About the preimage of a compact set

  • Thread starter sapporozoe
  • Start date
  • #1
12
0
If f from R to R is continuous, does it then follow that the pre-image of the closed unit interval [0,1] is compact?

-At first I thought of a counterexample like f=sinx but it seems that its range is not R. So will the answer be yes? And how can we prove it? Will the preimage have to be bounded in this case?

Thanks.
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
176
0
false, take f=1 for all x in R.
then preimage of the closed unit interval is R which is not compact.
 
  • #3
12
0
but...

but the range of this f is not R, is it?

false, take f=1 for all x in R.
then preimage of the closed unit interval is R which is not compact.
 
  • #4
Hurkyl
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
14,950
19
The range of a function is not necessarily the same as its image.

(But it's easy enough to modify yours, or SiddharthM's, suggestion so that the image of the function really is all of R)
 
  • #5
176
0
you mean if f is ONTO R?. how about f(x)=xsinx, the preimage of the closed unit interval here isn't bounded! So by heineborel it isn't compact.
 
  • #6
12
0
great! thanks...

you mean if f is ONTO R?. how about f(x)=xsinx, the preimage of the closed unit interval here isn't bounded! So by heineborel it isn't compact.
 
  • #7
12
0
thank you. but do we usually take Rn as the domain and Rm as the range when we say "f is from Rn to Rm"? I am a bit confused about this...

The range of a function is not necessarily the same as its image.

(But it's easy enough to modify yours, or SiddharthM's, suggestion so that the image of the function really is all of R)
 
  • #8
Hurkyl
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
14,950
19
f(x) = 0 is a perfectly good definition for a function from R to R.

But the image of this function is the set {0}.
 
  • #9
12
0
Thanks for your patience:). But the following example tells my confusion...

Perhaps we are familiar with a statement like this:"if f:Rn to Rm is continuous and B in Rn is bounded, then f(B) is Rm is bounded". We know that boundedness is not preserved under continuous mapping. But this statement is true in that Rn is its domain... So I am confused about the exact meaning "f is Rn to Rm".


f(x) = 0 is a perfectly good definition for a function from R to R.

But the image of this function is the set {0}.
 
  • #10
Hurkyl
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
14,950
19
We know that boundedness is not preserved under continuous mapping.
There exist continuous functions that don't preserve boundedness. That doesn't imply all continuous functions don't preserve boundedness.

In the case you cited, the theorem follows from the fact that continuous maps preserve compactness. (And the properties of Euclidean space)

I'm not sure why you think this relates to the notion of range, though.
 
  • #11
12
0
when i wrote down the previous post, i was worried whether i made my question clear:)

The statement is true because we exclude cases like: f(x)=tanx, x in (-pi/2, pi/2). We can exclude such cases as we require the domain of f(x) is Rn.

So my question becomes: if we say "f is from Rn to Rm", do we mean "the domain of f is Rn but the range of f is a subset of Rm"?

Thanks again:)
 
  • #12
Hurkyl
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
14,950
19
when i wrote down the previous post, i was worried whether i made my question clear:)

The statement is true because we exclude cases like: f(x)=tanx, x in (-pi/2, pi/2). We can exclude such cases as we require the domain of f(x) is Rn.

So my question becomes: if we say "f is from Rn to Rm", do we mean "the domain of f is Rn but the range of f is a subset of Rm"?

Thanks again:)

I have seen the word "range" used in two different ways:
(1) The target of a function. (Rm, for your example)
(2) The image of a function. (f(Rn), in your example)


It appears to me like your issue is entirely due to mixing up the two usages of the word "range".


(the target is also called the codomain)
 
  • #13
176
0
look at the definition of a ONTO or SURJECTIVE function (these two capitalized words mean the same thing). When a function's domain and range are specified it only means that a function is a rule that assigns to each value in the domain ONE value from the range. The IMAGE of the ENTIRE domain can still be a proper subset of the range. A ONTO function is one where the image of the domain is the ENTIRE range.
 
  • #14
12
0
i almost get it:) Thanks.
 
  • #15
mathwonk
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
2020 Award
11,267
1,470
you are stumbling around over the trivial part of the topic, i.e. the domain and range.

the interesting part is: when is the preimage of a compact set compact? continuos functions with this property are called proper and are very important.
 

Related Threads on About the preimage of a compact set

  • Last Post
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
6K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
10
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
15K
Top