Translational KE, specific heats at constant volume and pressure

[castrodisastro]

Homework Statement

Two copper cylinders, immersed in a water tank at 30.3 °C , contain helium and nitrogen, respectively. The helium-filled cylinder has a volume twice as large as the nitrogen-filled cylinder.

a) Calculate the average translational kinetic energy of a helium molecule and the average translational kinetic energy of a nitrogen molecule.

b) Determine the molar specific heat at constant volume (C_V) and at constant pressure (C_p) for the two gases.

c) Find γ for the two gases.

Given/Known information
C_p = C_v+R
C_V = $\frac{3}{2}$R = 12.5 J/(mol*K) monatomic gas
C_p = $\frac{5}{2}$R = 20.8 J/(mol*K) monatomic gas
C_V = 20.7 J/(mol*K) Nitrogen gas
C_p = 29.1 J/(mol*K) Nitrogen gas
T = 30.3 °C = 303.3 K

Homework Equations

K_ave = $\frac{3}{2}$k_BT
γ = C_p/C_V

The Attempt at a Solution

Part a)
Helium is a monatomic molecule.
The average energy per degree of freedom is given by $\frac{1}{2}$k_B for each gas molecule. I was asked for the average translational kinetic energy, since a monatomic molecule has 3 translational degrees of freedom, and Nitrogen has 3 translational degrees of freedom and 2 rotational degrees, then the average kinetic energy is equal to,

Helium

K_ave=$\frac{3}{2}$k_BT

K_ave=$\frac{3}{2}$($1.38\ \times\ 10^{-23}\ J\ K^{-1}$)(303.3 K)

K_ave=$6.278\ \times\ 10^{-21}\ J$ ←INCORRECT

Nitrogen

K_ave=$\frac{3}{2}$($1.38\ \times\ 10^{-23}\ J\ K^{-1}$)(303.3 K)

K_ave=$6.278\ \times\ 10^{-21}\ J$ ←INCORRECT

I don't know if the two gases being inside of copper cylinders affects the calculations somehow since there is no temperature change, no reaction going on, or anything that will change the equation. I know that for a polyatomic molecule you need to consider the additional degrees of freedom available, but for both He and N₂, there are 3 translational degrees of freedom, giving us the $\frac{3}{2}$. I don't know why that one is wrong.

Part b)
Values were obtained from a table in the book on Molar Specific Heats at constant volume and constant pressure. Also on this table was a column for the values of γ=C_p/C_V for some gases.

C_{V, He} = 12.5 J/(mol*K) ←CORRECT
C_{p, He} = 20.8 J/(mol*K) ←CORRECT
C_{V, N2} = 20.7 J/(mol*K) ←CORRECT
C_{p, N2} = 29.1 J/(mol*K) ←CORRECT

Part c)
γ is stated to be the ratio C_p/C_V

γHe = C_{p, He}/C_{V, He}
γHe = (20.8 J/(mol*K))/(12.5 J/(mol*K))
γHe = 1.664 ≈ 1.67 ←INCORRECT

γN₂ = C_{p, N2}/C_{V, N2}
γN₂ = (29.1 J/(mol*K))/(20.7 J/(mol*K))
γN₂ = 1.4058 ≈ 1.4 ←CORRECT

I really don't know what other value γHe could be if we are told γHe=C_p/C_V. Using values that I verified are correct for part b, taking C_p/C_V for He should give me the correct answer, which the table in the book also verifies that it is a value of 1.67. Even more confusing is how doing that calculation for N₂ gives me the correct answer for γN₂.

All help is greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance

Please let me know if something is confusing or if something looks like a typo, this took me a little while to proofread and edit and I went back numerous times to make it easier to read so I may have missed something.

 

[DrClaude]

How do you know the answers you marked as incorrect are incorrect?

 

[RTW69]

Isn't the equation k_ave=3/2*N*k_b*T where N is the number of molecules in the vessel? What is N? I'm guessing it isn't 1.

 

[DrClaude]

Isn't the equation k_ave=3/2*N*k_b*T where N is the number of molecules in the vessel? What is N? I'm guessing it isn't 1.

a) Calculate the average translational kinetic energy of a helium molecule and the average translational kinetic energy of a nitrogen molecule.

I read "a molecule" as $N=1$. :tongue2:

 

[castrodisastro]

How do you know the answers you marked as incorrect are incorrect?

This online homework assignment is designed in a way that for every question, in one field I type the answer in numerical form, and in a separate field I type in the units. After every time I fill it in I can hit a button that says check my answer and it just tells me if it's wrong or right.

Isn't the equation k_ave=3/2*N*k_b*T where N is the number of molecules in the vessel? What is N? I'm guessing it isn't 1.

The question states that I have "two copper cylinders that contain helium and nitrogen respectively" In one container, the one with the helium, would be one molecule. That would be N=1.

The equation K_ave=$\frac{3}{2}$k_BT is written this way specifically for a monatomic gas. N would equal 1.

 

[Andrew Mason]

Try converting T using K = 273.15 + C°

AM

 

[castrodisastro]

Try converting T using K = 273.15 + C°

AM

All my calculations were done using 303.5 K as my temp. Which is (30.3 °C) + 273 = 303.5 K

 

[Andrew Mason]

All my calculations were done using 303.5 K as my temp. Which is (30.3 °C) + 273 = 303.5 K

You are using 303.3 K as the temperature. I suggested that you use 303.45K as the temperature and see if your answers match the given "correct" answers. You could also try rounding your final answer to the correct significant figures.

AM

 

[castrodisastro]

Actually, our professor informed us that the homework assignment has an error on this problem, preventing it from giving students full credit. So he dropped this one. Thanks for the help though.