Partial Differential Equations vs Classical Mechanics 2?

In summary: No, it's not silly. Theoretical physicists often have a lot of knowledge in mathematics and it's helpful. It's good to have a strong foundation in mathematics so you can understand the mathematics that theoretical physicists use.
  • #1
Elvis 123456789
158
6
Hello everyone. So I wanted to get some opinions on what some of you thought was a better choice, as far taking PDE's or classical mechanics 2 goes. First let me start off by giving a little info; I've already taken calc 1-3 and ordinary differential equations, physics 1 & 2, thermodynamics/statistical mechanics, modern physics with a modern lab class, and classical mechanics 1. I want to go to grad school in physics, but I am pretty sure that I don't want to be an experimentalist. I do enjoy programming and data analysis, just not messing with instrumentation or taking direct measurements with instruments. So when I apply to grad school it'll either be for computational physics or some area of theoretical physics. My schedule for next semester, as of right now, is the following

Adv Classical Mechanics - Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics, rigid body dynamics, coupled oscillators and normal modes, nonlinear dynamics and chaos, collision theory, continuum mechanics, and special relativity.

Methods in Theoretical Physics - Methods in theoretical physics and theoretical applications in physics. Includes analytic and numerical methods for differential equations, integral equations and transformations and other applications of real analysis.

Intro To Advanced Math - opics include: naive set theory, functions, cardinality, sequences of real numbers and limits. Emphasis on formal proofs

Advanced Differential Equations - A second course in differential equations. Topics may include: Bessel functions and other special functions arising from classical differential equations, Sturm-Liouville problems, partial differential equations, transform techniques.


Linear Algebra - An introduction to the topics in linear algebra most often used in applications. Topics include: matrices and their applications; simultaneous linear equations and elementary operations; linear dependence; vector spaces; rank and inverses; inner products and `best¿ approximations; numerical solutions of simultaneous linear equations; eigen-values and eigenvectors; iterative methods for calculating eigenvalues; and systems of linear equations.

The only class from those above that is actually required for me is the methods in theoretical physics class. I could take all five at the same time, but that seems a little overkill for me. So I was looking to either ditch the PDE's class or the classical mechanics 2 one; what do you guys think?



 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
None of the topics in Intro to Advanced Math course you listed are likely to help you in grad school in physics. I think it would be better to do well in the courses you do take. Quality in four course is better than quantity in five. I think the advance classical mechanics course would be more helpful than partial differential equations if the partial differential equations is taught by the math department. I the partial differential equations course is taught by the Physics department as a Methods in Theoretical Physics course, then maybe partial differential equations would get priority.
 
  • #3
mpresic said:
None of the topics in Intro to Advanced Math course you listed are likely to help you in grad school in physics. I think it would be better to do well in the courses you do take. Quality in four course is better than quantity in five. I think the advance classical mechanics course would be more helpful than partial differential equations if the partial differential equations is taught by the math department. I the partial differential equations course is taught by the Physics department as a Methods in Theoretical Physics course, then maybe partial differential equations would get priority.
Yah I've thought about dropping the intro to advanced math class, I just haven't because I really want to get into proof based mathematics a lot more. Not to mention that the class is a prerequisite for higher level math classes such as topology and real analysis. The PDE's class is taught by the math department by the way. I just wanted to get some opinions on this because I've kinda gotten the impression that to be a theoretical physicist, you have to have had experience with proof based maths such as the ones i mentioned. So I'm kinda coming from the perspective of prioritizing the math over the physics, is that silly?
 

1. What is the difference between partial differential equations and classical mechanics?

Partial differential equations are mathematical equations that involve multiple variables and their partial derivatives. They are commonly used to model physical phenomena in fields such as physics and engineering. Classical mechanics, on the other hand, is a branch of physics that studies the motion of objects and systems under the influence of forces. It is heavily based on Newton's laws of motion and uses mathematical equations such as differential equations to describe the motion of objects.

2. How are partial differential equations used in classical mechanics?

Partial differential equations are used in classical mechanics to describe the behavior of physical systems. For example, the famous wave equation, which is a partial differential equation, is used to describe the motion of a vibrating string in classical mechanics. Other examples include the heat equation, which is used to describe the flow of heat in a system, and the Navier-Stokes equations, which are used to describe fluid flow.

3. Which one is more useful in real-world applications, partial differential equations or classical mechanics?

Both partial differential equations and classical mechanics have their own strengths and are useful in different real-world applications. Partial differential equations are often used in fields such as engineering, geophysics, and fluid mechanics to model complex systems with multiple variables. Classical mechanics, on the other hand, is used in fields such as astrophysics, biomechanics, and applied physics to study the behavior of objects and systems under the influence of forces.

4. Can classical mechanics be derived from partial differential equations?

No, classical mechanics cannot be derived from partial differential equations. While partial differential equations are used to describe the behavior of physical systems, classical mechanics is a set of laws and principles that govern the behavior of objects and systems. These laws and principles are based on observations and experiments and cannot be derived from mathematical equations.

5. Are there any limitations to using partial differential equations in classical mechanics?

While partial differential equations are powerful tools for modeling physical systems, they also have limitations. One limitation is that they can only describe systems that can be represented by continuous mathematical functions. This means that they may not accurately describe systems with discontinuities or singularities. Additionally, solving partial differential equations can be computationally intensive, making them less practical for some real-world applications.

Similar threads

  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
16
Views
431
Replies
35
Views
3K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
11
Views
679
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
26
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
6
Views
190
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
618
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
3
Views
1K
Back
Top