A new found respect for protesters

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pengwuino
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the effectiveness of email protests compared to more active forms of protest. Participants express frustration with the ease of sending emails, arguing that it lacks the commitment and impact of traditional protests like marches or direct action. There's a consensus that email campaigns often go unnoticed, with Congress reportedly treating them as spam rather than genuine communication. The conversation critiques the trend of "professional protesters" who seem to adopt new causes frequently, suggesting that true passion for a cause should drive more substantial action. Some participants advocate for writing physical letters as a more effective means of communication, while others reflect on the limitations of email activism, emphasizing the importance of personal engagement in advocacy. Overall, the thread conveys skepticism about the sincerity and impact of digital protests.
Pengwuino
Gold Member
Messages
5,112
Reaction score
20
No not those PETA idiots or people out burning the flag or claiming Bush sleeping in and missing a meeting was equivalent to the Holocaust... just any normal person that protests when that isn't their 'job' so to speak.

I've been noticing something a lot the past few years. Whenever someone’s mad... they... email people! Right now there’s something on school bullies and these supervisors that don’t care or something and the big conclusion... people emailed the school! Email! Email! EMAIL?? You know, it's so freaken easy to write an email (and I'm sure people probably take on average, 1 minute to write their emails) that I'm really turned off by those kinds of pathetic forms of protesting. Get your butt off the computer and go wave a sign or something infront of the school, storm into the offices, GET OUT OF YOUR HOUSE! I've always felt you get out of life what you put into it. All e-mail protests shoudl be thrown out, I don't care what the cause. I especially hate when people go "We got 380 zillion emails showing how much support this thingy whatever has!” Give me a break, it takes less time and effort to write an email then it does to actually hear what something is about. Write your congressmen? Email them? No wonder Congress doesn't listen to people, they probably just get a flood of spam email from idiots whose only form of protest is writing a bunch of unintelligible statements and probably not even putting ' Joe Blow' or any other sign that this mailing was meant to be taken seriously.

Signed,
Oh who cares.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Pengwuino said:
No not those PETA idiots or people out burning the flag or claiming Bush sleeping in and missing a meeting was equivalent to the Holocaust... just any normal person that protests when that isn't their 'job' so to speak.

I've been noticing something a lot the past few years. Whenever someone’s mad... they... email people! Right now there’s something on school bullies and these supervisors that don’t care or something and the big conclusion... people emailed the school! Email! Email! EMAIL?? You know, it's so freaken easy to write an email (and I'm sure people probably take on average, 1 minute to write their emails) that I'm really turned off by those kinds of pathetic forms of protesting. Get your butt off the computer and go wave a sign or something infront of the school, storm into the offices, GET OUT OF YOUR HOUSE! I've always felt you get out of life what you put into it. All e-mail protests shoudl be thrown out, I don't care what the cause. I especially hate when people go "We got 380 zillion emails showing how much support this thingy whatever has!” Give me a break, it takes less time and effort to write an email then it does to actually hear what something is about. Write your congressmen? Email them? No wonder Congress doesn't listen to people, they probably just get a flood of spam email from idiots whose only form of protest is writing a bunch of unintelligible statements and probably not even putting ' Joe Blow' or any other sign that this mailing was meant to be taken seriously.

Signed,
Oh who cares.

Even though i agrree with you i am going to e mail Evo and protest about this rant.:smile:
 
I wouldn't think a one minute e-mail would be very effective.

Second, how much attention do e-mails get? Probably none.
 
JasonRox said:
I wouldn't think a one minute e-mail would be very effective.

Second, how much attention do e-mails get? Probably none.

The general public IS spam.
 
I've been told that when people send emails to Congress, they pretty much tally up the for and against emails, and don't actually read them, so you better make your position clear in the subject line or first sentence. I don't think they actually read even the well-written ones. Apparently, if you want to get attention, you should actually write an old-fashioned paper letter.

The silly thing is that most people that do those email "protests" just copy and paste the same email everyone else is sending. It's probably pretty easy to set up an email filter to just dump them all straight in the trash with the rest of the spam.

I don't quite "get" what I call the professional protesters...the ones who seem to have a new cause every weekend. I think it's just a hobby for them. On the other hand, when someone truly feels passionate about a particular issue, I think it's good that they speak up for it.
 
I've heard that if you actually write a letter, some members of congress actually write you back! Only for hand written letters however. With the way some people (ADULTS!) write emails as a 'protest', i would worship a congressmen or company representative if they actually sat down and read every email they got for over a year.
 
For five years mom and dad have been protesting about a row of trees
that back on to their garden, there is some (act ) about blocking ones light,and they have been told by local councilers that these trees contravene this act and they will get them loped, still waiting.
 
Last edited:
I've always been a believer in domains of influence rather than protests. But protesting has its place since it draws [can draw] attention to an issue.

The domain of influence approach is seen in concepts such as "think globally, act locally". ~It is easier for me to affect my world and indirectly affect the rest of the world, than to try to change the broader world directly.
 
Ivan Seeking said:
The domain of influence approach is seen in concepts such as "think globally, act locally". ~It is easier for me to affect my world and indirectly affect the rest of the world, than to try to change the broader world directly.

That's a rather naive (or lazy) way of looking at things. The civil rights movement probably would have never gotten so far if it weren't for people like King. Far reaching consequences rarely happen on participants weekends. Then again you did say easier. Life is what you put into it my alien brethren! Wait no! WRITE AN EMAIL :smile: :smile: :smile: :smile: Oh email... you've ruined the western world...

On that note, its sad that the only people who devote their lives to protesting tend to make fools of themselves (ie 99% of san francisco based protests) or are protesting for things that make you wonder if the protestors are mentally ill (ie 99% of san francisco based protests).

Oh some idiot came on just now with a thread that's going to get deleted where he asks people ot sign petitions. That's even worse then writing emails! You barely have to write 2 words down. Petitions filed should require automatic arrest of hte petitioners. It's pathetic.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top