
#1
Mar1312, 11:57 AM

P: 2

I have a friend who insists in an idea and I want to prove to him that it cannot work because it would violate basic physical laws.
But somehow I don't find the right words. He says if he drilled a well of 2km (or any other depth) into the earth and at the bottom there was a pump that pumped water through a pipe back into to the head of the well he could create more electric energy than the pump would be using. He would install a few, not just one, turbines into the well at different heights, where the sum of energy generated by all turbines is greater than the energy needed to pump all the water up. Now according to this: A simple formula for approximating electric power production at a hydroelectric plant is: where P is Power in kilowatts, h is height in meters, r is flow rate in cubic meters per second, g is acceleration due to gravity of 9.8 m/s2, and k is a coefficient of efficiency ranging from 0 to 1. the only parameter that is different for all turbines is the height. Unless the flow rate is changing. This formula is similiar for pumps. Leaving acceleration (fixed) and water density and losses aside the only parameters ar flow rate and height. It looks like very easy to explain why it cannot work, yet... Does anyone have a calculation example? 



#2
Mar1312, 12:29 PM

P: 459

The formula quoted is for the energy available from an uninterrupted flow, assuming that each turbine is 100% efficient then at the outlet of each turbine the velocity flow will be zero and you have to plug inthe numbers for the drop to the next turbine.



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Heat Pumps  Minimum Power  Advanced Physics Homework  1  
Maximum flow rates through water turbines given power and head.  Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework  3  
Power issues with power drill physics help needed please  General Physics  31  
Alternative method for power assessment of small wind turbines  Mechanical Engineering  12  
Help needed fast :S Characteristics of the power method and the inverse power method  Calculus & Beyond Homework  1 