Is lightning caused by the cloud acting as a capacitor?

AI Thread Summary
Lightning is caused by the separation of electrical charges within a thunderstorm, where hail collects a negative charge at the cloud's base and ice crystals retain a positive charge at the top. This charge separation creates a potential difference that, when strong enough, leads to a discharge of electricity, resulting in a lightning strike. The analogy of lightning to a capacitor is valid, as both involve separated charges and a breakdown of a medium—in this case, air. While capacitance plays a role in the discharge process, the phenomenon of lightning can occur without it, although it would manifest differently. Overall, the current understanding of lightning continues to evolve as new observations may challenge existing theories.
ChromeBit
Messages
27
Reaction score
0
So I was looking up what causes thunderstorms online and found this:
"As hail moves within the cloud it picks up a negative charge by rubbing against smaller positively charged ice crystals. A negative charge forms at the base of the cloud where the hail collects, while the lighter ice crystals remain near the top of the cloud and create a positive charge.

The negative charge is attracted to the Earth's surface and other clouds and objects and when the attraction becomes too strong, the positive and negative charges come together, or discharge, to balance the difference in a flash of lightning (sometimes known as a lightning strike or lightning bolt). The rapid expansion and heating of air caused by lightning produces the accompanying loud clap of thunder."

The line that really interested me was this: "and when the attraction becomes too strong, the positive and negative charges come together". This sounds to me like a capacitor.

Am I correct in thinking this or am I mistaken?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Well, you have separated charges with a bad conductor (air) in between, that is similar to a capacitor.
 
(i think) you have thought a correct analogy between lighting and capacitance . What i think is that when lighting strikes them the maximum capacitance of air is crossed and the charge is finally transferred from clouds to the land .
 
ChromeBit said:
Am I correct in thinking this or am I mistaken?
You have described the currently accepted paradigm correctly. Unfortunately it does not explain everything that is observed and so will be subject to revision at some time in the future.

When the potential difference between two parcels or pools of opposite charge exceeds the breakdown voltage of the air, an ionised path called lightning forms that discharges the local charge difference.

There is capacitance between the two parcels of air and there is a charge difference. The voltage is therefore V = Q / C, derived from the definition of capacitance C = Q / V.
 
To answer the question you posed in the title, whether capacitance "causes" lightning is a matter of semantics.
Without the capacitance, there would still be a discharge, but it would have to be a continuous current. It would not be lightning-like.
 
  • Like
Likes spacewrinkle
Back
Top