How Long to Ingest an Earth-Size Planet?

  • Thread starter Thread starter wolram
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Planet
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the ingestion time of an Earth-sized planet by a 100-solar mass black hole, emphasizing that the ingestion rate depends on the black hole's mass, the object's approach speed, and tidal forces. Tidal forces would likely tear the Earth apart, forming an accretion disk before the black hole could fully consume it. The energy released from friction in the accretion disk could eject a significant portion of Earth's mass into space. The conversation also touches on the rarity of mid-sized black holes, noting that most are smaller, around 5-15 solar masses. Overall, the process of ingestion is complex and could take an effectively infinite time due to these dynamics.
wolram
Gold Member
Dearly Missed
Messages
4,410
Reaction score
555
Take a small bh say 100 sol masses, how long would it take to ingest a Earth size planet?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
wolram said:
Take a small bh say 100 sol masses, how long would it take to ingest a Earth size planet?

Depends - I think black holes are hungrier in the mornings, I know I am!

On a serious note - the ingestion rate would be directly proportional to mass of the BH and I suspect the angle/inclination and speed of the approaching object may have an impact. Then again tidal forces may be so strong as to render the approach dynamics irrelevant. There is also reference frames to consider. From the reference frame of the infalling Earth mass, the time would be fairly quick, from the reference frame of a relatavistic observer you would see a different result.

However I suspect the mass would have been smashed into an accretion disk long before all of this matter is gobbled up by the hungry hole.

Any more knowledgeable posts welcome as I find a Black Hole appetite fairly interesting!
 
A 100-solar mass black hole has a Schwarzschild radius of about 300 km, a lot smaller than Earth's radius. Tidal forces would tear Earth apart as it approached the black hole, creating an accretion disc. Friction in the accretion disc would release vast amounts of energy, blowing a substantial portion of Earth's mass completely away from the interaction (to ∞ and beyond?). So the pedantic answer is forever.
 
wolram said:
Take a small bh say 100 sol masses, how long would it take to ingest a Earth size planet?
Others have answered your question, so I'll just nitpick: 100 solar masses is pretty big for an astrophysical black hole (though obviously very small for a supermassive one!). We expect most black holes that are not the nuclei of galaxies to be closer to 5-15 solar masses, give or take. I don't think 100 solar mass black holes are nonexistent, just that there are likely a heck of a lot more smaller ones out there, so that I wouldn't call that particularly small.
 
Chalnoth said:
Others have answered your question, so I'll just nitpick: 100 solar masses is pretty big for an astrophysical black hole (though obviously very small for a supermassive one!). We expect most black holes that are not the nuclei of galaxies to be closer to 5-15 solar masses, give or take. I don't think 100 solar mass black holes are nonexistent, just that there are likely a heck of a lot more smaller ones out there, so that I wouldn't call that particularly small.

If I recall correctly the lack of mid size black holes is a hot topic at the moment.
 
If the Earth gets torn apart by tidal forces and is turned into an accretion disk, what does that mean? Does that mean that the matter in the disk tumbles into the black hole in a spiral?
 
SHISHKABOB said:
If the Earth gets torn apart by tidal forces and is turned into an accretion disk, what does that mean? Does that mean that the matter in the disk tumbles into the black hole in a spiral?

Thats a fairly accurate layman description. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accretion_disc for more info.
 
Back
Top