Why the existence of the potential function ##U## is not sufficient?

In summary, in this conversation from Sommerfeld's Lectures on Theoretical Physics, it is discussed that for liquids to be in equilibrium, the external force must have a potential, represented by the scalar function ##U##. However, it is not enough for ##U## to simply exist; it must also be single valued within the space occupied by the liquid. This means that the work done around a loop in the field created by the potential must be zero. This concept may be difficult to understand, as it is a specific requirement for equilibrium that goes beyond just the existence of a potential function.
  • #1
Adesh
735
191
Homework Statement
See the main body
Relevant Equations
See the main body
In Sommerfeld’s Lectures on Theoretical Physics, Vol II, Chapter 2, Section 6, Page 43 we derive an expression for the equilibrium of liquids as $$ grad ~p = \mathbf F$$ Where ##p## is the pressure and ##F## is the exertnal force. Then he writes,
[ The equation above ]includes a very remarkable Theorem: equilibrium is only possible if the external force has a potential, that is, if ##\mathbf F## can be represented as the gradient of a scalar function: $$ \mathbf F = -grad ~U$$ Where the minus sign is prompted by the relation to the potential energy. The existence of the potential function ##U## is not sufficient, ##U## must also be single valued within the space occupied by the liquid.

My problem is why existence of potential function is not sufficient? When he writes “##U## must also be single valued” I couldn’t understand him as a scalar function will always be “single valued”. What he actually meant ? Please explain.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I asked it to someone and he said that “single valued” means a kind of potential so that work done around a loop (in the field created by that potential) comes out to be zero. But I couldn’t understand what he meant, beacuse in the original text Sommerfeld wanted “##U## to be single-valued” and he (Sommerfeld) said that ##U## was a scalar function so I don’t know what’s happening.
 

1. Why is the existence of a potential function not sufficient to fully describe a physical system?

The existence of a potential function alone does not provide enough information to fully describe a physical system because it only describes the potential energy of the system at a given point in space. In order to fully understand the behavior of a system, we also need to know the kinetic energy of the system, which is not provided by the potential function alone.

2. What other factors need to be considered in addition to the potential function?

In addition to the potential function, we also need to consider the initial conditions of the system, the laws of motion governing the system, and any external forces acting on the system. These factors, along with the potential function, make up the complete set of information needed to fully describe a physical system.

3. Can a system have multiple potential functions?

Yes, a system can have multiple potential functions. This is because the potential function is dependent on the choice of coordinate system and different coordinate systems can result in different potential functions. However, all of these potential functions should still describe the same physical system.

4. Is the potential function the only factor that determines the behavior of a system?

No, the potential function is not the only factor that determines the behavior of a system. As mentioned before, the initial conditions and laws of motion also play a crucial role in determining the behavior of a system. Additionally, external forces and other factors such as friction can also affect the behavior of a system.

5. Can a system exist without a potential function?

Yes, a system can exist without a potential function. For example, a system with only kinetic energy and no potential energy would not have a potential function. However, in most physical systems, there is some form of potential energy present, even if it is not explicitly described by a potential function.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
8
Views
865
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
47
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
867
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
16
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
11
Views
946
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Differential Equations
Replies
1
Views
775
Back
Top