Why can't X-Rays travel through water?

In summary, the conversation discusses the interaction between X-rays and water molecules. It is mentioned that X-rays cannot travel through water due to the photoelectric effect, where the photon energy is absorbed by the atoms in the water. This effect is stronger for low-energy X-rays, making them unable to penetrate through water. The difference between hard and soft X-rays, and their applications in medical imaging, is also mentioned.
  • #1
nst.john
163
1
I read that X-Rays cannot travel through water and I wanted to understand why. What happens when X-Rays and water molecules interact that prohibit X-rays from traveling within water?
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
http://www-als.lbl.gov/index.php/holding/167-isotope-and-temperature-effects-in-liquid-water-probed-by-soft-x-rays.html
Above describes interactions between x-rays and water. Water is not opaque to x-rays.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #3
nst.john said:
I read that

And you aren't going to tell us where, so we can't then look it up and find out what they are talking about?

You are mostly water. If water were opaque to x-rays, you would be too. Does this sound right to you?
 
  • #5
Where do they mention x-rays in that paper? Can you indicate at least the page?
 
  • #6
nasu said:
Where do they mention x-rays in that paper? Can you indicate at least the page?

It's on the last page, left hand column, the paragraph immediately preceding "Noble Addition".
 
  • #7
OK so they are referring to Soft X-rays not traveling through water which is basically correct

medical X-rays are "Hard" X-rays ( higher frequency)

http://www.genesis.net.au/~ajs/projects/medical_physics/x-rays/

The clinical application of X-rays to form images
Hard and soft X-rays
Hard X-rays are X-rays with a higher frequency and are more penetrating than soft X-rays. Soft X-rays are usually filtered when doing a scan because they can't penetrate through a patient's body and add needless risk of radiation damage.
Dave
 
  • #8
Okee doke thank you for the clarification. But why can't soft xrays propagate through water?
 
  • #9
At reasonable* photon energies the main interaction between x-rays and matter is through the photoelectric effect: The photon gets absorbed by an atom and produces a free electron and a "hole" in the electronic configuration of the atom.

The photoelectric cross section decreases very fast with the photon energy, i.e. low energy, soft x-rays are absorbed much stronger than high-energy, hard ones.

In practice this means that x-rays with E<1keV cannot penetrate a sheet of paper whereas hard x-rays with E>50 keV can go through a lot of stuff - several centimeters of water, bones, even steel, rocks, etc.

Visible light, IR and so on can travel through some materials if the photon energy is smaller than the band gap/smallest binding energy of the material. In that case the photons do not have enough "punch" to produce an electron-hole pair.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photoelectric_effect

* "unreasonable" according to this definition starts at a few 100 keV
 

1. Why can't X-Rays travel through water?

X-Rays are a form of electromagnetic radiation, which means they travel in waves. These waves have a very high frequency and a short wavelength, allowing them to pass through certain materials like skin and muscle, but not through denser substances like bone or metal. When X-Rays encounter water, they are absorbed and scattered by the hydrogen and oxygen molecules, making it difficult for them to pass through.

2. Can any amount of water block X-Rays?

Yes, any amount of water can block X-Rays to some degree. The more water that is present, the more X-Rays will be absorbed and scattered. However, X-Rays can still pass through thin layers of water, which is why they are used in medical imaging to capture images of bones and tissues inside the body.

3. Why do X-Rays pass through soft tissue but not water?

X-Rays are able to pass through soft tissues such as skin and muscle because these substances have a lower density compared to water. Furthermore, soft tissues contain a lot of water, which allows X-Rays to pass through with minimal scattering. On the other hand, water has a higher density and contains more molecules, making it difficult for X-Rays to travel through without being absorbed or scattered.

4. Are there any materials that X-Rays can pass through better than water?

Yes, there are some materials that X-Rays can pass through better than water. For example, X-Rays can pass through air much more easily than water since air has a lower density and contains fewer molecules. However, there are also denser materials like certain types of plastic or glass that can block X-Rays more effectively than water.

5. Can X-Rays pass through other liquids besides water?

Yes, X-Rays can pass through other liquids besides water. The ability of X-Rays to pass through a liquid depends on its density and the number of molecules present. For example, X-Rays can pass through alcohol and oil more easily than water, but liquids like mercury or lead are much denser and can block X-Rays more effectively.

Similar threads

Replies
54
Views
5K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Optics
Replies
11
Views
892
Replies
4
Views
666
Replies
2
Views
860
Back
Top