How is the information of a change in position of a star transmitted?

In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of gravity as the curvature of spacetime, the motion of stars relative to each other, and the transmission of information through spacetime. The book "Reality is not what it seems - The journey to quantum gravity" by Carlo Rovelli is mentioned, but it is questioned whether the content of a book can be discussed on Physics Forums. The topic of spinfoams and their role in bending spacetime is also brought up, but without a valid reference, it is difficult to discuss this in the context of quantum gravity. The question can be addressed in the framework of classical general relativity, but it would need to be moved to the relativity forum.
  • #1
KurtLudwig
Gold Member
144
30
TL;DR Summary
How is the information of a change in position of a star transmitted through spacetime? What is the quantum mechanism?
Gravity is the curvature of space time. Stars move relative to each other. How is the information of this change transmitted through spacetime? I have just finished reading "Reality is not what it seems - The journey to quantum gravity" by Carlo Rovelli. (Can the content of a book be discussed on Physics Forums?) Does the information quickly travel from spinfoam to spinfoam? See page 186, the section on spinfoams. It is stated that spinfoams will bend spacetime. But it does not describe the mechanism of changes. Maybe it is beyond the scope of this book. I assume that changes happen at the speed of light.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
KurtLudwig said:
I have just finished reading "Reality is not what it seems - The journey to quantum gravity" by Carlo Rovelli. (Can the content of a book be discussed on Physics Forums?)

Not that book, since it's not a textbook.
 
  • #3
KurtLudwig said:
Gravity is the curvature of space time. Stars move relative to each other. How is the information of this change transmitted through spacetime?

"Transmitted through spacetime" is a misnomer. Spacetime is a 4-dimensional geometry. It doesn't "change" and things don't get "transmitted" through it. It just is. The "motion" of the stars is just the geometric shapes of their worldlines (or "world tubes" if, more realistically, you consider them to have finite size) and how those world tubes are embedded in the overall spacetime geometry. The "information" about the stars is just the spacetime curvature at any particular event, which will be determined by the Einstein Field Equation and the stress-energy that is present.

KurtLudwig said:
Does the information quickly travel from spinfoam to spinfoam?

We can't discuss the question on these terms without a valid reference--textbook or peer-reviewed paper--that gives the actual theoretical machinery necessary to address the question in a spin foam theory.

The question can be discussed in the framework of classical GR--that's what I did earlier in this post. But that will have nothing to do with anyone's speculations about quantum gravity. If you're willing to discuss the question as a classical GR question, we can continue to do so in this thread, but in that case it needs to be moved to the relativity forum.
 

1. How is the information of a change in position of a star transmitted?

The information of a change in position of a star is typically transmitted through the use of telescopes and other astronomical instruments. These instruments collect data on the star's position and movement, which is then analyzed and transmitted to other scientists and organizations.

2. Can the information of a change in position of a star be transmitted instantly?

No, the information of a change in position of a star cannot be transmitted instantly. Due to the vast distances between stars and the limitations of technology, it can take anywhere from a few minutes to several years for the information to reach us.

3. How accurate is the information of a change in position of a star?

The accuracy of the information of a change in position of a star depends on the precision of the instruments used to collect the data. With advancements in technology, the accuracy of this information has greatly improved over time.

4. Who is responsible for transmitting the information of a change in position of a star?

The responsibility for transmitting the information of a change in position of a star falls on a variety of individuals and organizations, including astronomers, scientists, and space agencies. These individuals and organizations work together to collect, analyze, and share this information with the scientific community and the general public.

5. How is the information of a change in position of a star used in scientific research?

The information of a change in position of a star is used in a variety of ways in scientific research. It can help us understand the behavior and evolution of stars, track the movement of celestial objects, and even provide insights into the structure and composition of the universe.

Similar threads

  • Special and General Relativity
3
Replies
84
Views
3K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
28
Views
3K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
15
Views
3K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
13
Views
6K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
Replies
3
Views
978
  • STEM Career Guidance
Replies
33
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Back
Top