Airplane Landing Questions -- How can the pilot see the ground?

  • Thread starter seazal
  • Start date
119
3
The most nervous moments for me is during airplane landing when I'm concerned if the plane would just stall or hit the concrete so hard. So let me take this opportunity to understand it.

How many commercial airliners use manual and automatic landing technology (in terms of percentage)?

For manual. During landing the nose is pointed up, so how can the pilot sees the ground ahead? Do they just guess how many distances to the ground?

Or do they depend on altimeter? Are these so sensitive it can differentiate between 2 meters or 3 meters? Does it work by measuring the force of gravity or air pressure?

For automatic landing, the angle and descent speed is decided by computers? I remember in Die Hard 3, the height was modified by computer and it crash landed. I can remember the part during every landing giving me some kind of landing phobia.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

jrmichler

Science Advisor
923
822
The process of landing starts several miles before the runway. The pilot slows the airplane to the proper speed, puts the landing gear down, puts the flaps down, and lines up with the runway. A typical speed when getting close to the runway is 30% faster than stall speed, or a little faster in rough conditions. They fly a prescribed slope. In good weather, there are visual indicators in addition to knowing the proper sight picture. In bad weather, they have an electronic glide slope.

All airplanes, from a two seat Cessna to a huge Airbus A380, fly the same slope, although at different speeds.

upload_2018-12-27_18-9-34.png


In modern airplanes, the pilot can see the runway ahead when flaring for a landing. That was not the case for many pre World War II small airplanes, where the pilot needed to have good peripheral vision and situational awareness.
 

Attachments

berkeman

Mentor
55,934
5,980

rcgldr

Homework Helper
8,604
493
Large commercial aircraft have an altitude call out system that uses a radar altimeter to call out the height above the runway during the final phase of landing approach.

All airplanes, from a two seat Cessna to a huge Airbus A380, fly the same slope, although at different speeds.
Not always, at some airports, such as John Wayne in Orange County California, the smaller aircraft use a steeper slope on approach to avoid any wake turbulence left behind by a large aircraft landing on the adjacent runway.
 
119
3
About a decade ago. I rode an airplane where inches away from touchdown, it took off again with full afterburners (?) on, what situation calls for such emergency take off during landing?

I remembered a china airliner where the same thing happened but it didn't have enough power to take off again after near landing, it just dropped and exploded killing all on broad.

What phase of airplane riding are you concerned the most? Or do you just avoid riding airliner?
 

jrmichler

Science Advisor
923
822
what situation calls for such emergency take off during landing?
It's not an emergency, it's a "go-around". I had to go around once when another airplane pulled onto the runway when I was on short final. It was not dangerous, I was at flying speed in a faster airplane and the other plane was just starting from a dead stop. Fortunately, one of us was looking out the windshield.

Airline pilots are taught to go around if the approach is not fully stabilized. If they are a little fast or slow, a little high or low, a little off to one side, they are supposed to go around and get the airplane lined up better the next time.
 

russ_watters

Mentor
18,979
5,137
About a decade ago. I rode an airplane where inches away from touchdown, it took off again with full afterburners (?) on...
No, commercial airliners don't have afterburners. That was just full power.
What phase of airplane riding are you concerned the most? Or do you just avoid riding airliner?
I love flying and fly as much as I can (I'm currently taking lessons), so I don't get "concerned" in normal situations. But statistically the landing is the most dangerous:

phase_en.gif
 

Attachments

Klystron

Gold Member
497
566
The most nervous moments for me is during airplane landing when I'm concerned if the plane would just stall or hit the concrete so hard. So let me take this opportunity to understand it.
[snip]
What phase of airplane riding are you concerned the most? Or do you just avoid riding airliner?
Along with the excellent posts above consider the physics as an aircraft transitions from flight to a surface https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ground_effect_(aerodynamics)

Ground effects tend to cushion and support large aircraft so-to-speak, so relax and enjoy your flights. As the wiki article describes, entering ground effect gives pilots more effective lift and thrust control.
 
Last edited:

cjl

Science Advisor
1,754
343
No, commercial airliners don't have afterburners. That was just full power.
Yep, although full TO/GA power in a modern twin engine airliner certainly feels impressive, especially with the aircraft at a fairly light gross weight (as it usually is when landing)
 

russ_watters

Mentor
18,979
5,137
Yep, although full TO/GA power in a modern twin engine airliner certainly feels impressive, especially with the aircraft at a fairly light gross weight (as it usually is when landing)
Question: for a go-around, is that "full" as in full? I have trouble wrapping my head around the idea that (as I understand it), they do not apply full power at takeoff, but only as much power as is required for the conditions.
 

CWatters

Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
10,528
2,292
Just wanted to add..

Contrary to popular opinion landings in an airliner aren't meant to be some sort of soft floaty experience. Its meant to be reasonably "positive" or even "firm". Remember you cant use the wheel brakes while floating along with no weight on the wheels.

Aborted landings are nothing to fear. Whatever the reason I'm quite happy for a pilot to make a positive decision to go around and come back in 15mins. See it as a good thing. Last one that happened to me was due to a small thunder cloud lingering a bit too close to the airfield.

Decades ago planes flew a lot lower and you experience a lot more turbulence at low altitude. Almost every flight had some bumps, but you got used to it and didn't worry. These days planes fly much higher and turbulence is less frequent up there so people tend not to have experienced it much. They sometimes over react when it does occur. Old hands just pull their belt a bit tighter and order another Martini.

I flew gliders for several years and have had many flights in light aircraft, seaplanes, airliners and even one in an airship. I feel far safer in any of these than I do 6ft up a ladder.
 

cjl

Science Advisor
1,754
343
For a go-around, it would usually be full power, yes (with a couple minor caveats that "full power" is actually a software setting in the engine, and the exact same engine may have different "full power" settings depending on what airframe it's hung on and what use case the operator has). You'll see either a switch or a position on the throttles marked as TOGA or TO/GA (for Take Off/Go Around) on modern airliners, and if you're near the ground and have a reason to go around, you'll usually want as much extra energy as possible.

You're right about the takeoff too - derated takeoffs are very common because they save a lot of wear and tear on the engines. A slightly lower turbine inlet temperature really can extend the life of the hot section of the engine, and they still plan it to have plenty of margin for aborts if necessary.

Oh, and Cwatters, unless you're really rather ancient, chances are airline cruising altitudes are about the same as they've been for your whole life. Cruising altitudes have been in the ~28-40k ft range since about the DC-8/707/Convair 880, all of which entered service in the late 1950s. Weather forecasting and radar have gotten much better though, allowing airliners to more successfully navigate around turbulence, and airliner control systems have gotten a lot better at damping it out.
 
119
3
I read this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_Northern_Airlines_Flight_6901

"While on final approach, the autopilot automatically disconnected. The Captain proceeded to reengage it, believing that it would still be in APP mode. When activated however, the autopilot went into VERT SPD mode with a setting of -800 feet per minute. The crew's failure to disconnect the autopilot and manually land the airplane contributed to the accident. Another factor was the crew's lack of proficiency in English. When the GPWS issued an aural alarm, the captain asked his first officer what the words "Pull up" meant. The first officer replied that he did not know. Consequently, the pilots ignored the warnings and failed to correct their excessive rate of descent, causing the plane to strike power lines and a wall before coming down in a field".

Are there landings that uses autopilot?
What does APP mode and VERT SPD mode mean above?

Also doesn't airliner manufacturer change the language to the native's so the user can understand it?
 

cjl

Science Advisor
1,754
343
Yes, autolands are frequently done (and are very safe). APP mode is approach mode, used when the plane is approaching the runway. VERT SPD mode is vertical speed mode, which is designed to simply hold a given vertical speed (in this case, 800 feet per minute down). All air traffic control and airliner controls are done in english, even in non-English speaking countries by convention. This is done so international traffic can understand each other.
 

jim hardy

Science Advisor
Gold Member
2018 Award
Dearly Missed
9,813
4,875
The most nervous moments for me is during airplane landing when I'm concerned if the plane would just stall or hit the concrete so hard.
You've probably felt but were unaware of something called "Ground Effect"
when the plane gets about one wingspan above the ground, the air underneath it has to get squished out from under the wings
raising pressure on bottom side of the wings causing more lift.
Pilot will reduce power and raise the nose to increase drag and dump speed, encouraging the plane to continue on down to the ground..
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ground_effect_(aerodynamics)

Next time you fly
pick a window seat a row or two behind back edge of the wing.
Pay attention to what goes on as you get over the end of the runway-
As the plane descends toward the runway you'll see those big flaps move back and down changing the wing shape from flat to curved
trapping air underneath the wing as it gets ever closer to the runway.
On a warm humid summer day you'll see vapor trails curl around the flap edges as the air moves from high pressure region ahead of the flap to low pressure behind it, cooling as it goes...
Just watch and ask yourself "why" about everything you notice.

For manual. During landing the nose is pointed up, so how can the pilot sees the ground ahead?
He looks out the side window.

If you like aviation
i recommend reading Charles Lindbergh's "Spirit of St Louis"
he didn't have a forward view at all , only side windows...
the 1956 movie starring James Stewart is also very good, and is on Netflix
 

Klystron

Gold Member
497
566
The term autopilot seems slightly naive on an I-level thread. The old stick and rudder flight controls nearly all channel through sophisticated avionics; so-called fly by wire. Most landing checklists I've seen describe gradual steps and procedures with some inputs into and action taken by autopilot.

JFTR my experience includes 11 years of aerodynamic experiments at NASA wind tunnels then human factor studies using actual flight crews in full-motion flight simulators. The 12' wind tunnel for instance conducts scads of ground effect studies on any external mods to passenger planes. They test everything including runway surfaces, tire materials. The flight sims include actual ATC (air traffic control) operators using stored traffic but real voice commands to the flight crews.

Before that I was a radar jock at an international TRACON and other places. English is the official language of the skies but communication can be difficult particularly considering radio, weather, and background sounds. Saying the Captain 'spoke Chinese' says little about their mother tongue or ability to understand and speak English under stress. I tried to help this kind of problem on my next assignment designing speech networks.
 
Last edited:
119
3
You've probably felt but were unaware of something called "Ground Effect"
when the plane gets about one wingspan above the ground, the air underneath it has to get squished out from under the wings
raising pressure on bottom side of the wings causing more lift.
Pilot will reduce power and raise the nose to increase drag and dump speed, encouraging the plane to continue on down to the ground..
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ground_effect_(aerodynamics)

Next time you fly
pick a window seat a row or two behind back edge of the wing.
Pay attention to what goes on as you get over the end of the runway-
As the plane descends toward the runway you'll see those big flaps move back and down changing the wing shape from flat to curved
trapping air underneath the wing as it gets ever closer to the runway.
On a warm humid summer day you'll see vapor trails curl around the flap edges as the air moves from high pressure region ahead of the flap to low pressure behind it, cooling as it goes...
Just watch and ask yourself "why" about everything you notice.


He looks out the side window.

If you like aviation
i recommend reading Charles Lindbergh's "Spirit of St Louis"
he didn't have a forward view at all , only side windows...
the 1956 movie starring James Stewart is also very good, and is on Netflix
I never thought Airline pilot cabin has side windows too. Let's go to this Die Hard 2 scene which gives me phobia.


The conversations is "Activate the " " system, re calibrate sea level to minus -200 feet"

What is the " "? All airliners have it too? or just fiction?
 

jim hardy

Science Advisor
Gold Member
2018 Award
Dearly Missed
9,813
4,875
What is the " "?
ILS ? "Instrument Landing System"

a narrow, directional radio beam broadcast from the airport.
If the plane flies right along the beam it'll wind up at the end of the runway at correct altitude.

upload_2018-12-28_19-57-29.png



there's an indicator on the panel something akin to this
upload_2018-12-28_20-2-48.png


pilot flies the plane to keep the two needles in the circle
i tried it a time or two and decided it's a job for the autopilot...
 

Attachments

russ_watters

Mentor
18,979
5,137

jim hardy

Science Advisor
Gold Member
2018 Award
Dearly Missed
9,813
4,875
ps i hope that wasn't an in-fight movie.....
 
119
3
ILS ? "Instrument Landing System"

a narrow, directional radio beam broadcast from the airport.
If the plane flies right along the beam it'll wind up at the end of the runway at correct altitude.

View attachment 236505


there's an indicator on the panel something akin to this
View attachment 236506

pilot flies the plane to keep the two needles in the circle
i tried it a time or two and decided it's a job for the autopilot...
I'm reviewing all airliner crashes incidents at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_accidents_and_incidents_involving_airliners_by_location

I don't come across airplane that stalls and falls down during landing. The 30% above stall speed saves the day? But can't a suicidal pilot just adjusts the lever suddenly to below the stall speed during landing?
 

jim hardy

Science Advisor
Gold Member
2018 Award
Dearly Missed
9,813
4,875
I don't come across airplane that stalls and falls down during landing.
Airline disasters are always like dominoes - several little things align and something sets them in motion.

this has caused more than one stall
(annotations mine)

upload_2018-12-28_20-42-49.png


google "windshear"
Let's just say this guy's stall speed is 70
if pilot enters the storm with airspeed of 100
and headwind is 25
his ground speed is 75,
5 above stall. which sounds ok
but it's airspeed that makes lift not groundspeed.....
When he transitions from 25 headwind to 25 tailwind with ground speed still at 75
his airspeed falls to 50
so he's at 20 less than stall speed and is in trouble

http://www.aviation-accidents.net/tag/windshear/

If you're interested in aviation you might enjoy Ernest Gann's book "Fate is the Hunter"
a retired airline captain, he wrote his memoirs and discusses such things..
 

Attachments

Last edited:
119
3
Airline disasters are always like dominoes - several little things align and something sets them in motion.

this has caused more than one stall
(annotations mine)

View attachment 236508

google "windshear"

If you're interested in aviation you might enjoy Ernest Gann's book "Fate is the Hunter"
a retired airline captain, he wrote his memoirs and discusses such things..
Please suggest books that answer these questions directly:

Before the Wright Brothers, what were the theories why birds fly? When was the airfoil technology or principles first discovered? And why were the Wright Brothers the first one to successfully apply it?

I'm interesting in flight because I am wondering if something similar could occur in the future, where something akin to airfoil principles (analogy wise) can be used in the vacuum (biased by bohmian mechanics) so vacuaplane (instead of airplane) can use it to navigate the stars. References about such from NASA also welcomed.
 
119
3
Here is the hit list when I googled Pilot's View When Landing an Airplane:

https://www.google.com/search?q=pilot's+view+landing+an+airplane&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&client=firefox-b-1

That should help to put your mind at ease a bit, I hope. :smile:
I'm surprised the pilots can still see the ground during landing. Is it not the nose is pointed upwards so the pilots shouldn't see the ground. I guessed before they were all landing blind. But are there airplanes where they really land blind?
 

Related Threads for: Airplane Landing Questions -- How can the pilot see the ground?

  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
43
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
852
  • Last Post
Replies
10
Views
12K
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
26
Views
6K
Replies
2
Views
960
  • Last Post
Replies
7
Views
3K
Top