- #1
MikeeMiracle
- 398
- 310
- TL;DR Summary
- By what process do different sized stars form?
So the standard explanation for star formation says we have a disk of gas collapsing into itself until a certain pressure/temperature is reached at which point the star "ignites" and pushes away the rest of the material in the disk.
My thinking is, surely this pressure/temperature needed for ignition is the same for all stars? This line of thinking leads on to all stars being the same size when they first ignite? Using this logic, should all starts not be the same size?
I know I am missing something but doing web searches are only bringing up "how a star forms" answers and no explanations for why we have different sizes of star.
Clearly stars exist in many different sizes and temperatures so...which part of the puzzle am I missing and not taking into account that can explain the multitude of different star sizes? Logic would point to the stars igniting at different points and my previous statement about the pressure/temperature required for ignition being different for different stars...but why would this be so? Surely at the temperatures required, all matter just exists as plasma anyway?
Thanks
My thinking is, surely this pressure/temperature needed for ignition is the same for all stars? This line of thinking leads on to all stars being the same size when they first ignite? Using this logic, should all starts not be the same size?
I know I am missing something but doing web searches are only bringing up "how a star forms" answers and no explanations for why we have different sizes of star.
Clearly stars exist in many different sizes and temperatures so...which part of the puzzle am I missing and not taking into account that can explain the multitude of different star sizes? Logic would point to the stars igniting at different points and my previous statement about the pressure/temperature required for ignition being different for different stars...but why would this be so? Surely at the temperatures required, all matter just exists as plasma anyway?
Thanks