Can any type light bulb be powered by gas?

AI Thread Summary
Halogen and incandescent light bulbs are primarily designed to be powered by electricity. While theoretically, an incandescent bulb could be heated by gas passing through a hollow filament, this concept has not been mass-produced or widely implemented due to the inefficiency of such a method. Gas lamps, which produce light through burning gas, do not contain traditional light bulbs; instead, they emit light directly from the flame. The discussion highlights that while flames can produce light through incandescence, the definition of a light bulb typically involves a filament that generates light through electrical resistance. Historical references include the thorium-containing incandescent mantle, which was developed in the 19th century and utilized gas to create light, but this is distinct from conventional light bulbs. Additionally, legal definitions of incandescent lighting have evolved, particularly in the UK, where regulations previously restricted LED lights in favor of traditional incandescent sources.
stickythighs
Messages
37
Reaction score
0
Can a halogen light bulb be powered by gas, or can a halogen light bulb only be powered by electricity?

Can an incandescent light bulb be powered by gas, or can an incandescent light bulb only be powered by electricity?
 
Computer science news on Phys.org
stickythighs said:
Can a halogen light bulb be powered by gas, or can a halogen light bulb only be powered by electricity?

Can an incandescent light bulb be powered by gas, or can an incandescent light bulb only be powered by electricity?

An incandescent light bulb only needs the filament to be heated, so I suppose you could have a hollow filament with very hot gas passing through the centre and heating it.

A halogen light bulb is just an incandescent light bulb whose filament is surrounded by a halogen, which let's it get hotter while lengthening its life. :smile:
 
tiny-tim said:
An incandescent light bulb only needs the filament to be heated, so I suppose you could have a hollow filament with very hot gas passing through the centre and heating it.

Are there (or have there ever been) incandescent light bulbs that were powered by gas and mass-produced?
 
No. I'm not even really sure what the point would be. The burning gas would give off more light than the filament!

Judging by your other thread, I'm not sure you understand something here: a gas lamp doesn't have a ligth bulb in it.
 
russ_watters said:
The burning gas would give off more light than the filament!

That's why I'm putting it inside the filament! :wink:
 
russ_watters said:
No. I'm not even really sure what the point would be. The burning gas would give off more light than the filament!

Do you concur with tiny_tim that a gas light is basically just a torch that is powered by gas?


Judging by your other thread, I'm not sure you understand something here: a gas lamp doesn't have a ligth bulb in it.

I've seen gas lights in which the flame is enclosed in a glass box. By definition, does a light enclosed by glass have to have a filament that is lit by incandescence in order to be a light bulb?
 
Yes, a gas light is just a torch. The flame gives off light. I'm not sure it that is incandescence or not. I think it is - the flame glows because it is hot and contains impurities. Some types of flames give off light via other processes though, so I'm not certain if that's really incandescence or not. We've had that question enough times though, I aught to know by now...
 
tiny-tim said:
That's why I'm putting it inside the filament! :wink:
Yeah, missed that part, sorry. That would be interesting - I wonder if its ever been done (it is done for infrared, but I haven't heard of it for visible light).
 
  • #10
russ_watters said:
The flame gives off light. I'm not sure it that is incandescence or not.

Incandescence is light due to heat - it is an important question because the law in the UK said that you had to have an "incandescent light" which banned LED bike lights.

It got changed recently when EU car makers started fitting LED lights.
Until then you could be stopped for having an LED light which both exceeded laser eye safety limits and wasn't considered accepatable illimunation!
 
Back
Top