Register to reply 
Derivation of gauge condition in linearized GR 
Share this thread: 
#1
Feb1113, 11:58 AM

C. Spirit
Sci Advisor
Thanks
P: 5,427

Hey there guys! So we know that in linearized GR we work with small perturbations [itex]\gamma _{ab}[/itex] of the background flat minkowski metric. In deriving the linearized field equations the quantity [itex]\bar{\gamma _{ab}} = \gamma _{ab}  \frac{1}{2}\eta _{ab}\gamma [/itex] is usually defined, where [itex]\gamma = \gamma ^{a}_{a}[/itex]. Under the action of an infinitesimal diffeomorphism (generator of flow), [itex]\gamma _{ab}[/itex] transforms as [itex]\gamma' _{ab} = \gamma _{ab} + \partial _{b}\xi _{a} + \partial _{a}\xi _{b}[/itex] (this comes out of the lie derivative of the minkowski metric with respect to the flow generated by this vector field). This implies that [itex]\bar{\gamma' _{ab}} = \bar{\gamma _{ab}} + \partial _{b}\xi _{a} + \partial _{a}\xi _{b}  \eta _{ab}\partial^{c}\xi _{c}[/itex]. Since we have the freedom to then fix the gauge by choosing some [itex]\xi ^{a}[/itex], we can take one satisfying [itex]\partial ^{b}\partial _{b}\xi _{a} = \partial ^{b}\bar{\gamma _{ab}}[/itex] which, after differentiating the expression for [itex]\bar{\gamma' _{ab}}[/itex], gives [itex]\partial^{b}\bar{\gamma' _{ab}} = 0[/itex]. Apparently we can then conclude from this that [itex]\partial^{b}\bar{\gamma _{ab}} = 0[/itex] but why is that? Is it because in a background flat space  time we can regard [itex]\partial^{b}\bar{\gamma' _{ab}} = 0[/itex] as a covariant equation due to being able to treat [itex]\triangledown _{a}[/itex] as [itex]\partial _{a}[/itex] therefore, since [itex]\bar{\gamma '_{ab}}, \bar{\gamma _{ab}}[/itex] are related by a diffeomorphism, the equation must remain invariant under the transformation [itex]\bar{\gamma '_{ab}}\rightarrow \bar{\gamma _{ab}}[/itex] (in the context of GR)?



#2
Feb1113, 04:45 PM

Sci Advisor
Thanks
P: 4,160

I don't see the difference. You use the gauge transformation to put γ_{ab} into the Hilbert gauge and then just drop the prime.



#3
Feb1113, 04:52 PM

C. Spirit
Sci Advisor
Thanks
P: 5,427

Hi Bill! Thanks for responding. My question is why are we allowed to drop the prime? Thanks again mate.



#4
Feb1113, 08:41 PM

Sci Advisor
P: 8,374

Derivation of gauge condition in linearized GR
Seems to be a discussion after Eq 20, 21 of http://www.tapir.caltech.edu/~chirata/ph236/lec08.pdf. Something about nonuniqueness of the gauge.



#5
Feb1213, 06:59 AM

Sci Advisor
Thanks
P: 4,160

By the way, in gravity this gauge condition IS called the Hilbert gauge, not the "Lorentz gauge", which pertains to electromagnetism. And "Lorentz gauge" itself is incorrect. Quoting Wikipedia, 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
How to arrive at Lorentz gauge condition?  Classical Physics  7  
Linearized Gravity and the TransverseTraceless Gauge Conditions  Advanced Physics Homework  0  
Derivation of (linearized) perturbation equations  Cosmology  2  
Linearized gravity / Linearized Einstein Field Equations / GEM  Special & General Relativity  1 