Ice melted by impact of lead bullet

In summary: I see that the value you've used for the specific heat of lead is 0.160 j/g/C, or 160 J/kg/C). Was this a given value in the problem or text that it came from? The reason I ask is that in the tables I've seen the value is generally given to be around 128 J/kg/C.An example is the table of specific heats from the hyperphysics web site, where the entry for lead is 0.128 J/gm K.
  • #1
Erenjaeger
141
6

Homework Statement


A 3.20 g lead bullet at 28.0°C is fired at a speed of 210 m/s into a large block of ice at 0°C, in which it becomes embedded. What mass of ice melts (g)?

Homework Equations


I thought that the KE of the bullet would be transferred into heat

The Attempt at a Solution


I used MV^2/2 = 0.0032x210^2/2
=70.56J
divided that by heat of fusion of ice, 80cal/g
=0.882g
Its wrong tho
someone pls help :) thanks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Erenjaeger said:

Homework Statement


A 3.20 g lead bullet at 28.0°C is fired at a speed of 210 m/s into a large block of ice at 0°C, in which it becomes embedded. What mass of ice melts (g)?
[/B]

Homework Equations


I thought that the KE of the bullet would be transferred into heat [/B]

The Attempt at a Solution


I used MV^2/2 = 0.0032x210^2/2
=70.56J
divided that by heat of fusion of ice, 80cal/g
=0.882g
Its wrong tho
someone pls help :) thanks.[/B]
So you're just dividing numbers willy-nilly and disregarding units? Are calories the same as joules?
 
  • #3
Poster has been reminded not to use text speak at the PF
SteamKing said:
So you're just dividing numbers willy-nilly and disregarding units? Are calories the same as joules?
Are you talking about where i divided 70.56J by 80cal/g because i also tried converting 70.56J into cals and dividing it by 80cal/g again and it didnt work. If not please expand on what you mean buddy
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #4
Erenjaeger said:
R u talking about where i divided 70.56J by 80cal/g because i also tried converting 70.56J into cals and dividing it by 80cal/g again and it didnt work. If not pls expand on wot u mean buddy
You didn't show any attempt at converting joules to calories or vice versa, so how are we to guess what you did? How do we know you even did the right conversion?

BTW, text speak is not welcome at PF.
 
  • #5
Erenjaeger said:
A lead bullet at 28.0°C
Presumably you are given this information for a reason. Eg don't just consider the bullets kinetic energy, include it's thermal energy too.
 
  • Like
Likes atom jana
  • #6
billy_joule said:
Presumably you are given this information for a reason. Eg don't just consider the bullets kinetic energy, include it's thermal energy too.
< Mentor Note -- text speak edited out of post >

so thermal energy is
Q=mcΔT
which works out to be 14.336 J
but how do i incorporate that into my working?
My working so far:
We= energy from bullet
=1/2 mv^2 + mc(sub)pΔT
mass in kg
the C(sub)p being specific heat of lead = 0.160 j/g degrees celsius
which comes out to be 70.57J
energy is fully absorbed by the blocked of ice
∴ We=Mi(Hf)
Mi = mass that melted
Hf = heat of fusion of ice
∴Mi=We/Hf
=211.97
which is wrong
Can you please help by explaining where I am going wrong.
thx
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #7
Erenjaeger said:
...

Can u pls help by explaining where I am going wrong.
thx
Please, knock off the "text speak".

The words are spelled, you, please and thanks .
 
  • #8
Erenjaeger said:
so thermal energy is
Q=mcΔT
which works out to be 14.336 J
but how do i incorporate that into my working?
My working so far:
We= energy from bullet
=1/2 mv^2 + mc(sub)pΔT
mass in kg
the C(sub)p being specific heat of lead = 0.160 j/g degrees celsius
which comes out to be 70.57J
energy is fully absorbed by the blocked of ice
∴ We=Mi(Hf)
Mi = mass that melted
Hf = heat of fusion of ice
∴Mi=We/Hf
=211.97
which is wrong
Can u pls help by explaining where I am going wrong.
thx
To recap:

The total heat provided by the bullet is 70.57 J (KE) + 14.336 J (ΔT)

You were given the heat of fusion of ice as 80 cal/g

You must convert joules to calories or vice versa in order to calculate the amount of ice melted by the bullet.
It's not clear which conversion you are using.

Mi = 211.97 what? grams? kgs? Please show units on your results.
 
  • #9
I see that the value you've used for the specific heat of lead is 0.160 j/g/C, or 160 J/kg/C). Was this a given value in the problem or text that it came from? The reason I ask is that in the tables I've seen the value is generally given to be around 128 J/kg/C.
 
  • #10
gneill said:
I see that the value you've used for the specific heat of lead is 0.160 j/g/C, or 160 J/kg/C). Was this a given value in the problem or text that it came from? The reason I ask is that in the tables I've seen the value is generally given to be around 128 J/kg/C.
We weren't given a specific heat of lead value, so I just googled it
 
  • #11

1. How does the impact of a lead bullet cause ice to melt?

The impact of a lead bullet creates a sudden and intense release of energy, which in turn causes a rapid increase in temperature. This increase in temperature causes the ice to melt.

2. Can ice melt from the impact of any type of bullet?

Yes, any type of bullet can cause ice to melt upon impact. However, bullets made of materials with higher melting points, such as copper or steel, may not cause as much melting as lead bullets.

3. Does the size of the bullet affect the amount of ice melted?

Yes, the size of the bullet does play a role in the amount of ice melted. A larger bullet will typically have more mass and therefore more energy upon impact, resulting in a larger area of melted ice.

4. What other factors can influence the amount of ice melted by a lead bullet?

The temperature of the ice, the speed and angle of the bullet, and the composition of the ice (e.g. salt water vs. fresh water) can all impact the amount of ice melted by a lead bullet.

5. Is the melting of ice by a lead bullet a significant environmental concern?

While the melting of ice by a lead bullet may seem concerning, it is not a significant environmental issue. The amount of ice melted by a single bullet is usually minimal and does not pose a threat to the environment.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
995
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
16
Views
2K
Back
Top