip a midterm?
I was wondering the same thing.
inknit
#10
Dec23-10, 01:26 PM
P: 59
I forgot I had one that day.
Jokerhelper
#11
Dec24-10, 04:13 AM
P: 183
Quote Quote by inknit View Post
I forgot I had one that day.
...
PhanthomJay
#12
Dec24-10, 04:42 AM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
PhanthomJay's Avatar
P: 6,038
Keep up your GPA. A 3.1 or higher, preferrably 3.3 or higher, is what you want in the end. A 'cum laude' degree, goes a long way. Getting a C in your freshman year doesn't mean that much....it's your overall performance over 4 years, especially in the later year courses, that matters.
diligence
#13
Dec24-10, 04:50 AM
P: 144
don't take this the wrong way since it's honestly the only real truth of this matter: you should stop worrying about the B- but rather figure out why you "forgot" about a midterm exam. i can't even begin to understand how that's even possible for a serious student who wants to go to graduate school!!!!!
lurky
#14
Dec24-10, 12:01 PM
P: 59
Use an electronic calendar of some sort. I use one and I have it programmed to send me e-mail each morning with that day's agenda, send me SMS messages about 20 minutes before an exam, and send me popups on both my computer and my phone as well (so I get lots of beeping on my phone, basically). Works perfectly. Do something like this and you'll never forget anything ever again, unless you fail to enter it into the calendar in the first place.
Leveret
#15
Dec24-10, 03:17 PM
P: 105
Quote Quote by inknit View Post
Retake? That would be a huge waste of my time. Besides, retaking it won't erase that B-.
Are you sure about that? You may want to check with your advisor; I think my school, at least, replaces the lower grade on your transcript if you retake a course and do better.

At any rate, since you know the material, you'll only have to take time to go to exams this time around (all of them, mind you!)
inknit
#16
Dec24-10, 03:25 PM
P: 59
I'm taking linear algebra and calc III next semester, so I don't think I'm taking it again.
mathwonk
#17
Dec24-10, 11:25 PM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
mathwonk's Avatar
P: 9,470
why are you asking us this question? do you really think what we say will have any effect on your future?

go talk to the professor. he/she is the one who will write the letter that will explain why you got the grade. by the way, i got a D- in calc II, and now I am a renowned genius. or a renowned moron, depending on who[m?] you ask.

[do you want to know which, before heeding my advice?] (or perhaps my answer makes it evident!)


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Econ Math Problem! Precalculus Mathematics Homework 2
Undergrad. Chem/Math Major: Numerical Analy. or Stat. Theory Course? Academic Guidance 0
Prospective Physics/Math Schedule Academic Guidance 8
Catching up in math after calc 1 failure. Academic Guidance 21
Prospective Math Major Here... Academic Guidance 10