A question regarding Special Relativity.

  • Thread starter JPBenowitz
  • Start date
  • #1
144
2
Suppose there is a rocket that is traveling at a constant .9c starting at an initial position x1 and fires a photon every second to observers on earth. (Observers on earth do not know the velocity of the rocket)

If 1s is the proper time [itex]\Delta[/itex][itex]\tau[/itex] then the time passed on earth between each photon being fired would be [itex]\gamma[/itex] or 2.29416s. Then dependent on the initial position x1 the time between each measured photon on earth would be the time for each photon to travel the distance d from each position x at every 2.29416s? From measuring the time between each photon that reaches earth you could calculate the positions x2...xn. But you would only be able to know the positions of where the rocket was not where it is presently.

Assuming I understand the above, how would someone go about by calculating the positions if the rocket is accelerating?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
144
2
Suppose there is a rocket that is traveling at a constant .9c starting at an initial position x1 and fires a photon every second to observers on earth. (Observers on earth do not know the velocity of the rocket)

If 1s is the proper time [itex]\Delta[/itex][itex]\tau[/itex] then the time passed on earth between each photon being fired would be [itex]\gamma[/itex] or 2.29416s. Then dependent on the initial position x1 the time between each measured photon on earth would be the time for each photon to travel the distance d from each position x at every 2.29416s? From measuring the time between each photon that reaches earth you could calculate the positions x2...xn. But you would only be able to know the positions of where the rocket was not where it is presently.

Assuming I understand the above, how would someone go about by calculating the positions if the rocket is accelerating?
Wait a minute, if the rocket is accelerating then [itex]\Delta[/itex]t and [itex]\Delta\tau[/itex] would be changing but the observers on earth wouldn't be able to determine the relativistic time because it would be an element of the time it takes the photon to travel to earth.
 
  • #3
Dale
Mentor
Insights Author
2020 Award
30,866
7,474
But you would only be able to know the positions of where the rocket was not where it is presently.
Yes. That is always true.
 
  • #4
ghwellsjr
Science Advisor
Gold Member
5,122
147
Suppose there is a rocket that is traveling at a constant .9c starting at an initial position x1 and fires a photon every second to observers on earth. (Observers on earth do not know the velocity of the rocket)

If 1s is the proper time [itex]\Delta[/itex][itex]\tau[/itex] then the time passed on earth between each photon being fired would be [itex]\gamma[/itex] or 2.29416s. Then dependent on the initial position x1 the time between each measured photon on earth would be the time for each photon to travel the distance d from each position x at every 2.29416s? From measuring the time between each photon that reaches earth you could calculate the positions x2...xn. But you would only be able to know the positions of where the rocket was not where it is presently.

Assuming I understand the above, how would someone go about by calculating the positions if the rocket is accelerating?
You are right, the time observed from earth of the 1 photon per second coming from the rocket will take even longer than the 2.29416 seconds. It's easy to calculate using the Relativistic Doppler Factor which for comparing intervals for objects moving directly apart from each other is:

D = √[(1+β)/(1-β)]

For β = 0.9
D = √[(1+0.9)/(1-0.9)]
D = √[(1.9)/(0.1)]
D = √19
D = 4.3589

That means as long as the rocket travels at the constant speed of 0.9c away from earth and continues to send out a photon every second, earth will receive them every 4.3589 seconds.

Now with a little algebra, you can turn the above formula around to calculate β if you know D:

β = |(1 - D2) / (1 + D2)|

So let's see if this works:

D = 4.3589
β = |(1 - D2) / (1 + D2)|
β = |(1 - 4.35892) / (1 + 4.35892)|
β = |(1 - 19) / (1 + 19)|
β = |-18/20|
β = |-0.9|
β = 0.9

So now we know how to determine the delayed speed of the rocket as it accelerates. If we wanted to keep track of the change in position just by looking at the Doppler Shift Periods, we could integrate the calculated speed measured as each photon was received.
 
Last edited:

Related Threads on A question regarding Special Relativity.

Replies
12
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
927
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
9
Views
2K
Top