Recent content by Nugatory
-
High School Rotating disc: tidal relativity across surface of disc
The term “fabric” is used as a metaphor in unserious descriptions of relativity to avoid the math required for a real explanation of the theory. But it is a metaphor, and will be serious misleading if taken too seriously - there is no fabric and hence nothing to “tear”. So your question is...- Nugatory
- Post #2
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
High School The world is not enough
There is a (possibly apocryphal) account of great consternation when Magellan returned to Spain and his ship’s log was missing a day….- Nugatory
- Post #14
- Forum: Classical Physics
-
Graduate Exact symmetry, quantum states, and symmetric dynamics
There is not. Nothing stops you from writing down a wave function and a Hamiltonian with spherical symmetry. These might not describe any physically realizable system, but you’ve already excluded those concerns: "I am not asking about experimental feasibility, observers, or measurement...- Nugatory
- Post #5
- Forum: Quantum Physics
-
Undergrad EPR revisited
From the very first post in this thread: “the moment when B has ##|b>_B##” is specifying an event.- Nugatory
- Post #36
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
Undergrad EPR revisited
The collapsed state is a mixture of ##|+-\rangle## and ##|-+\rangle##; the uncollapsed state is a pure superposition of the two. These are different states that behave differently in experiments designed to expose the difference. What does it mean to “interpret” one as the other?- Nugatory
- Post #33
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
Other than just FizzBuzz to test programmer candidates
@Filip Larsen said in a later post that this was decades ago. Depending on how many decades ago (Python is 35 years old) this would have been appreciably more difficult. Four hours for a constant-space solution using K&R C would be pretty good.- Nugatory
- Post #11
- Forum: Programming and Computer Science
-
High School Individual photons or electrons on a screen?
We can’t say for these exact images because we don’t know where they came from - they may be real photos or they may be simulation output. But they could be real, there are techniques sensitive enough to detect the impact of a single subatomic particle and amplify it into a visible dot on a...- Nugatory
- Post #2
- Forum: Other Physics Topics
-
High School Contradictions in the Distribution of Gamma-Ray Bursts
The thread will remain closed.- Nugatory
- Post #25
- Forum: Astronomy and Astrophysics
-
High School True static equilibrium and effects on time
You are just cheating yourself out of essential background understanding (which is the really fun part) if you've skipped chapters 1-3. (Edited to add: I said above that I had learned relativity from that book - actually the first edition, which I still prefer. By far the hardest part was...- Nugatory
- Post #18
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
High School Questions about the structure of dark matter
There’s no “if” here, dark matter is defined to be the stuff we haven’t seen yet that is interacting with the mass we have seen. It differs from ordinary matter only in that we haven’t seen it yet; in particular it has mass and behaves gravitationally just like any other matter. Please please... -
Graduate Collapse of wave function and consciousness
Yes, seriously in some philosophies of ethics and less seriously in new-age pseudo-philosophy. However this thinking has proven unhelpful in empirical science - there's no getting around the "but what difference does it make?" question.- Nugatory
- Post #9
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Undergrad Nested universes across scales - existing literature?
No. Your speculative idea neither explains some previously observed but unexplained phenomenon nor suggests some experiment/observation that might demonstrate an otherwise unexplainable result. Thus, as far as empirical science is concerned, there is nothing to explore here.- Nugatory
- Post #2
- Forum: Beyond the Standard Models
-
Paul Hinds has passed
Very sorry to hear this - he contributed much over the years and will be missed.- Nugatory
- Post #6
- Forum: Feedback and Announcements
-
Undergrad EPR revisited
Do remember that collapse is not part of the theory of quantum mechanics as described by the math (which is the only real description of the theory). Collapse is an interpretation, a way that we can think about what the math is telling us if we find it helpful. But we don't have to think in...- Nugatory
- Post #26
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
High School Thought Experiment on Charge Carriers and Electrical Conduction
Your hypothetical “electrop”differs from the positron (the electron’s anti-particle, and not hypothetical) only in that it doesn’t interact with electrons? They would form bound pairs with electrons (like positronium, but stable), these pairs would be neutral, and now we don’t have charge...- Nugatory
- Post #2
- Forum: Electromagnetism