Explanation for the Fountain effect in superfluids

In summary, the fountain effect in superfluids is caused by the 'two fluid model'. When the heater in the tube is turned on, the liquid helium in the tube begins to warm up. Since superfluid helium flows from cool areas to warm areas, superfluid helium flows into the tube through the porous plug. Normal fluid is too viscous to flow out through the porous plug. Therefore, when the tube fills with liquid helium, the only way out for the normal fluid is to squirt out the hole in the top.
  • #1
BobGom
11
0
I'm looking for an explanation for the fountain effect in superfluids using the 'two fluid model'. However the explanations I've come across are not very satisfactory

From the NASA website

http://cryo.gsfc.nasa.gov/introduction/liquid_helium.html

Here is the two fluid model explanation of the fountain effect. When the heater in the tube is turned on, the liquid helium in the tube begins to warm up. Since superfluid helium flows from cool areas to warm areas, superfluid helium flows into the tube through the porous plug. Normal fluid is too viscous to flow out through the porous plug. Therefore, when the tube fills with liquid helium, the only way out for the normal fluid is to squirt out the hole in the top.

But why does superfluid Helium flow from cool areas to warm areas? Unless I'm missing something that it is not a property of all fluids is it? The wiki article on Helium says

In the fountain effect, a chamber is constructed which is connected to a reservoir of helium II by a sintered disc through which superfluid helium leaks easily but through which non-superfluid helium cannot pass. If the interior of the container is heated, the superfluid helium changes to non-superfluid helium. In order to maintain the equilibrium fraction of superfluid helium, superfluid helium leaks through and increases the pressure, causing liquid to fountain out of the container.

But I don't see why the system needs to maintain the same fraction of superfluid helium. Surely at higher temperatures there is a lower equilibrium fraction of superfluid.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The analogy is that of partial pressure. Like with osmosis you get osmotic pressure if you have an uneven concentration of some salt. If you have an uneven concentration of suprafluid helium it is the same
 
  • #3
BobGom said:
I'm looking for an explanation for the fountain effect in superfluids using the 'two fluid model'. However the explanations I've come across are not very satisfactory

Yes, this fact is known. Even Feynman couldn't explore theory of superfluidity in details.
You can see his book on statistical mechanics (last edition) and see that Feynman suggest to publish anybody paper explaining lambda point curve in He4. He couldn't get second order phase transition curve himself (only third order phase transition for Bose codensation).

I also remember, that Feynman main paper on superfluidity didn't deal with the fountain effect. So we don't have so genius author to explain fountain effect now to all of us.

But at the same time we can find such instability in plasma and/or in hydrodynamics as "negative energy wave" (we can google out topical reviews on such instabilities). This instability is famous for moving frames could diminish total energy of the system. So "moving frame" (in our case "superfluid" fraction of He4 can fontain at the expense of total energy.
 

1. What is the fountain effect in superfluids?

The fountain effect in superfluids is a phenomenon in which a liquid, typically helium, will spontaneously rise up and out of a container without any external forces acting on it. This effect is caused by the unique properties of superfluids, which have zero viscosity and can flow without resistance.

2. How does the fountain effect occur in superfluids?

The fountain effect occurs due to a combination of two factors: superfluidity and capillarity. Superfluidity allows the liquid to flow without resistance, while capillarity, which is the tendency of liquids to rise up in thin tubes, helps to push the liquid out of the container.

3. What causes superfluidity in superfluids?

Superfluidity in superfluids is caused by a phenomenon known as Bose-Einstein condensation. This occurs when a collection of particles, in this case helium atoms, are cooled to extremely low temperatures, causing them to lose their individual identities and behave as a single quantum mechanical entity.

4. What is the significance of the fountain effect in superfluids?

The fountain effect in superfluids is not only a fascinating physical phenomenon, but it also has practical applications. It has been observed in liquid helium, which is used in cryogenics, and it has also been studied as a potential method for liquid transport in microfluidic devices.

5. Are there any other examples of superfluidity in nature?

Yes, there are other examples of superfluidity in nature, such as in neutron stars and in certain types of superconductors. However, these are different types of superfluidity with their own unique properties. The fountain effect specifically occurs in superfluid helium, which is the only known fluid to exhibit this behavior.

Similar threads

Replies
17
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
31
Views
1K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
623
  • Mechanics
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • Mechanics
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • Classical Physics
2
Replies
51
Views
7K
Back
Top