General relaivity Definition and 166 Threads

  1. mr John wheeler

    I Confused about time dilation -- motion vs energy

    Hey, I’ve been trying to understand time dilation, and I think I might be mixing some concepts. If you’re moving very close to the speed of light (say 0.99999c), your clock slows. If you then enter a strong gravitational field, that also slows clocks. From your point of view, would that mean...
  2. J

    I MTW exercise 21.26: junction conditions for a thin shell of dust

    I need help with exercise 21.26 in MTW. The question goes like this: For a thin shell of dust surrounded by vacuum ( ##[T^{in}]=0## , ##\mathbf{t}=0## ), derive the following equations$$\frac{d\sigma}{d\tau}=-\sigma^b{}_{|b}\;\; ,\tag{21.175a}$$$$\mathbf{a}^+ +\mathbf{a}^- =0 \;\...
  3. Sciencemaster

    I How do non-diagonal indices of a metric allow for local flatness?

    I'm having trouble understanding the local flatness of GR. So far, my interpretation was that it meant that the metric tensor at an infinitesimal point in spacetime will be equal to some multiple of the Minkowski metric since that's the metric that preserves the speed of light/spacetime...
  4. A

    I Is Spacetime infinite dimensional?

    So I found this paper while in a discussion online and I don't think I fully understand it, here's my understanding so far The paper starts by recouting the string uncerainty relation the paper then points out that one of the formulae used there only has a finite amount of terms, where it...
  5. Kostik

    A Reconciling units for the Einstein and Landau-Lifshitz pseudotensors

    The Einstein (or Einstein-Dirac) pseudotensor ##{t_\mu}^\nu## satisfies $$\left[ \sqrt{-g}({t_\mu}^\nu + T_\mu^\nu) \right]_{,\nu}=0$$ (see Dirac, "General Theory of Relativity", eq. 31.2)). Similarly, the Landau-Lifshitz pseudotensor ##t^{\mu\nu}## satisfies $$\left[ (-g)(t^{\mu\nu} +...
  6. P

    A Bivector mediation of standard field equations to form coupled system

    Can a single bivector field ##\mathcal{A}_\mu##, defined within a Clifford algebra framework, mediate the following four standard field equations using a covariant derivative ##D_\mu = \partial_\mu + [\mathcal{A}_\mu, \cdot]##? The standard equations are: \textbf{Yang-Mills Equation}: $$D_\mu...
  7. H

    Derivation of the acceleration in the Eddington-Finkelstein Metric

    Hi, I'm trying to derive the equation (14) ##a^r = \frac{a u^r e}{\sqrt{e^2 + g_{tt}}}## from this article No Way Back: Maximizing survival time below the Schwarzschild event horizon and my algebra is really messy, so I'm wondering if I made some mistakes. The authors say: "With the above...
  8. LightPhoton

    I Black hole formation and infinite redshift

    In A short course in general relativity, Foster and Nightingale write: So in modern astronomy, how is this apparent paradox resolved?
  9. stixlee

    Physicist ISO no strings attached fun (see what I did there?)

    Rancher, film producer, writer, AI entrepreneur, US Army veteran/paratrooper and theoretical physicist. Granted, that’s a professional Venn diagram you won’t see often, but I’ve just submitted my first paper for pre-published peer review on viXra and am hoping to contribute to the forum and...
  10. Safinaz

    Simplifying terms of Ricci tensor

    So that they become: ## g^{\sigma \rho} \nabla_\sigma \nabla_\rho R ~g_{\mu\nu} + R ~R_{\mu\nu} - \nabla_\mu \nabla_\nu R ##
  11. Trysse

    At what age is special relativity taught?

    This is a question to school teachers (and all those who know about physics syllabus at school). Is relativity (special and or general) taught in school (pre university) in your country? If yes, at what age are students introduced to relativity? What aspects are taught? As far as I remember...
  12. Gary Venter

    I Quantum field in curved space-time

    The wave function includes coordinates for position in space. For two distant but correlated particles, do their distances and paths of movement used in the wave function follow the curved space-time of general relativity, or is Euclidean distance assumed in QM?
  13. ric peregrino

    On the order of indices of the Christoffel symbol of the 1st kind

    Homework Statement: The order of indices of the Christoffel symbol of the 1st kind seems to vary from source to source. Is there a preference, and if so why? Relevant Equations: Christoffel symbol of the 1st kind. The 1st definition of the Christoffel symbol of the 1st kind I came across was...
  14. K

    I Why does general relativity break down at high energies?

    more specifically what does high energies mean in this context, does it actually mean a high amount of energy? I can intuitively understand why it breaks down at small scales where quantum effects take place. for example it is said that high speed collisions produce a lot of energy and general...
  15. J

    I Theoretically, can perfectly flat spacetime exist in the Universe?

    According to general relativity, mass and energy cause the curvature of spacetime. To have perfectly flat spacetime, there must be a completely empty vacuum state with no mass or energy. Does this mean that perfectly flat spacetime cannot exist if mass and energy are present? Let's assume that...
  16. Bosko

    I Experimental evidence of the existence of an event horizon

    There is good enough experimental evidence for the existence of a Photon Sphere. Is there clear unequivocal experimental evidence for the existence of an Event Horizon ?
  17. baba26

    A Proof of covariant derivative of spinor

    I have read that we can define covariant derivative for spinors using the spin connection. But I can't see its proof in any textbook. Can anyone point to a reference where it is proved that such a definition indeed transforms covariantly ?
  18. K

    I On the existence of Gravitational energy in General relativity

    I was reading this paper that puts forward the argument that Gravitational energy in GR is unnecessary and doesn't exist and that got me wondering if this is a fringe theory or what exactly is the mainstream view regarding gravitational energy in GR? Also does GR predict or need the existence...
  19. K

    I Does Phantom Dark Energy Violate Conservation of Energy?

    from Sean Carroll's blog " “there’s energy in the gravitational field, but it’s negative, so it exactly cancels the energy you think is being gained in the matter fields”. This is an explanation that I have seen mentioned somewhat frequently, my question is in the case of phantom dark energy...
  20. K

    I Conservation of stress-energy tensor

    I came across this statement "The covariant energy-momentum conservation lawis ∇𝜇𝑇𝜇𝜈=0. Be careful though: "convariant conservation" equations do not imply that any component of the energy or momentum is actually conserved. To get actual conserved quantities you need a symmetry. In particular...
  21. K

    I Dark energy and conservation of energy

    According to this Sean Carroll article, “https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2010/02/22/energy-is-not-conserved/ “ And other threads in here, depending on your definition of energy, dark energy does not violate conservation of energy, my questions is if this is true regardless of the type...
  22. djanni_unchained

    A How do we interpret measurements of Mercury's position?

    When scientists measured the position of Mercury in the 18th century, they interpreted the results assuming a Euclidean background, because they did not know general relativity. So they measured r and φ in fuction of time attributing to these coordinates an Euclidean meaning, that is, assuming...
  23. Baela

    A Variation of the kinetic term in scalar field theory

    Varying ##\partial_\lambda\phi\,\partial^\lambda\phi## wrt the metric tensor ##g_{\mu\nu}## in two different ways gives me different results. Obviously I'm doing something wrong. Where am I going wrong? Method 1: \begin{equation} (\delta g_{\mu\nu})\,\partial^\mu\phi\,\partial^\nu\phi...
  24. S

    I Explanation for Galaxy Rotation Curves

    The existence of dark matter was initially proposed to address discrepancies between observed galaxy rotation curves and the expected behavior dictated by our current understanding of gravity. Typically, it's argued that stars at the edges of galaxies rotate faster than expected, leading to...
  25. Leureka

    I Does potential energy curve spacetime?

    Hi there, I looked around on the net but I didn't quite find the answer to my question. I preface that I don't have training in GR, even though I know about the basics (like what tensors are, geodesics, a bit about topology and differential geometry...). So I wasn't sure if to put this question...
  26. K

    I Is the Black Hole Information Paradox Truly Resolved?

    from what I understand it is believed that information is preserved but we are still working out how exactly, is this the case?
  27. Safinaz

    A A question from a paper on perturbation theory

    Where ##\delta \phi## is the first-order perturbation of a scalar field, ##\Phi## is the first-order perturbation of the space-time metric, and ##H## is the universe’s scale factor. It’s mentioned that this relation is given in reference: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1002.0600.pdf But I can't find...
  28. M

    I Physical meaning of zero time metric

    I am reading Wald's General Relativity and just did problem 2.8(b). The result I get is ##\omega^2(x'^2+y'^2)-1## as the coefficient for ##dt^2##, and I am wondering about the physical significance of when ##x'^2+y'^2=\frac{1}{\omega^2}##, what would this mean? Mads
  29. Nitacii

    Integrate source terms for test EM field in Kerr spacetime

    Hello, the Homework Statement is quite long, since it includes a lot of equations so I will rather post the as images as to prevent mistypes. We need to find the integral where with $$ J_m =(\sqrt{2}(r−ia\cos⁡θ))^{−1} i(r^2+a^2)\sin⁡(θ)j, $$ $$ J_n = - \frac{a \Delta}{ 2 \Sigma} \sin(\theta...
  30. Steve Rogers

    I Quasi-local mass as a measure of the gravitational energy?

    I'm self-studying the mathematical aspects of quasi-local mass, or quasi-local energy (e.g. Hawking energy), and a fundamental question has been lingering in my mind for a long time: why does quasi-local mass provide us with a measure of the gravitational energy? In general relativity...
  31. vinicius_linhares

    A Newmann-Penrose Spin coefficients for Schwarschild metric

    I need to use the N-P formalism to apply in my work so I'm trying first to apply in a simple case to understand better. So in this article ( https://arxiv.org/abs/1809.02764 ) which I'm using, they present a null tetrad for the Schwarszchild metric in pg.14 (with accordance with the...
  32. namelessuser

    I Quantum Mechanics vs Einstein: Light Btwn Black Holes, Double Slit Experiment

    Quantum mechanics vs Einsteins theory of relativity: How does light move between two black holes if we create a double slit experiment in front of the light? Do the light waves distribute themselves equally on the screen or does gravity distort light waves at the edges? So just imagine doing...
  33. sarriiss

    A Preserving Covariant Derivatives of Null Vectors Under Variation

    Having two null vectors with $$n^{a} l_{a}=-1, \\ g_{ab}=-(l_{a}n_{b}+n_{a}l_{b}),\\ n^{a}\nabla_{a}n^{b}=0$$ gives $$\nabla_{a}n_{b}=\kappa n_{a}n_{b},\\ \nabla_{a}n^{a}=0,\\ \nabla_{a}l_{b}=-\kappa n_{a}l_{b},\\ \nabla_{a}l^{a}=\kappa$$. How to show that under the variation of the null...
  34. E

    General relativity - Using Ricc and Weyl tensor to find the area

    I have the following question to solve:Use the metric:$$ds^2 = -dt^2 +dx^2 +2a^2(t)dxdy + dy^2 +dz^2$$ Test bodies are arranged in a circle on the metric at rest at ##t=0##. The circle define as $$x^2 +y^2 \leq R^2$$ The bodies start to move on geodesic when we have $$a(0)=0$$ a. we have to...
  35. E

    A Solving Geodesics with Metric $$ds^2$$

    I have the following question to solve:Use the metric: $$ds^2 = -dt^2 +dx^2 +2a^2(t)dxdy + dy^2 +dz^2$$ Test bodies are arranged in a circle on the metric at rest at $$t=0$$. The circle define as $$x^2 +y^2 \leq R^2$$ The bodies start to move on geodesic when we have $$a(0)=0$$ a. we have to...
  36. H

    I Dark Energy Strength in Great Voids of Galaxies

    Assuming dark energy is fairly, uniformly distributed through out the cosmos, how strong is it, or how much energy is associate with it, out in the deepest, emptiest voids in space? I'm specificlaly refering to the great voids in between the great walls of galaxy clusters. I'm making the...
  37. L

    B If gravity was a force wouldn't going back in time cause us to float?

    This might sound as a dumb and silly question but if you think about it, it makes sense. If we wrongly assume that gravity is a force just like any other, and given the fact that time is closely related to gravity and that gravitational time dilation is a thing, wouldn't reverse time travel...
  38. S

    I Explore Spacetimes, Metrics & Symmetries in Relativity Theory

    I was discussing this paper with a couple of physicists colleagues of mine (https://arxiv.org/abs/2011.12970) In the paper, the authors describe "spacetimes without symmetries". When I mentioned that, one of my friends said that no spacetime predicted or included in the theory of relativity...
  39. T

    Why was my post deleted on PF?

    I'm not aware of the mathcode here, so forgive me for not posting my work straight away. I simply need to ascertain what code first displays equations. $a$ a a
  40. L

    A Going from Cauchy Stress Tensor to GR's Energy Momentum Tensor

    Why do the Cauchy Stress Tensor & the Energy Momentum Tensor have the same SI units? Shouldn't adding time as a dimension changes the Energy Momentum Tensor's units? Did Einstein start with the Cauchy Tensor when he started working on the right hand side of the field equations of GR? If so, What...
  41. P

    A Popular Pseudoscience Video on General Relativity: Analysis & Criticism

    Here is the video: [link deleted by moderators] His basic idea is to take the spacetime interval and add a 5th term for the 5th dimension he is describing so it looks like: $$\Delta S^2 = c^2\Delta t^2 + c^2\Delta w^2 - \Delta x^2 - \Delta y^2 - \Delta z^2 $$ where w is the difference in time...
  42. N

    I Orbital Precession Calculation: Unit Explained

    Hi, I've just calculated the orbital precession for the earth using the sigma formula of general relativity. $$ \sigma=\frac{24 \pi^{3} R^{2}}{T^{2} c^{2}\left(1-e^{2}\right)}=\frac{24\pi^3×1.5×10^{11}}{3×10^7×3×10^8(1-0.0034^2)}=0.012 $$ What is the unit of the result? Degrees per century or...
  43. B

    I Observing a Collapsing Shell: Time Dilation Explained

    What does and observer inside of a collapsing shell observe? Lets say we have a shell of matter collapsing to a black hole. What would observers near the center see? How would the rest of the universe appear when, The shell is approaching the Schwarzschild radius? After the shell passes the...
  44. U

    A The force from the energy gradient

    From this post-gradient energy in classical field theory, one identifies the term ##E\equiv\frac{1}{2}\left(\partial_x\phi\right)^2## as the gradient energy which can be interpreted as elastic potential energy. Can one then say that $$F\equiv -\frac{\partial...
  45. Tertius

    I Co-Moving Coordinates & Lapse Function N(t) in ADM Decomposition

    In the ADM decomposition, like in the construction of the FRW metric, the coordinates are defined to be co-moving, so we know $$d\tau = dt$$ (i.e. the lapse function is normalized away) Starting from a five-dimensional embedded hyperboloid (as in carroll pg. 324) ## -u^2 + x^2 + y^2 + z^2 + w^2...
  46. Safinaz

    I The Units of the Cosmological Constant: eV^2

    In natural units, it’s known that the unit of the cosmological constant is ##eV^2##. I don‘t get why in this paper : https://arxiv.org/pdf/2201.09016.pdf page (1), it says the value of ##\Lambda \sim meV^4##, this means ##\Lambda \sim (10^6 ~ eV)^4 \sim 10^{24} eV^4 ##, shoud not the unit ##eV...
  47. Spockishere

    B Travel 7 Light Years at 50000km/s - How Long?

    let's say i would like to drop by one of my pals on a certain planet, 7ly away. I got to 42 years but it doesn't really sound correct.
  48. S

    Normal vector of an embedding surface

    I will only care about the ##t## and ##x## coordinates so that ##(t, z, x, x_i) \rightarrow (t,x)##. The normal vector is given by, ##n^\mu = g^{\mu\nu} \partial_\nu S ## How do I calculate ##n^\mu## in terms of ##U## given that the surface is written in terms of ##t## and ##x##? Also, after...
  49. M

    A Wald's Abstract Index Notation: Explaining T^{acde}_b

    In the second paragraph on page 25 of Wald's General Relativity he rewrites T^{acde}_b as g_{bf}g^{dh} g^{ej}T^{afc}_{hj} . Can anyone explain this? I am confused by the explantion given in the book. Especially puzzling is that the inverse of g seems to be applied twice, which I can't make sese...
  50. Lars Krogh-Stea

    B Energy Conservation w/ Charged Battery Time Travel

    Hi! I want to start with saying that I'm not an expert on these type of problems, but I will be gratefull for some calarifications. I've heard that there's nothing in psysics that says that time travel is impossible. I want to make a case with the time traveling battery. Could be any mass with...
Back
Top