My copper electrodes are discoloring, and I'm not sure why

In summary, the conversation discusses building a device to separate ions dissolved in water using copper plates and a magnetic field. However, there are unexpected reactions occurring and the speaker questions the cause. The expert suggests that the observed effects are likely due to electrochemical reactions, and recommends calculating theoretical charges for the copper plates to better understand the situation.
  • #1
Hexnovae
1
0
For a high school school project I'm trying to build a device that will separate ions dissolved in water. I'm pumping water trough a box that has copper plates in it, and I'm putting that in a magnetic field. Because of Lorentz force the ions should bend off to different sides and heap up, creating a charge. Theoretically.

In practice it isn't that easy (it never is, is it?). I built the box, and it appears to work, however there are other things happening that neither I nor my teacher can explain. Take a look at the first image of the imgur album. It's a graph that has the voltage on the vertical axis and time on the horizontal axis. From t=0 until t=40 nothing was on, it was just the box. At t=40 we started pumping water with NaCl dissolved in it and a bit later we turned on the magnet. At the bump at t=120 we inverted the flow of the water and the current of the electromagnet. At the peaks we tried to discharge the plates by plugging it into a battery. It had a negative voltage after that, which went positive and then back to the voltage it had during the first part (25 mV). The copper plates got a dark color after plugging in the battery, which faded as the current went back to 24 mV. They became a matte orange, as you can see in the picture.

When we stop the water flow the charge stays. Even if we short the circuit the charge stays. What is happening here? Obviously some kind of reaction with the copper plates, because they discolor as you can see in the pictures. But what's going on exactly?
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
  • #2
Lorentz force (as long as the voltages involved are measured in volts, not in megavolts) is way too weak to overcome thermal movements of ions. What you observe is most likely some electrochemical reaction (dark coloration may suggest copper was oxidized to CuO) followed by voltage of a galvanic cell.

You may try to estimate charges that can build assuming your copper plates are just a capacitor - estimate its capacity, see what voltage you apply and that's all you need to calculate theoretical charge. You won't get higher charges than that, as these are what is needed to neutralize the electric field created by the potential difference.
 

1. Why are my copper electrodes discoloring?

Copper electrodes may discolor due to a variety of reasons, such as exposure to air or other chemicals, corrosion, or high temperatures. It is important to identify the specific cause in order to address the issue properly.

2. How do I prevent my copper electrodes from discoloring?

To prevent discoloration, make sure to store your copper electrodes in a dry and cool place, away from exposure to air or other chemicals. You can also coat the electrodes with a protective layer, such as varnish or oil, to prevent corrosion.

3. Can discoloration affect the performance of my copper electrodes?

In most cases, discoloration does not affect the performance of copper electrodes. However, if the discoloration is due to corrosion or other damage to the surface, it may impact the conductivity of the electrode. It is important to regularly clean and maintain your electrodes to ensure optimal performance.

4. How do I clean my discolored copper electrodes?

To clean discolored copper electrodes, you can use a mild acid solution, such as vinegar or lemon juice, to remove any buildup or corrosion. Make sure to rinse the electrodes thoroughly with water afterwards and dry them completely before use.

5. Can I still use discolored copper electrodes for my experiments?

In most cases, discoloration does not affect the functionality of copper electrodes. However, if the discoloration is due to corrosion or other damage, it may impact their performance. It is best to regularly check and replace your electrodes if needed to ensure accurate and reliable results.

Similar threads

Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
809
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
1
Views
723
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
5K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
2K
Back
Top