- #1
JerryG
- 58
- 0
I am an electrical engineering student and I want to buy a good multimeter. Can anyone recommend on of these two models or tell me what the primary advantages of each on is?
turbo-1 said:Capacitance, frequency, and RMS evaluations of noisy signals all got me to spend a few extra bucks on the Extech. I had several basic DMMs, including a pocket model, but I needed to be able to evaluate old (possibly dried-out) capacitors in guitar amps. I used to work on Fenders a lot, and Leo was not known for buying top-shelf components. If you use those old amps regularly, the filter caps can last a long time. Long periods of inaction can accelerate the degradation. Old amps can look wonderful, but sound like crap - check the caps.
berkeman said:I still remember the old joke (from another analog guy that I used to work with)... "If it works, it's a Fluke!" .
waht said:One of my profs used to say that to a class. All the students had blank stares. I replied "77 or 87?"
Probably true, but the meter helped me weed out the dogs. Look at a Fender guitar amp schematic to see what I mean. Bulk replacement was not always necessary. I had one customer that wanted me to peel the paper covers back from old caps and use them to cover the smaller more modern caps. I refused, and told him to take his business elsewhere. He relented, and got some nice bright Astrons instead. I had removed enough stupid mods from his vintage amps and got them singing again that he chose pragmatism.waht said:I think capacitance will not really tell you the condition of the capacitor accurately. For that there is an ESR meter which measures internal resistance of a capacitor. Alot of bad caps can look fine and show good capacitance, but still can have high ESR.
The Fluke 87v and 28-II are both high-quality multimeters, but they have some key differences. The 87v has a higher voltage range (1000V) compared to the 28-II (600V), making it better for industrial and high-energy applications. The 28-II, on the other hand, has a higher frequency range (100kHz) compared to the 87v (20kHz), making it better for electronics and telecommunications work. The 87v also has additional features such as temperature measurement and a low pass filter, while the 28-II has a built-in flashlight and backlit display.
Both the Fluke 87v and 28-II are suitable for measuring resistance, but the 87v has a slightly higher accuracy with a range of 0.1 ohms to 50 megaohms compared to the 28-II's range of 0.1 ohms to 10 megaohms. However, for most everyday use, the difference in accuracy may not be significant.
Yes, both multimeters can measure both AC and DC voltage. The Fluke 87v has a higher voltage range of 1000V compared to the 28-II's range of 600V, making it more suitable for industrial applications where higher voltages may be present.
Yes, both multimeters are known for their durability and ruggedness. They are designed to withstand high impact and have a CAT IV safety rating, making them suitable for use in industrial and high-energy environments.
Yes, both multimeters come with a limited lifetime warranty, which covers any defects in materials or workmanship. However, the warranty may not cover damage caused by misuse or neglect.