Designing a spiral with a certain angle relative to movement direction

In summary, the disk will have a pin that can move back and forth in a slot in a gear, and will only be able to switch tracks when it reaches a point. The spiral is self-similar, meaning that if you "blow it up" uniformly it can be laid atop the smaller version exactly.
  • #1
DefinitelyAnEnjinear
10
6
TL;DR Summary
Designing a spiral with a 45 degree angle relative to the movement of a disk orbiting around a point
I have a disk traveling on the inner blue track (let's say the blue part is the center of the disk).
I want to push the disk outside (as the disk is traveling in a circle) to the outer track.
The black part is the wall separating the tracks

1664044007937.png

To that end, I've made some calculations, but I have some concerns regarding my results, and am wondering if there's a better way to go about it.
I have a decent math background, but no engineering background at all.

I started out by noting the direction of movement for the disk, say it's moving counter-clockwise. If c is a point on the inner circle (for simplicity: unit circle), then the movement direction is determined as follows:
1664044216960.gif

Also, some relevant trigonometric identities:
1664044360242.gif

where Δθ is the angle between u and v.

Let's say I want a 45 degree angle between my spiral and the movement direction of the disk (my very limited physics knowledge tells me a steeper angle would require more force to be applied because more of the "equal and opposite reaction" thing would be in the direction that's against the disk movement. Obviously a smaller angle would mean it takes longer to get the disk as far as I need it to go).
The sine and cosine of 45 degrees go without saying, yielding:
1664047123247.gif

And after doing some mathTM
1664044740436.gif

1664047195662.gif

So now we have v, which... I'm not sure how to put this into words in a technically accurate way, so let's say it's the direction of the tangent to the spiral. Meaning its slope is that of the derivative. Meaning:
1664048026581.gif

is the derivative of the function describing my spiral, with α being the angle between the x-axis and the vector pointing to some point on the circle.

This is the part where I start to get worried and confused, because (1) I potentially have a division by 0 here, and (2) the point is to move the disk during rotation and I'm not sure if my reasoning still holds at this point.

With a little help from wikipedia I got to:
1664048286861.gif

Being my derivative.
So if, say, I wanted to start the transition when we're at 45 degrees... I start off on a singularity.

So, did I get anything wrong? Is there a better approach to solving this problem?
 
  • Like
Likes The Bill
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
Try researching "equiangular spiral" (or Bernoulli spiral or logarithmic spiral). Does that help?
 
  • Like
Likes The Bill and DefinitelyAnEnjinear
  • #3
What is driving the rotation and what is forcing the disc to follow the circular trajectories and switch from one to another?
 
  • #4
hutchphd said:
Try researching "equiangular spiral" (or Bernoulli spiral or logarithmic spiral). Does that help?
A brief look tells me the distances increase geometrically as opposed to an Archimedean spiral where the distances increase by a constant. Is this really what I should be looking at? my intuition tells me I need distances that increase by a constant, don't I?

Edit: I see now that the angle remains a constant according to wikipedia. counter-intuitive to me but it definitely seems like the answer.

Lnewqban said:
What is driving the rotation and what is forcing the disc to follow the circular trajectories and switch from one to another?
1664051376636.png

The disk will have a pin in it that will be able to move back and forth in a slot in a gear which will be driven.
There will be a wall preventing the disk from switching tracks until it reaches the point
I didn't want to complicate the question with details that seem unimportant.
 
  • Like
Likes The Bill
  • #5
DefinitelyAnEnjinear said:
intuitive to me but it definitely seems like the answer.
What I find interesting (and obvious, after you see it!) is that the spiral is self-similar: If you "blow it up" uniformly it can be laid atop the smaller version exactly (with a rotation). Of course that follows from the equal angle requirement. Fun.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes The Bill and DefinitelyAnEnjinear
  • #6
DefinitelyAnEnjinear said:
...
The disk will have a pin in it that will be able to move back and forth in a slot in a gear which will be driven.
There will be a wall preventing the disk from switching tracks until it reaches the point
I didn't want to complicate the question with details that seem unimportant.
I see.
Thank you.
 

1. How do you determine the angle of a spiral relative to movement direction?

The angle of a spiral can be determined by first defining the direction of movement, and then using trigonometric functions to calculate the desired angle. This can be done using the tangent function, where the angle of the spiral is equal to the inverse tangent of the ratio of the change in y-coordinate to the change in x-coordinate.

2. Can the angle of a spiral be changed after it has been designed?

Yes, the angle of a spiral can be changed after it has been designed. This can be done by adjusting the parameters used in the original design, such as the rate of change of the spiral or the starting angle.

3. What is the purpose of designing a spiral with a certain angle relative to movement direction?

The purpose of designing a spiral with a certain angle relative to movement direction is to create a visually appealing and efficient shape for various applications. This can include creating spiral staircases, coiled ropes, or even the shape of galaxies.

4. Are there any limitations to designing a spiral with a certain angle relative to movement direction?

There are some limitations to designing a spiral with a certain angle relative to movement direction. These limitations may include the availability of materials, the desired level of precision, and the intended use of the spiral.

5. Can a spiral be designed with multiple angles relative to movement direction?

Yes, a spiral can be designed with multiple angles relative to movement direction. This can be achieved by using different parameters for different sections of the spiral, creating a more complex and dynamic shape.

Similar threads

Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
2
Views
730
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
21
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
955
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Differential Geometry
Replies
3
Views
2K
Back
Top