Affordable Alternatives to Silver Solder for Heating Element Joining

AI Thread Summary
Using silver solder for joining heating elements on copper pipes can be costly, prompting the search for more economical alternatives. Tin-copper solder, commonly used in electronics, offers a lower-cost solution with a melting point around 200°C, while the now-banned tin-lead solder was previously favored for its effectiveness. Clean surfaces and appropriate flux are crucial for successful soldering. For applications requiring lower temperatures (up to 150°C), mechanical connections with thermal paste can be effective, provided surfaces are well-matched and securely pressed. Standard 95/5 plumbing solder is suitable for lower pressure and temperature applications, while silver solder remains necessary for high-pressure refrigerants like R-410a due to its superior performance. Despite the high costs, the need for reliable connections in high-temperature environments continues to drive the use of silver solder.
math111
Messages
42
Reaction score
0
Right now I am using silver solder to combine heating elements on a copper pipe. This is becoming very expensive. Any other means/materials I could use that could get the similar results as the silver without the high cost!
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Silver solder resists higher temperatures. If you don't need them, just take tin-copper solder used for electronics presently, or the better tin-lead that was used previously (forbidden in Europe now). Their melting point is like +200°C and +180°C. Clean surfaces and good flux are important.

Available from plumbers and their shops.

Other compositions exist(ed) which I haven't used, like cadmium. Must be forbidden in Europe meanwhile.

At maximum +150°C, you can make a mechanical contact, with thermal paste between the parts. Press seriously with screws the precisely matched surfaces.
 
As a plumber, we use standard 95/5 plumbing solder (available at home centers and plumbing supply houses). It is used on water and heating copper with pressures below 125 PSI and temps below 210 deg F.

For pressures and temps above those levels we use Silver Solder. And yes Silver Solder is expensive. I do HVAC work and it is the only approved joining material for R-410a refrigerant due to the high pressures.
 
Thanks for the replies. The fin heaters we use get pretty hot with the amount of 1 to 6 Kw supplied quickly passing 212F+. I'll keep at it I guess. Lead is good but needed major protection so I am sure it will not be the best bet.
 
Back
Top