Can Atoms be Classified as Dipolar Substances?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Prashasti
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Atoms
AI Thread Summary
Atoms can exhibit dipole characteristics under certain conditions, particularly when influenced by external electric fields. A neutral hydrogen atom, with its single electron, can theoretically show a dipole moment, but this is contingent on the electron cloud's response to an external field. In contrast, other atoms do not display dipole behavior unless subjected to similar conditions. The discussion highlights the importance of quantum mechanics in understanding atomic structure and behavior, emphasizing that electron positions are not fixed but exist as probability distributions. Overall, while hydrogen can be considered a dipole under specific circumstances, this does not apply universally to all atoms.
Prashasti
Messages
63
Reaction score
2
Can an atom be considered as an example of a dipole? It has positive charge in the nucleus and negative charge around it?!
 
Science news on Phys.org
Depends. For example with neutral hydrogen atom the electron "cloud" completely cancels the positive charge from the nucleus.

But if there is an external field applied, then the electron cloud can be reshaped so that there is a dipole moment. This happens when sunlight passes by the nitrogen molecules in the atmosphere - the result is Rayleigh scattering of the light from these molecular dipoles - and so the sky appears blue.

See http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/atmos/blusky.html
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
That means for a neutral Hydrogen atom it is "Yes" but for any other atom, it is no, (unless electric field is applied). Am I right if I say that this is because there is only one electron in a neutral H atom ,as for one electron and one proton, the direction of dipole moment is possible to tell?!
 
Prashasti said:
That means for a neutral Hydrogen atom it is "Yes" but for any other atom, it is no, (unless electric field is applied). Am I right if I say that this is because there is only one electron in a neutral H atom ,as for one electron and one proton, the direction of dipole moment is possible to tell?!

It is a _no_ for the neutral hydrogen atom.

I must have explained things poorly if you got the other impression. The hydrogen atom, like all other atoms, must be analyzed via quantum mechanics. The "orbital electrons" are not located in a definite place, but instead have definite energy states. They "appear" as smeared out in an "electron cloud" - even when there is only one electron, as with hydrogen.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_orbital
 
  • Like
Likes Prashasti
Now I got it!
 
Sorry. I know. I was a bit confused on where to post this query at as it comes under atomic physics and general physics, both - that is why I posted it twice. I didnt read the rules carefully- sorry.
 
Back
Top