- #1
jmblock2
- 9
- 0
It's a question I've been lingering on to for some years now. If the laws of physics are invariant in time, then energy is conserved through time. Shouldn't that imply there is no free-will; there is no room in the laws of physics for energy to be shifted around inside each one of our brains as if we did have free-will? And furthermore, each moment of free-will would have to have a further change in the laws, for each and every one of us for each new free thought we have.
*Edit* And I do realize that it is still an open-ended question what the exact laws of physics are and if they are actually invariant over time. But they appear to be exactly invariant in time at least in our local region of spacetime.
Thoughts? I hope this is the right topic. It's heavy in physics, but maybe it should still be under philosophy?
And has anyone heard of any similar arguments against free-will before?
Thanks!
Jacob
*Edit* And I do realize that it is still an open-ended question what the exact laws of physics are and if they are actually invariant over time. But they appear to be exactly invariant in time at least in our local region of spacetime.
Thoughts? I hope this is the right topic. It's heavy in physics, but maybe it should still be under philosophy?
And has anyone heard of any similar arguments against free-will before?
Thanks!
Jacob