
#1
Nov2510, 04:00 PM

P: 21

Block A rests on block B, which lies on a flat frictionless surface. There is friction only between the two blocks. If I were to exert on block A a horizontal force of magnitude less than that of the maximum static frictional force between the two blocks so that for block A Fnet,x=0, then block B would receive an equal frictional reaction force in the opposite direction. That block A would remain stationary while block B would accelerate in the direction of the force is clearly counterintuitive. Can someone please point out the flaw in my thinking?
Thanks! 



#2
Nov2510, 06:14 PM

P: 7

I'm not exactly sure if this is the answer you're looking for, but I'll give it a go anyways.
If the force F you exert on A is smaller than the static friction between the two blocks, they will not move relatively to each other. Therefore you can consider the two blocks as being one block with the total mass M = m_A + m_B. They will move forward with constant acceleration a = F/M 



#3
Nov2510, 06:14 PM

P: 96

Hi mr.physics
you have two equations governing the motion parallel to the surface [tex]m_A a_A = F  f_{fr}[/tex] [tex]m_B a_B = f_{fr}[/tex] with an additional constraint  if we are to have static friction that the two blocks are at rest relatively to each other. Assuming they both start at rest, this requirement imposes the same acceleration on them: [tex]\frac{F  f_{fr}}{m_A}=\frac{f_{fr}}{m_B}[/tex] [tex]F=f_{fr}(1+\frac{m_A}{m_B}) \leq \mu_S m_A g (1+\frac{m_A}{m_B}) [/tex] which is the maximum force that can be applied to A for static friction to hold the two blocks together Please doublecheck and let me know if this is convincing 



#4
Nov2510, 06:33 PM

P: 7

Friction between two stacked blocksIt DOES seem a little weird though. Wouldn't you normally just think that the force F applied just has to be smaller than the maximum possible static friction which is f_statis = mu_s * mass_a * g ? 



#5
Nov2510, 06:46 PM

P: 96

I agree this is not very intuitive but the result seems to have the right limit behavior so I guess this is one of those cases were math helps.




#6
Nov2510, 06:51 PM

P: 7

Force equilibrium (at max static friction): F  mu_s * m * g = 0. The moment F gets bigger than mu_s * m * g, there is no longer force equilibrium, thus the block A will accelerate relatively to the table (or block B). So....?! Both my physical arguments and your mathematical arguments seem to be right. What IS right then :P ? 



#7
Nov2510, 07:17 PM

P: 96

Hi doubleyou
I am not sure I am getting your counterexample: if the block B is very massive (is that what you mean by table?) from [tex]F \leq \mu_S m_A g (1+ m_A / m_B)[/tex] one gets the usual result [tex]F \leq \mu_S m_A g [/tex] What am I missing? 



#8
Nov2610, 01:36 AM

HW Helper
P: 6,925

Getting back to the OP:




#9
Nov2610, 01:43 AM

P: 96

what is this adding to the previous replies?




#10
Nov2610, 02:26 AM

P: 7





#11
Nov2610, 04:24 AM

P: 21

mu_Sm_A g < F < mu_S m_A g (1+(m_A)/(m_B) and a_A is not equal to a_B, so block A should be accelerating relative to block B (kinetic friction) and the blocks are not moving together. I think that from the way you have formulated your equations, a_A = a_B only in the specific scenario when F=mu_S m_A g (1+(m_A)/(m_B). For values of F when [tex] F \leq\ mu_Sm_A g [/tex], [tex] f_{fr} = F [/tex] so your equations indicate that [tex]m_A a_A = F  f_{fr} =0 [/tex] and if [tex] a_A [/tex] and [tex] a_B [/tex] are forcibly set equal because the friction is static, you should arrive at [tex]\frac{o}{m_A}=\frac{f_{fr}}{m_B}[/tex], an inconsistency. So I'm not sure [tex]F_{max} [/tex] <= [tex] mu_S m_A g (1+\frac{m_A}{m_B}) [/tex] are the correct values of F for which the two blocks don't slide relative to each other. 



#12
Nov2710, 01:05 AM

P: 96

 to have the interfaces moving at the same speed (be at rest wrt to each other)  for the friction force to be LESS THAN (not equal to) the product of static friction coefficient and normal reaction of the interface My equations simply answer the following question: under what conditions are the two blocks moving together (same acceleration, same initial conditions)? The answer of Newton's equations is [tex]F \leq \mu_S m_A g (1+\frac{m_A}{m_B}) [/tex] even if this is not intuitive, it is correct so you will have to attune your intuition to it 



#13
Nov2710, 03:22 AM

P: 21

Sorry, I must still be misunderstanding something. If [tex]F \leq \mu_S m_A g (1+\frac{m_A}{m_B}) [/tex] there will be some values of F when it is greater than "the product of static friction coefficient and normal reaction of the interface". Right? 



#14
Nov2710, 03:58 AM

HW Helper
P: 6,925





#15
Nov2710, 04:47 AM

P: 96

 F is not a friction force but the force applied to block A  F can be larger than the maximum value of static friction, [tex] \mu_S m_A g [/tex]  [tex]f_{fr}[/tex] (the friction force) cannot be larger than [tex] \mu_S m_A g [/tex](and will not be as long as the quoted constraint on F is respected)  F can be larger than [tex]f_{fr}[/tex] because of acceleration 



#16
Nov2710, 04:51 AM

P: 21

But when F is greater than F(fr) doesn't that mean the friction is no longer static?




#17
Nov2710, 05:02 AM

P: 96

If the object is not moving the applied force (or better its component parallel to the friction direction) and friction have the same magnitude but if the object is moving as in your case since friction occurs with another moving body they will differ by ma 



#18
Nov2710, 11:28 AM

P: 21

I think i'm beginning to understand what you are saying. If either of you has time can you post up an example in which you solve for the Fneta, Fnetb, and the friction force given some F greater than the maximum_static_friction_force and less than mu_S m_A g (1+(m_A)/(m_B)? Thanks



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
two blocks stacked on one another  Introductory Physics Homework  17  
Stacked Blocks Question  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
Stacked blocks  Introductory Physics Homework  5  
Two stacked blocks, push using one block, static friction between blocks  Introductory Physics Homework  0  
Forces acting on two blocks stacked one on another  Introductory Physics Homework  4 